Advice. Who needs it? Well, you do. We all do. The Bible talks about finding wisdom in a multitude of counselors. But how do we get the advice and counsel we need? That is an important question. And the answer will impact your happiness.
For Christian leaders, one traditional source for advice has been the church board. The church board has also proved to be a good source of pain and suffering. Yes, you get the counsel you need. But you pay a high price for it. Is there a way to get counsel without the pain and suffering? Yes. Have your friends over for a barbeque. Yum. Let me explain.
You can get the advice you need formally, through a standing board or council, or informally, through an ad hoc group of friends. I say, get it ad hoc from friends. Just go to the people you respect and say, "I have a few things I've been thinking about and I'd like to bounce them off you. Are you free to come over for hamburgers Friday night?" In all likelihood, they will say yes, come over, give you some great advice, and go home. No fuss. No expectation of a "next meeting." No worries about a secretary, agenda, minutes, or quorums. No political posturing. No trying to get people on or off the board. No meetings before the meeting, or after the meeting. No misunderstandings about who is leading the church. Just good, simple feedback. And barbeque. Yum.
At CTK (a multi-site church) our governance structure is different than the traditional church. There is a Church Council that oversees me, and from there the accountability is mediated through the relationships of the pastors. It is a very clean and efficient form of governance, and one of the best things about pastoring in the CTK network. However, there is an option for pastors to appoint a Local Advisory Council for their Worship Center. This option is stated in our bylaws, but personally, I discourage pastors from taking this option for the reasons I'm outlining here. When people are given a "position" or a "title" they can get a little weird on you. They start to think that they should relate to you as a "board member" instead of as your "friend." Other people start to relate to them differently as well. They are approached by folks who say, "Hey, you're a board member! I need to talk with you about something!" Don't put yourself or these people through this. You don't have to. Just have a barbeque. Yum.
Another option you might consider is asking everyone. Yes, everyone. What if you explained what you were thinking at a weekend service, and asked people to write you a note to let you know what they thought? Or what if you invited the entire church to a meeting at which you shared the concern and asked people to brainstorm it with you. You might be surprised at who comes to this meeting, and the solutions they might provide. I have found this limited-term approach to be superior to a standing board or committee. It gives everyone a chance to influence you, instead of a select few. There are not "haves" and "have nots" when it comes to power. Anyone and everyone can be part of the process. All you need is a bigger barbeque. Yum.
Friday, September 21, 2007
Lasting
The CTK story has been messy, and sometimes we have not cleaned up very well after ourselves. Over the years, in addition to launching a couple dozen Worship Centers, we have also had a half dozen that haven't made it. We've wiped the tears from our eyes, and kept moving forward. But not everyone is as comfortable when things don't "last." I recently received an email in which someone inquired, "We see things happening in India and Africa....but how long will they last?" That is a very interesting question. My answer, of course, is the one in which I have become well-versed: "I don't know." Here's what I wrote in reply:
"As to how long things last, I have been quite surprised to see how long most of what we've done has lasted! But it's not one of my goals to make things "last." It is one of my goals to try to cooperate with God."
I would encourage us to not have as one of our goals to make something "last." That is language that fits better with institutional thinking than organic thinking. You want a machine to last. You want a plant to grow. We want to think of ourselves more like a plant than a machine.
A man told me recently about how he had transplanted a tree to his back yard. The tree did not do so well in its new environment. The leaves began to turn brown. The man was expecting company for a back yard BBQ. He wanted his tree to "last." So what did he do? He painted the leaves green with spray paint. Yup. Full-on impression management.
I am deathly afraid of institutionalism, when people become servants to the institution, instead of the institution serving the people. A good question to ask is, "What is being kept green?" Is it the organization, or the people in it?
One of the best ways for us to stave off institutionalism is to continue to be open to both the life and death of enterprises. Both life and death are part of the organic process. Frankly, one of the things that I find commendable about our story is how willing we are to close something if it is not "working." So far, I think we've shut down 6 or 7 Worship Centers, and we'll probably have several more before the story is over. We're not going to paint the leaves.
"As to how long things last, I have been quite surprised to see how long most of what we've done has lasted! But it's not one of my goals to make things "last." It is one of my goals to try to cooperate with God."
I would encourage us to not have as one of our goals to make something "last." That is language that fits better with institutional thinking than organic thinking. You want a machine to last. You want a plant to grow. We want to think of ourselves more like a plant than a machine.
A man told me recently about how he had transplanted a tree to his back yard. The tree did not do so well in its new environment. The leaves began to turn brown. The man was expecting company for a back yard BBQ. He wanted his tree to "last." So what did he do? He painted the leaves green with spray paint. Yup. Full-on impression management.
I am deathly afraid of institutionalism, when people become servants to the institution, instead of the institution serving the people. A good question to ask is, "What is being kept green?" Is it the organization, or the people in it?
One of the best ways for us to stave off institutionalism is to continue to be open to both the life and death of enterprises. Both life and death are part of the organic process. Frankly, one of the things that I find commendable about our story is how willing we are to close something if it is not "working." So far, I think we've shut down 6 or 7 Worship Centers, and we'll probably have several more before the story is over. We're not going to paint the leaves.
Results
It's not necessary to do extraordinary things to get extraordinary results. Warren Buffett has become one of the richest men in the world by being a disciplined investor - buying stock in good companies at good prices and watching the companies grow. Not really very complicated, but very effective. In a similar way, it is possible to have a very effective ministry by understanding the values of simplicity, focus, compounding interest and the laity.
The value of simplicity. Warren Buffett keeps it simple. He was heavily influenced by Franciscan Monk William of Occam who put forth the idea that the simplest explanation was usually the best explanation. Here's what Buffett has to say:
• The business schools reward difficult, complex behavior more than simple behavior, but simple behavior is more effective.
• There seems to be some perverse human characteristic that likes to make easy things difficult.
Today, church has become some complicated and difficult that you need to be a professional to do it. When you boil it down, it's really just about loving God and loving people.
The value of focus. Warren Buffett does not try to do everything. He does a few things well. He sticks with what he knows. Here's what Buffett has to say:
• I can't be involved in fifty or seventy-five things. That's a Noah's ark way of investing - you end up with a zoo that way. I like to put meaningful amounts of money in a few things.
• If we can't find things within our circle of competence, we don't expand the circle. We'll wait.
• Diversification is a protection against ignorance. It makes very little sense for those who know what they are doing.
• Why not invest your assets in the companies you really like? As Mae West said, "Too much of a good thing can be wonderful."
It is not very sexy to "stick to your knitting." But it can be pretty effective. CTK has been blessed by prioritizing "worship, small groups and outreach." We've put our investment in a few things that are life-changing and life-giving and it has paid off.
The value of compounding interest. Warren Buffett did not get rich over night. He believes you win with the running game, not the long-bomb. He invests for the long term. Here is what he says:
• You should invest like a Catholic marries - for life.
• Recommending something to be held for thirty years is a level of self-sacrifice you'll rarely see in a monastery, let alone a brokerage house.
• No matter how great the talent or effort, some things just take time: You can't produce a baby in one month by getting nine women pregnant.
Studies show that there is a correspondence between church growth and a pastor's tenure. It takes time to build a ministry and even more to set in motion a movement.
The value of the laity. Warren Buffett is the classic "everyman" - famed for driving around Omaha, Nebraska in an old Volkswagen Beetle. Buying a great business at a great price and holding it for twenty years is something anyone can do. Mary Buffet says,
• Every profession is a conspiracy against the laity....Priests of any profession need complexity to keep the laity from performing their priestly magic.
The "professionalization" of business has created the illusion that we need inside information or professionals to do it. People appreciate the fact that CTK is structured to allow the average person to have a ministry.
The value of simplicity. Warren Buffett keeps it simple. He was heavily influenced by Franciscan Monk William of Occam who put forth the idea that the simplest explanation was usually the best explanation. Here's what Buffett has to say:
• The business schools reward difficult, complex behavior more than simple behavior, but simple behavior is more effective.
• There seems to be some perverse human characteristic that likes to make easy things difficult.
Today, church has become some complicated and difficult that you need to be a professional to do it. When you boil it down, it's really just about loving God and loving people.
The value of focus. Warren Buffett does not try to do everything. He does a few things well. He sticks with what he knows. Here's what Buffett has to say:
• I can't be involved in fifty or seventy-five things. That's a Noah's ark way of investing - you end up with a zoo that way. I like to put meaningful amounts of money in a few things.
• If we can't find things within our circle of competence, we don't expand the circle. We'll wait.
• Diversification is a protection against ignorance. It makes very little sense for those who know what they are doing.
• Why not invest your assets in the companies you really like? As Mae West said, "Too much of a good thing can be wonderful."
It is not very sexy to "stick to your knitting." But it can be pretty effective. CTK has been blessed by prioritizing "worship, small groups and outreach." We've put our investment in a few things that are life-changing and life-giving and it has paid off.
The value of compounding interest. Warren Buffett did not get rich over night. He believes you win with the running game, not the long-bomb. He invests for the long term. Here is what he says:
• You should invest like a Catholic marries - for life.
• Recommending something to be held for thirty years is a level of self-sacrifice you'll rarely see in a monastery, let alone a brokerage house.
• No matter how great the talent or effort, some things just take time: You can't produce a baby in one month by getting nine women pregnant.
Studies show that there is a correspondence between church growth and a pastor's tenure. It takes time to build a ministry and even more to set in motion a movement.
The value of the laity. Warren Buffett is the classic "everyman" - famed for driving around Omaha, Nebraska in an old Volkswagen Beetle. Buying a great business at a great price and holding it for twenty years is something anyone can do. Mary Buffet says,
• Every profession is a conspiracy against the laity....Priests of any profession need complexity to keep the laity from performing their priestly magic.
The "professionalization" of business has created the illusion that we need inside information or professionals to do it. People appreciate the fact that CTK is structured to allow the average person to have a ministry.
Rhythm
When Michael Jordan “first” retired from basketball (he later “came back” ), commentators were philosophizing on his
retirement’s impact on the game of basketball, and the Chicago Bulls. The bigger story? The factors that led up to his stunning
decision to give up what he was doing, very, very successfully.
1. Physical fatigue. To understand what led to Jordan’s decision you had to go back to the previous off-season - an off-season
Jordan never had because he participated in the Olympic Games in Barcelona. When in the midst of a run of three NBA
championships, you don’t take time off, away from basketball, you are taking your battery down to zero. Perhaps Jordan chose
retirement because it was the only way he could envision ever recharging.
2. Emotional processing. In the previous three years, too many stressful things happened in Jordan’s life, with no time to really
process the magnitude of the events. No sooner had he won a championship, than they were talking about a repeat. Then
there was the Dream Team. Then there were gambling allegations. Then there was a three-peat. Then there was the death of
his father. Events of this magnitude take time for our souls to process. This was time Jordan never had.
3. No vision. By Jordan’s own admission, the fun left the game when his vision did. “There’s nothing left for me to accom-
plish.” When we lose sight of long-term goals and objectives our lives take on a treadmill effect. We keep running but we’re
not getting anywhere. Jordan finally said, “Stop the treadmill, I want to get off.”
4. Over-exposure. People who are not “in-fronters” probably don’t relate to the pressure of having your life scrutinized and, in
a sense, owned by the masses. This lack of privacy can be confining and restricting. The life of a public person is not his own.
Perhaps Jordan sensed that the only way to take by his private life was to no longer be a public person.
There is a syndrome that afflicts people who are in a place where they must give a lot of themselves to others. You don’t have
to play basketball to experience these factors that can lead you to want to throw in the towel. To face these factors without
retirement life must be lived rythmically. The mixture of the sabbath (six parts labor; one part rest) must be dutifully
maintained if we expect to stay in the game.
retirement’s impact on the game of basketball, and the Chicago Bulls. The bigger story? The factors that led up to his stunning
decision to give up what he was doing, very, very successfully.
1. Physical fatigue. To understand what led to Jordan’s decision you had to go back to the previous off-season - an off-season
Jordan never had because he participated in the Olympic Games in Barcelona. When in the midst of a run of three NBA
championships, you don’t take time off, away from basketball, you are taking your battery down to zero. Perhaps Jordan chose
retirement because it was the only way he could envision ever recharging.
2. Emotional processing. In the previous three years, too many stressful things happened in Jordan’s life, with no time to really
process the magnitude of the events. No sooner had he won a championship, than they were talking about a repeat. Then
there was the Dream Team. Then there were gambling allegations. Then there was a three-peat. Then there was the death of
his father. Events of this magnitude take time for our souls to process. This was time Jordan never had.
3. No vision. By Jordan’s own admission, the fun left the game when his vision did. “There’s nothing left for me to accom-
plish.” When we lose sight of long-term goals and objectives our lives take on a treadmill effect. We keep running but we’re
not getting anywhere. Jordan finally said, “Stop the treadmill, I want to get off.”
4. Over-exposure. People who are not “in-fronters” probably don’t relate to the pressure of having your life scrutinized and, in
a sense, owned by the masses. This lack of privacy can be confining and restricting. The life of a public person is not his own.
Perhaps Jordan sensed that the only way to take by his private life was to no longer be a public person.
There is a syndrome that afflicts people who are in a place where they must give a lot of themselves to others. You don’t have
to play basketball to experience these factors that can lead you to want to throw in the towel. To face these factors without
retirement life must be lived rythmically. The mixture of the sabbath (six parts labor; one part rest) must be dutifully
maintained if we expect to stay in the game.
Momentum
Momentum matters. It is an amplifier. When you have it, things feel like they are going better than they really are. When you don't have it, things feel like they are going worse than they really are.
What is momentum, and how do you get "mo" on your side? Scott Whitaker has a nice take on momentum. He says that momentum is:
Discomfort
Fed by Vision
Ignited by Anticipation
Led by Change
Momentum is born out of a healthy discomfort. Bill Hybels calls it a holy discontent. Momentum is born out of a discomfort of where you are and a knowledge of what could be. So if you have a dissatisfactory condition (maybe small groups are going as well as you'd like, or the worship experience has been inadequate, or fill in the blank) you have the right context for momentum.
Momentum is fed by vision. Vision is more than a suggested solution. Solutions may meet a temporary need. Vision is what constantly supplies the fuel to get you from where you are to where God wants you to be.
Momentum is ignited by anticipation. Anticipation is the first spark that moves someone from where they are to where they need to be. Anticipation is a desire for God to do something greater and expecting Him to do it. It is a transfer from the head (knowledge) to the heart (desire).
Momentum is led by change. You can't have momentum without some change. The status quo never causes momentum. And it can't just be change for the sake of change. It has to line up with and fulfill the discomfort, vision and anticipation.
Momentum is a ride that will come to an end. It is bound by the laws of physics. People will become comfortable with the familiar. An environment of momentum involves the unfamiliar. Which leads back to creating some sort of discomfort. If your people are comfortable you won't have momentum, you'll have complacency. You have to create some sort of discomfort and start the process all over.
------------
You can't experience momentum without anticipation. I have found that anticipation is a very important stage in the momentum cycle. It is most definitely the bridge between vision and change. Anticipation is so significant that it can give people a feeling of change before the change happens. Painting a picture of a preferable future is almost as good as being there sometimes. If you appropriately leverage momentum, you can enjoy the emotional benefits of improved conditions before they become reality. Let me give a couple examples from the CTK story:
No Kids Ministry in Mount Vernon
When we started CTK in Mount Vernon, we defied pretty much every rule of church planting. For instance, we had no kids ministry for the first few months. CTK actually grew to nearly 300 people without any nursery or children's classes. Talk about discomfort! We had it. But while we didn't have a kids ministry, we did have the anticipation of a kids ministry, and that was a suitable surrogate. I put a note in the program that said, "At CTK we believe that children are special and deserve special treatment. While we do not currently have a kids program, we want to develop a first-class ministry for kids to learn about Jesus and grow in their faith. Does this interest you? Would you like to be part of the team that develops this opportunity for kids? If so, please contact Dave Browning and let him know that you are praying." This little note cast vision and created anticipation. Shortly thereafter we had 20 people come to a meeting to organize a children's ministry and started changing the situation. Sometimes instead of building ministries, you first need to build anticipation of those ministries.
Tough Times in Burlington
When I stepped into the Burlington Worship Center I found a pretty demoralized group of people following a pastor's deceit and a church split. I took a few Sunday mornings with a white board and outlined some of the challenges, and then I started talking about what things would be like "a year from now." I talked about a church that wasn't focused on the past, but on the future. I talked about a church that was no longer concerned with the hurting people who were inside the church, but with the hurting people who were outside the church. I shared that one of the key words we would be working with within twelve months would be the word "fun." Even as I shared these ideas, I could feel the mood in the room change, almost as if we were already there. (Studies show that visualization can stimulate the brain in similar ways as the actual experience.) Now, a year later, we are "there." But the joy started to set in during the anticipation stage, before change was visible.
What is momentum, and how do you get "mo" on your side? Scott Whitaker has a nice take on momentum. He says that momentum is:
Discomfort
Fed by Vision
Ignited by Anticipation
Led by Change
Momentum is born out of a healthy discomfort. Bill Hybels calls it a holy discontent. Momentum is born out of a discomfort of where you are and a knowledge of what could be. So if you have a dissatisfactory condition (maybe small groups are going as well as you'd like, or the worship experience has been inadequate, or fill in the blank) you have the right context for momentum.
Momentum is fed by vision. Vision is more than a suggested solution. Solutions may meet a temporary need. Vision is what constantly supplies the fuel to get you from where you are to where God wants you to be.
Momentum is ignited by anticipation. Anticipation is the first spark that moves someone from where they are to where they need to be. Anticipation is a desire for God to do something greater and expecting Him to do it. It is a transfer from the head (knowledge) to the heart (desire).
Momentum is led by change. You can't have momentum without some change. The status quo never causes momentum. And it can't just be change for the sake of change. It has to line up with and fulfill the discomfort, vision and anticipation.
Momentum is a ride that will come to an end. It is bound by the laws of physics. People will become comfortable with the familiar. An environment of momentum involves the unfamiliar. Which leads back to creating some sort of discomfort. If your people are comfortable you won't have momentum, you'll have complacency. You have to create some sort of discomfort and start the process all over.
------------
You can't experience momentum without anticipation. I have found that anticipation is a very important stage in the momentum cycle. It is most definitely the bridge between vision and change. Anticipation is so significant that it can give people a feeling of change before the change happens. Painting a picture of a preferable future is almost as good as being there sometimes. If you appropriately leverage momentum, you can enjoy the emotional benefits of improved conditions before they become reality. Let me give a couple examples from the CTK story:
No Kids Ministry in Mount Vernon
When we started CTK in Mount Vernon, we defied pretty much every rule of church planting. For instance, we had no kids ministry for the first few months. CTK actually grew to nearly 300 people without any nursery or children's classes. Talk about discomfort! We had it. But while we didn't have a kids ministry, we did have the anticipation of a kids ministry, and that was a suitable surrogate. I put a note in the program that said, "At CTK we believe that children are special and deserve special treatment. While we do not currently have a kids program, we want to develop a first-class ministry for kids to learn about Jesus and grow in their faith. Does this interest you? Would you like to be part of the team that develops this opportunity for kids? If so, please contact Dave Browning and let him know that you are praying." This little note cast vision and created anticipation. Shortly thereafter we had 20 people come to a meeting to organize a children's ministry and started changing the situation. Sometimes instead of building ministries, you first need to build anticipation of those ministries.
Tough Times in Burlington
When I stepped into the Burlington Worship Center I found a pretty demoralized group of people following a pastor's deceit and a church split. I took a few Sunday mornings with a white board and outlined some of the challenges, and then I started talking about what things would be like "a year from now." I talked about a church that wasn't focused on the past, but on the future. I talked about a church that was no longer concerned with the hurting people who were inside the church, but with the hurting people who were outside the church. I shared that one of the key words we would be working with within twelve months would be the word "fun." Even as I shared these ideas, I could feel the mood in the room change, almost as if we were already there. (Studies show that visualization can stimulate the brain in similar ways as the actual experience.) Now, a year later, we are "there." But the joy started to set in during the anticipation stage, before change was visible.
Northwest
I've been thinking lately about how our story got started in the northwest (sometimes called "the fourth corner"). It seems to me that God always has his reasons for places (no one can deny that in the much-bigger story Bethlehem, Nazareth and Jerusalem are the geographical centers). So why northwest Washington?
1. An intensely unchurched region. I believe that what God wants to do through CTK is reach out to unchurched people in love, acceptance and forgiveness. This is not about establishing another church or denomination. This is about a move of God that will sweep tens of thousands of lost people into His kingdom. Because we got our start in the most unchurched state in the country we have never had the luxury of building our ministry around pre-processed Christians. We have had to reach out to the lost.
2. Out of the loop. The way that we are going about outreach is quite different from the "traditional" church. Fortunately for our story, we have been out of the loop, and very minimally impacted by what is going on in the rest of the church. Christian singers and authors seldom come our way. In some ways being off the beaten path has been good for us. We have had our heads down in the book, trying to figure out how to do church in a Kingdom way, organically and relationally.
3. The world is our neighbor. What do Microsoft, Boeing, Starbucks, Amazon, World Vision and UPS have in common? They all have a global reach, and they all got their start in the Puget Sound. Is there something in the water here? No, but there is a sense, with apologies to Alaska, that we are "the last frontier." There is an entrepreneurial spirit here that thinks in a boundary-less way (you even see this in the "Seattle scene" music - Jimi Hendrix, Curt Cobain, et al). We have an ocean to our west. We have another country to our north. And if we go east, we have to traverse a broad expanse of wilderness to find the next population center. Once you realize that you have to go a ways to go somewhere, you're next thought is, "Why not go all the way?" At least that has been our thought process at CTK.
4. Organic is us. The northwest is "green," home to thousands of people who are pursuing a simpler, more organic lifestyle. At CTK we have translated these post-modern/pre-modern notions to the church. We are looking to Acts 2 for inspiration. Our grand experiment is to see if what God did there and then, can be done again here and now ("house to house and in the temple courts"). Our modus operandi is to see the church grow organically through relationships, instead of attractionally through programming.
1. An intensely unchurched region. I believe that what God wants to do through CTK is reach out to unchurched people in love, acceptance and forgiveness. This is not about establishing another church or denomination. This is about a move of God that will sweep tens of thousands of lost people into His kingdom. Because we got our start in the most unchurched state in the country we have never had the luxury of building our ministry around pre-processed Christians. We have had to reach out to the lost.
2. Out of the loop. The way that we are going about outreach is quite different from the "traditional" church. Fortunately for our story, we have been out of the loop, and very minimally impacted by what is going on in the rest of the church. Christian singers and authors seldom come our way. In some ways being off the beaten path has been good for us. We have had our heads down in the book, trying to figure out how to do church in a Kingdom way, organically and relationally.
3. The world is our neighbor. What do Microsoft, Boeing, Starbucks, Amazon, World Vision and UPS have in common? They all have a global reach, and they all got their start in the Puget Sound. Is there something in the water here? No, but there is a sense, with apologies to Alaska, that we are "the last frontier." There is an entrepreneurial spirit here that thinks in a boundary-less way (you even see this in the "Seattle scene" music - Jimi Hendrix, Curt Cobain, et al). We have an ocean to our west. We have another country to our north. And if we go east, we have to traverse a broad expanse of wilderness to find the next population center. Once you realize that you have to go a ways to go somewhere, you're next thought is, "Why not go all the way?" At least that has been our thought process at CTK.
4. Organic is us. The northwest is "green," home to thousands of people who are pursuing a simpler, more organic lifestyle. At CTK we have translated these post-modern/pre-modern notions to the church. We are looking to Acts 2 for inspiration. Our grand experiment is to see if what God did there and then, can be done again here and now ("house to house and in the temple courts"). Our modus operandi is to see the church grow organically through relationships, instead of attractionally through programming.
Faith
Faith or fear. These appear to be the options, for you individually, and for Christ the King Community Church as a whole. In life, these are the two different driving forces. There is an invisible line that divides them. One of the greater decisions a church can make is deciding which side of the line they want to be on.
On the fear side you take a defensive posture. You view people as potential threats. You spend a great deal of energy preventing the worst. You put in place a lot of policies and protocol to keep bad things from happening to good people.
On the faith side you take an offensive posture. You view people as the prize. You spend a lot of energy promoting the best. You put in place a lot of leaders to make sure good things are happening to bad people.
You know when you are on the fear side of the line when you keep hearing words like no, accountability, process and authority. You know when you are on the faith side of the line when you keep hearing words like yes, support, story and empowerment.
Every ministry must pick a side. At CTK we have made a decision to walk in faith, instead of fear. We have decided to not put the energy of our organization into protecting ourselves. Instead we have decided to put the bulk of energies into reaching out, knowing that we will have to be responsive to messes as they occur (which they most certainly will). This decision – to be responsive instead of protective – frees up significant time and energy for the mission.
In 1999, on the 10th year anniversary of the “original” CTK (in Bellingham, Washington) I stood up in a staff meeting and commended the founding pastor, Steve Mason. I said, “Steve, you have been a remarkable leader. I think most people are impressed by your faith in God. But what impresses me is you faith in people. Believing in people takes way more faith than believing in God.”
Has Steve’s faith in God and people paid off? I’d say so.
The same year that I made that statement, 1999, CTK in Bellingham “launched” CTK in Skagit Valley (now CTK International). In the last 8 years, CTK has gone from one location to a mini-movement, with locations in a number of counties, states and countries. Today tens of thousands of people are walking in the same grace that I experienced.
One of the questions I routinely get is, “With so many small groups and Worship Centers out there, how will you find out if people are teaching false doctrine, or straying morally?” The answer is simple: “People love to tattle.” How did Paul find out about the moral dysfunction at Corinth? It was reported to him. We don’t need to go looking for trouble for it to appear. Years ago, when we had a small group go “sideways” theologically, someone in the group placed a call to me almost immediately and let me know what was being espoused. I was able to deal immediately with the error, and “cut out the cancer.”
While we can’t prevent bad things from happening, we can be responsive to issues as they arise, and we anticipate that they will arise. We subscribe to the “2% rule.” The 2% rule says that out of every 100 groups we start, two will go sideways in a big way. This is based on our actual experience. Out of the first 100 small groups we started, 2 of them went sideways; one theologically, and one relationally. Knowing the 2% rule, we face choices as a church. Do we a) invest our efforts into trying to prevent the 2% from happening through extensive reporting and meetings (in which the 2% will still happen – we’ve just burned up a lot of energy trying to stop it), or do we b) put our efforts into reaching out, but prepare ourselves mentally and spiritually for dealing swiftly, truthfully and gracefully with issues as they arise? At CTK we have chosen b). Instead of organizing to keep the 2% from happening, we have chosen to put our energies into reaching out. As a friend of mine likes to say, “If you use your hands to cover your butt, it doesn’t leave you any hands to do the work.”
I have found that by trusting people until they prove themselves unworthy of that trust, a lot more happens.
Jim Burke
I bring you the gift of these four words: I believe in you.
Blaise Pascal
Even an overdose of trust that, at time, involves the risk of being deceived or disappointed is wiser, in the long run, than taking fro granted that most people are incompetent or insincere.
Warren Bennis
It is better to trust and sometimes be disappointed than to be forever mistrusting and be right occasionally.
Neil Maxwell
Trust brings out the best in people and literally changes the dynamics of interaction. While it is true that a few abuse this trust, the vast, vast majority of people do not abuse it, but respond amazingly well to it. And when they do, they don’t need external supervision, control, or the “carrot and stick” approach to motivation. They are inspired. They run with the trust they were extended. They want to live up to it. They want to give back.
Stephen M.R. Covey
Better trust all and be deceived,
And weep that trust, and that deceiving,
Than doubt one heart that, if believed
Had blessed one’s life with true believing.
Frances Anne Kemble
It is happier to be sometimes cheated than not to trust.
Samuel Smiles
On the fear side you take a defensive posture. You view people as potential threats. You spend a great deal of energy preventing the worst. You put in place a lot of policies and protocol to keep bad things from happening to good people.
On the faith side you take an offensive posture. You view people as the prize. You spend a lot of energy promoting the best. You put in place a lot of leaders to make sure good things are happening to bad people.
You know when you are on the fear side of the line when you keep hearing words like no, accountability, process and authority. You know when you are on the faith side of the line when you keep hearing words like yes, support, story and empowerment.
Every ministry must pick a side. At CTK we have made a decision to walk in faith, instead of fear. We have decided to not put the energy of our organization into protecting ourselves. Instead we have decided to put the bulk of energies into reaching out, knowing that we will have to be responsive to messes as they occur (which they most certainly will). This decision – to be responsive instead of protective – frees up significant time and energy for the mission.
In 1999, on the 10th year anniversary of the “original” CTK (in Bellingham, Washington) I stood up in a staff meeting and commended the founding pastor, Steve Mason. I said, “Steve, you have been a remarkable leader. I think most people are impressed by your faith in God. But what impresses me is you faith in people. Believing in people takes way more faith than believing in God.”
Has Steve’s faith in God and people paid off? I’d say so.
The same year that I made that statement, 1999, CTK in Bellingham “launched” CTK in Skagit Valley (now CTK International). In the last 8 years, CTK has gone from one location to a mini-movement, with locations in a number of counties, states and countries. Today tens of thousands of people are walking in the same grace that I experienced.
One of the questions I routinely get is, “With so many small groups and Worship Centers out there, how will you find out if people are teaching false doctrine, or straying morally?” The answer is simple: “People love to tattle.” How did Paul find out about the moral dysfunction at Corinth? It was reported to him. We don’t need to go looking for trouble for it to appear. Years ago, when we had a small group go “sideways” theologically, someone in the group placed a call to me almost immediately and let me know what was being espoused. I was able to deal immediately with the error, and “cut out the cancer.”
While we can’t prevent bad things from happening, we can be responsive to issues as they arise, and we anticipate that they will arise. We subscribe to the “2% rule.” The 2% rule says that out of every 100 groups we start, two will go sideways in a big way. This is based on our actual experience. Out of the first 100 small groups we started, 2 of them went sideways; one theologically, and one relationally. Knowing the 2% rule, we face choices as a church. Do we a) invest our efforts into trying to prevent the 2% from happening through extensive reporting and meetings (in which the 2% will still happen – we’ve just burned up a lot of energy trying to stop it), or do we b) put our efforts into reaching out, but prepare ourselves mentally and spiritually for dealing swiftly, truthfully and gracefully with issues as they arise? At CTK we have chosen b). Instead of organizing to keep the 2% from happening, we have chosen to put our energies into reaching out. As a friend of mine likes to say, “If you use your hands to cover your butt, it doesn’t leave you any hands to do the work.”
I have found that by trusting people until they prove themselves unworthy of that trust, a lot more happens.
Jim Burke
I bring you the gift of these four words: I believe in you.
Blaise Pascal
Even an overdose of trust that, at time, involves the risk of being deceived or disappointed is wiser, in the long run, than taking fro granted that most people are incompetent or insincere.
Warren Bennis
It is better to trust and sometimes be disappointed than to be forever mistrusting and be right occasionally.
Neil Maxwell
Trust brings out the best in people and literally changes the dynamics of interaction. While it is true that a few abuse this trust, the vast, vast majority of people do not abuse it, but respond amazingly well to it. And when they do, they don’t need external supervision, control, or the “carrot and stick” approach to motivation. They are inspired. They run with the trust they were extended. They want to live up to it. They want to give back.
Stephen M.R. Covey
Better trust all and be deceived,
And weep that trust, and that deceiving,
Than doubt one heart that, if believed
Had blessed one’s life with true believing.
Frances Anne Kemble
It is happier to be sometimes cheated than not to trust.
Samuel Smiles
Middle
After talking with her sister, my wife Kristyn asked me if I had heard about the "Extremely Focused Church" conference in Colorado (her sister was going to it). I told her I hadn't heard about it. After some research I realized she was talking about the "Externally Focused Church" conference (which I had heard about). But of the two conference names (one made up; one real) I like the sounds of the Extremely Focused Church conference better, and that's saying a lot, because the idea of being externally focused really resonates with me.
There is something to be said for being extreme. The old "bell curve" theory implied that the place to be was somewhere in the middle. The middle may be where most are, but it is not the place to be, particularly in ministry. The "bell curve" proves to actually be a "well curve." The middle is not the high point, but the low point. The extremes are the high points. The middle is a tar pit.
Wherever you end up, don't end up in the middle. Where is the worst place to be assigned a seat on an airplane? The dreaded middle seat. What is the worst kind of drink you can be served? The room-temperature, luke-warm, "spew-you-out-of-my-mouth" one. It is much better to be either inside or outside, hot or cold. And better to be either small or big. The medium sized church, once prized, is now not big enough for impact, or small enough for intimacy. There is no emotional strength in being in between.
Leonard Sweet explores this mental model a little bit in his book The Gospel According to Starbucks. He says that one of the keys to Starbucks success is its gravitation toward an extreme experience: extremely comfortable, extremely tasty, extremely hot. Maxwell House, on the other hand, is stuck in the middle. But today, the middles are in trouble, while the edges and extremes are vital. The days of the happy medium (related word: mediocre) are gone. Ideas that are dead or dying include middle-ground, mid-management, middle-class, as well as mainline denominations. Both ends now play against the middle in what Sweet calls "an hourglass society."
Examples of the shrinking middle abound:
• The popularity of extreme sports and entertainment.
• The rise in sales of either very big TVs, or very small TVs (and severe decline in the sale of mid-sized ones).
• Release of more automobiles of the extremely small and big varieties, and the decline in popularity of mid-sized vehicles.
• Organizations getting either bigger through acquisitions and merger or smaller through spin offs.
• Portion sizes at restaurants getting bigger, or else smaller.
How do these developments apply to your ministry?
------------
Balance is a biblical idea. For example, it was said of Jesus that He was "full of grace and truth." So there is a need for Christ-followers to stay in balance. But my thoughts about how to achieve this balance have evolved over the last few years. I used to think that you achieve balance by heading toward the middle. Now I realize that balance can be achieved in one of two ways; 1) by heading toward the middle, or 2) by counterbalancing on the edges. For instance, you can balance a teeter totter by coming to the middle of it and straddling the fulcrum, or by having equivalent weight applied to each end of the board. Of the two approaches, I like "balance by extreme."
An example of where "balance by extremes" might serve you well is in the area of worship. For example, if the extremes are "rockin' worship" on one end of the teeter-totter, and "old-time hymns" on the other, you might be better to do an extreme version of each in a service (really rock out, and really sign a hymn) than to try to put the two in a blender and come out with something that doesn't give you the taste of either. I know from experience that "blended" worship is not very tasty.
Group life is another one of the areas where I don't think you can go part-way and be successful. If you are going to make your ministry about relationships, then really make your ministry about relationships. Don't dabble here, or go half-way. Stick with your emphasis on small groups, and keep reaching out relationally. You can't "kind of" make small groups a priority. You have to make small groups your nearly exclusive activity. You have to go to extremes.
-------------
Part of CTK's appeal is that you will often find us at both ends of the teeter-totter. We've reached a balance by being extremely graceful and truthful, not by being slightly both. We've been engaging because our services present bleeding-edge music, with old-fashioned Biblical teaching. We've achieve impact by being extremely big as a network, and small as individual groups and centers, instead of a church that is somewhere in between, both, or neither. We've expanded rapidly by simultaneously strengthening the core of our mission, visions and values and expanding the frontier into new communities.
-------------
As a basketball official I can tell you that the worst angle from which to see the play is the middle of the key, right under the basket. You are much better off to get a "wide angle" toward the the corner of the court. In fact, officials are taught to imagine the area below the basket as "quicksand." You don't want to find yourself there, and if you do, you want to get through it as quickly as possible. Likewise in your ministry, don't get caught in the quick-sand of middle-ground. Go to extremes.
--------------
From Leonard Sweet, The Gospel According to Starbucks:
One example of how to bring the ends together in a well-curve work, and the benefits of a simultaneous engagement of both ends of the continuum, is the competing food habits of indulgence and wellness. "Contradictory consumers" are going in opposite directions at the same time. We go from Ben & Jerry's Ice Cream or Krispy Kreme Donuts to the organic salad bar or raw juice bar....
We live in a Godiva culture of indulgence layered upon indulgence lathered with a whipped-cream topping of guilty pleasures and a final red cherry of repentance. This is also a culture obsessed with weight and health consciousness. We have the highest obesity rates in the world, and eating disorders run rampant. How do you bring these "dueling extremes" of death-by-chocolates and squeaky-clean foods together?
The blended, cut-to-the-middle solution of the bell-curve world was to introduce low-cal, low-far chocolate. That didn't work. Why eat chocolate if you can't enjoy the fat-drenched flavor of decadence? People want the experience of luxurious chocolate. They don't want halfway, diluted experiences of chocolate. But they also want a responsible weight-management program, one that can make a difference and not just create delusions of health.
The key is to offer consumers two opposite experiences at the same time. Hence portion-controlled chocolates. Nestle's Butterfinger Stixx and Hershey's Sticks offer the binge experience of chocolate in a way that doesn't adversely impact the body. Hershey's Sticks, with a tagline promising a "convenient guilt-free way to indulge in chocolate," is available in an eleven-gram, sixty-calorie bar, with a choice of milk, dark, caramel, or mint-flavored chocolate. In a similar vein, Nabisco has introduced 100 Calorie Packs (portion-control versions of indulgent snacks such as Oreos and Cheese Nips).
How could this "solution by extremes" apply to your ministry?
There is something to be said for being extreme. The old "bell curve" theory implied that the place to be was somewhere in the middle. The middle may be where most are, but it is not the place to be, particularly in ministry. The "bell curve" proves to actually be a "well curve." The middle is not the high point, but the low point. The extremes are the high points. The middle is a tar pit.
Wherever you end up, don't end up in the middle. Where is the worst place to be assigned a seat on an airplane? The dreaded middle seat. What is the worst kind of drink you can be served? The room-temperature, luke-warm, "spew-you-out-of-my-mouth" one. It is much better to be either inside or outside, hot or cold. And better to be either small or big. The medium sized church, once prized, is now not big enough for impact, or small enough for intimacy. There is no emotional strength in being in between.
Leonard Sweet explores this mental model a little bit in his book The Gospel According to Starbucks. He says that one of the keys to Starbucks success is its gravitation toward an extreme experience: extremely comfortable, extremely tasty, extremely hot. Maxwell House, on the other hand, is stuck in the middle. But today, the middles are in trouble, while the edges and extremes are vital. The days of the happy medium (related word: mediocre) are gone. Ideas that are dead or dying include middle-ground, mid-management, middle-class, as well as mainline denominations. Both ends now play against the middle in what Sweet calls "an hourglass society."
Examples of the shrinking middle abound:
• The popularity of extreme sports and entertainment.
• The rise in sales of either very big TVs, or very small TVs (and severe decline in the sale of mid-sized ones).
• Release of more automobiles of the extremely small and big varieties, and the decline in popularity of mid-sized vehicles.
• Organizations getting either bigger through acquisitions and merger or smaller through spin offs.
• Portion sizes at restaurants getting bigger, or else smaller.
How do these developments apply to your ministry?
------------
Balance is a biblical idea. For example, it was said of Jesus that He was "full of grace and truth." So there is a need for Christ-followers to stay in balance. But my thoughts about how to achieve this balance have evolved over the last few years. I used to think that you achieve balance by heading toward the middle. Now I realize that balance can be achieved in one of two ways; 1) by heading toward the middle, or 2) by counterbalancing on the edges. For instance, you can balance a teeter totter by coming to the middle of it and straddling the fulcrum, or by having equivalent weight applied to each end of the board. Of the two approaches, I like "balance by extreme."
An example of where "balance by extremes" might serve you well is in the area of worship. For example, if the extremes are "rockin' worship" on one end of the teeter-totter, and "old-time hymns" on the other, you might be better to do an extreme version of each in a service (really rock out, and really sign a hymn) than to try to put the two in a blender and come out with something that doesn't give you the taste of either. I know from experience that "blended" worship is not very tasty.
Group life is another one of the areas where I don't think you can go part-way and be successful. If you are going to make your ministry about relationships, then really make your ministry about relationships. Don't dabble here, or go half-way. Stick with your emphasis on small groups, and keep reaching out relationally. You can't "kind of" make small groups a priority. You have to make small groups your nearly exclusive activity. You have to go to extremes.
-------------
Part of CTK's appeal is that you will often find us at both ends of the teeter-totter. We've reached a balance by being extremely graceful and truthful, not by being slightly both. We've been engaging because our services present bleeding-edge music, with old-fashioned Biblical teaching. We've achieve impact by being extremely big as a network, and small as individual groups and centers, instead of a church that is somewhere in between, both, or neither. We've expanded rapidly by simultaneously strengthening the core of our mission, visions and values and expanding the frontier into new communities.
-------------
As a basketball official I can tell you that the worst angle from which to see the play is the middle of the key, right under the basket. You are much better off to get a "wide angle" toward the the corner of the court. In fact, officials are taught to imagine the area below the basket as "quicksand." You don't want to find yourself there, and if you do, you want to get through it as quickly as possible. Likewise in your ministry, don't get caught in the quick-sand of middle-ground. Go to extremes.
--------------
From Leonard Sweet, The Gospel According to Starbucks:
One example of how to bring the ends together in a well-curve work, and the benefits of a simultaneous engagement of both ends of the continuum, is the competing food habits of indulgence and wellness. "Contradictory consumers" are going in opposite directions at the same time. We go from Ben & Jerry's Ice Cream or Krispy Kreme Donuts to the organic salad bar or raw juice bar....
We live in a Godiva culture of indulgence layered upon indulgence lathered with a whipped-cream topping of guilty pleasures and a final red cherry of repentance. This is also a culture obsessed with weight and health consciousness. We have the highest obesity rates in the world, and eating disorders run rampant. How do you bring these "dueling extremes" of death-by-chocolates and squeaky-clean foods together?
The blended, cut-to-the-middle solution of the bell-curve world was to introduce low-cal, low-far chocolate. That didn't work. Why eat chocolate if you can't enjoy the fat-drenched flavor of decadence? People want the experience of luxurious chocolate. They don't want halfway, diluted experiences of chocolate. But they also want a responsible weight-management program, one that can make a difference and not just create delusions of health.
The key is to offer consumers two opposite experiences at the same time. Hence portion-controlled chocolates. Nestle's Butterfinger Stixx and Hershey's Sticks offer the binge experience of chocolate in a way that doesn't adversely impact the body. Hershey's Sticks, with a tagline promising a "convenient guilt-free way to indulge in chocolate," is available in an eleven-gram, sixty-calorie bar, with a choice of milk, dark, caramel, or mint-flavored chocolate. In a similar vein, Nabisco has introduced 100 Calorie Packs (portion-control versions of indulgent snacks such as Oreos and Cheese Nips).
How could this "solution by extremes" apply to your ministry?
Gender
A therapist once said to me, "Gender is always part of the equation." He said this in the context of a conversation about moral failure in ministry. He was speaking to the ignorance that he saw among overly-idealistic church leaders who wanted to imagine that they could counsel and care for members of the opposite sex and yet not be snared by emotional or physical attraction (read: play with fire and not get burned).
Pastors, as other caring professionals, are at risk here. A pastor must care for unhealthy people, but in a healthy way. To this end it is important to be self-aware about attraction and limit your involvement with individuals of the opposite sex. The Apostle Paul had some winning ideas here: Older women instructing younger women; older men instructing younger men. That's a pretty proactive, common-sensical approach. You should definitely be developing a ministry team to assist you in a gender-specific way. Another common-sense biblical strategy that Joseph employed (a little bit more reactive) is RUN AS FAST AS YOUR CAN. You might have to be ready to do that as well.
As a pastor it is not possible to avoid conversations and meetings that are cross-gender. But clear boundaries are a must. Here are some ideas:
1. Do not meet alone
• Have someone else around
• Have a window or door open so that work associates can look in or listen in
• Meet in a public space, like an office building or coffee shop (not in a home or a car)
• Consider having someone else in the meeting (spouse, assistant, etc.)
2. Do not meet on their turf
• Stay in control of the environment
• Publicize the meeting place to others (no secret meeting place)
3. Do not meet after hours
• Early morning or late night meetings are a bad idea
4. Do not meet regularly
• Refer to a counselor for ongoing treatment
5. Do not share personal life details
• Stay strictly professional in your conversation
• If you speak of your wife and family only speak positively
6. Do not touch
• Make handshakes brief (do not linger)
• Avoid hugs entirely or else one-armed side hugs
• If any attempt is made to touch you (hold on to your hand, etc.) pull away and end the meeting immediately
7. Do not fantasize
• Discipline your mind toward Philippians 4:8 thoughts
• If you find yourself drowning in the soup talk with your area pastor and get some support
In your relationships with the opposite sex, be honest with yourself if problems are developing between your ears. There are some typically "red flags" that go up when attraction starts to be problematic. Be aware if:
1. You find yourself looking forward to a meeting with someone of the opposite gender.
2. You find yourself trying to figure out a reason to have a phone call or meeting with someone of the opposite gender.
3. You find yourself day-dreaming about someone of the opposite gender.
4. You find yourself speaking differently than you normally would (more charmingly, more sensitively) with someone of the opposite gender.
Remember, we are all made of the same stuff, and sometimes that's not very good stuff. Make others aware of the potential for problems, for you, or others. Tell the people around you to feel free to ask questions if they see something weird going on (someone calling frequently, hanging around after services, etc.). Better to be open and frank about the fact that "Gender is always part of the equation." Obviously, with as many leaders as we've seen "getting burned" it's time to quit playing with fire.
--------------
How do you handle physical beauty when you see it? I used to pretend that I didn't. That didn't work very well. I don't know who I was fooling, but I wasn't fooling myself, much less God. Now I have developed "the prayer." The prayer goes like this: "God, that is a beautiful woman. You created her, and you did a good job. But she belongs to you, Lord, not me. I just wanted you to know that I noticed." What does that prayer do for me? It keeps me in reality. It keeps me from objectifying someone. It pricks the bubble of illusion and fantasy. It helps me see that person with spiritual eyes. It keeps me in reality.
Pastors, as other caring professionals, are at risk here. A pastor must care for unhealthy people, but in a healthy way. To this end it is important to be self-aware about attraction and limit your involvement with individuals of the opposite sex. The Apostle Paul had some winning ideas here: Older women instructing younger women; older men instructing younger men. That's a pretty proactive, common-sensical approach. You should definitely be developing a ministry team to assist you in a gender-specific way. Another common-sense biblical strategy that Joseph employed (a little bit more reactive) is RUN AS FAST AS YOUR CAN. You might have to be ready to do that as well.
As a pastor it is not possible to avoid conversations and meetings that are cross-gender. But clear boundaries are a must. Here are some ideas:
1. Do not meet alone
• Have someone else around
• Have a window or door open so that work associates can look in or listen in
• Meet in a public space, like an office building or coffee shop (not in a home or a car)
• Consider having someone else in the meeting (spouse, assistant, etc.)
2. Do not meet on their turf
• Stay in control of the environment
• Publicize the meeting place to others (no secret meeting place)
3. Do not meet after hours
• Early morning or late night meetings are a bad idea
4. Do not meet regularly
• Refer to a counselor for ongoing treatment
5. Do not share personal life details
• Stay strictly professional in your conversation
• If you speak of your wife and family only speak positively
6. Do not touch
• Make handshakes brief (do not linger)
• Avoid hugs entirely or else one-armed side hugs
• If any attempt is made to touch you (hold on to your hand, etc.) pull away and end the meeting immediately
7. Do not fantasize
• Discipline your mind toward Philippians 4:8 thoughts
• If you find yourself drowning in the soup talk with your area pastor and get some support
In your relationships with the opposite sex, be honest with yourself if problems are developing between your ears. There are some typically "red flags" that go up when attraction starts to be problematic. Be aware if:
1. You find yourself looking forward to a meeting with someone of the opposite gender.
2. You find yourself trying to figure out a reason to have a phone call or meeting with someone of the opposite gender.
3. You find yourself day-dreaming about someone of the opposite gender.
4. You find yourself speaking differently than you normally would (more charmingly, more sensitively) with someone of the opposite gender.
Remember, we are all made of the same stuff, and sometimes that's not very good stuff. Make others aware of the potential for problems, for you, or others. Tell the people around you to feel free to ask questions if they see something weird going on (someone calling frequently, hanging around after services, etc.). Better to be open and frank about the fact that "Gender is always part of the equation." Obviously, with as many leaders as we've seen "getting burned" it's time to quit playing with fire.
--------------
How do you handle physical beauty when you see it? I used to pretend that I didn't. That didn't work very well. I don't know who I was fooling, but I wasn't fooling myself, much less God. Now I have developed "the prayer." The prayer goes like this: "God, that is a beautiful woman. You created her, and you did a good job. But she belongs to you, Lord, not me. I just wanted you to know that I noticed." What does that prayer do for me? It keeps me in reality. It keeps me from objectifying someone. It pricks the bubble of illusion and fantasy. It helps me see that person with spiritual eyes. It keeps me in reality.
Underground
Underground caves are a big part of God's story, not just at Easter, but at Christmas and other times. This thought was provoked by G.K. Chesterton in his book The Everlasting Man. In particular Chesterton reminded me that:
• God came to earth underground. In all likelihood the manger that held Joseph, Mary and Jesus was a cave, not an outbuilding. This means that when God came to earth, He did not even come on ground level, but underground, while “The horse hoofs of Herod passed like thunder over the head of Christ.”
• God provided salvation underground. The resurrection was truly underground, both literally and figuratively. On Easter morning, the women were surprised to fine an empty cave. “That is the paradox of the whole position….the highest thing can only work from below."
• The church got its start underground. “Christ was born in the cave and Christianity in the catacombs.” Until Constantine the church was organic, cellular, counter-culture and often persecuted.
It is clearly the nature of God to be underground, to do His work from below instead of from above. “There is in this buried divinity an idea of undermining the world; of shaking the towers and palaces from below.”
I believe that God wants us to be "underground" Christians, shaking things up from below, instead of from above. Some of the words written into our mission statement at CTK are "shake-up" words - authentic, love, acceptance, forgiveness, joy, purposeful. When we love people, care about people, serve people, we undermine the world - the towers and palaces begin to shake.
--------------
A friend who is very bright (he once taught at Yale) has done some research on church history. He said to me, "The church has related to culture in one of two ways; it has either tried to dominate the culture or infiltrate the culture. Periods in which the church has tried to dominate the culture have been followed by dark ages. Periods in which the church has tried to infiltrate the culture have been followed by revival."
Hmmmm.
--------------
One of the things that I love about being a church of small groups is that it is a largely "underground" approach to ministry. It is not patently obvious to the culture that we are here. It is not a top-down/dominate approach. It is a bottoms up/infiltrate approach. We are moving under the veil of secrecy. I have found that it is unnerving to people (in the same way that terrorist cells are). They aren't exactly sure where we're coming from, but they know we're up to something....good.
--------------
In concluding his discussion of caves, Chesterton said "A cave can be a hiding place for outcasts" or it can be "a hiding place of something valuable." Church is both. On one hand what we are doing is insignificant. On the other hand it's important. The church holds the hope of the world in its hands.
• God came to earth underground. In all likelihood the manger that held Joseph, Mary and Jesus was a cave, not an outbuilding. This means that when God came to earth, He did not even come on ground level, but underground, while “The horse hoofs of Herod passed like thunder over the head of Christ.”
• God provided salvation underground. The resurrection was truly underground, both literally and figuratively. On Easter morning, the women were surprised to fine an empty cave. “That is the paradox of the whole position….the highest thing can only work from below."
• The church got its start underground. “Christ was born in the cave and Christianity in the catacombs.” Until Constantine the church was organic, cellular, counter-culture and often persecuted.
It is clearly the nature of God to be underground, to do His work from below instead of from above. “There is in this buried divinity an idea of undermining the world; of shaking the towers and palaces from below.”
I believe that God wants us to be "underground" Christians, shaking things up from below, instead of from above. Some of the words written into our mission statement at CTK are "shake-up" words - authentic, love, acceptance, forgiveness, joy, purposeful. When we love people, care about people, serve people, we undermine the world - the towers and palaces begin to shake.
--------------
A friend who is very bright (he once taught at Yale) has done some research on church history. He said to me, "The church has related to culture in one of two ways; it has either tried to dominate the culture or infiltrate the culture. Periods in which the church has tried to dominate the culture have been followed by dark ages. Periods in which the church has tried to infiltrate the culture have been followed by revival."
Hmmmm.
--------------
One of the things that I love about being a church of small groups is that it is a largely "underground" approach to ministry. It is not patently obvious to the culture that we are here. It is not a top-down/dominate approach. It is a bottoms up/infiltrate approach. We are moving under the veil of secrecy. I have found that it is unnerving to people (in the same way that terrorist cells are). They aren't exactly sure where we're coming from, but they know we're up to something....good.
--------------
In concluding his discussion of caves, Chesterton said "A cave can be a hiding place for outcasts" or it can be "a hiding place of something valuable." Church is both. On one hand what we are doing is insignificant. On the other hand it's important. The church holds the hope of the world in its hands.
Easter
G.K. Chesterton, The Everlasting Man:
They took the body down from the cross and one of the few rich men among the first Christians obtained permission to bury it in a rock tomb in his garden; the Romans setting a military guard let there should be some riot and attempt to recovery the body. There was once more a natural symbolism in these natural proceedings; it was well that the tomb should be sealed with all the secrecy of ancient eastern sepulture and guarded by the authority of the Caesars. For in that cavern the whole of that great and glorious humanity which we call antiquity was gathered up and covered over; and in that place it was buried. It was the end of a very great thing called human history; the history that was merely human. The mythologies and the philosophies were buried there, the gods and the heroes and the sages. In the great Roman phrase, they had lives. But as they could only live, so they could only die; and they were dead.
On the third day the friends of Christ coming at day-break to the place found the grace empty and the stone rolled away. In varying ways they realized the new wonder, but even they hardly realized that the world had died in the night. What they were looking at was the first day of creation, with a new heaven and a new earth; and in a semblance of the gardener God walked again in the garden, in the cool not of the evening but the dawn.
They took the body down from the cross and one of the few rich men among the first Christians obtained permission to bury it in a rock tomb in his garden; the Romans setting a military guard let there should be some riot and attempt to recovery the body. There was once more a natural symbolism in these natural proceedings; it was well that the tomb should be sealed with all the secrecy of ancient eastern sepulture and guarded by the authority of the Caesars. For in that cavern the whole of that great and glorious humanity which we call antiquity was gathered up and covered over; and in that place it was buried. It was the end of a very great thing called human history; the history that was merely human. The mythologies and the philosophies were buried there, the gods and the heroes and the sages. In the great Roman phrase, they had lives. But as they could only live, so they could only die; and they were dead.
On the third day the friends of Christ coming at day-break to the place found the grace empty and the stone rolled away. In varying ways they realized the new wonder, but even they hardly realized that the world had died in the night. What they were looking at was the first day of creation, with a new heaven and a new earth; and in a semblance of the gardener God walked again in the garden, in the cool not of the evening but the dawn.
Impulse
When it comes to success, character is more important than intelligence. Walter Mischel is a research psychologist at Stanford University. He tested children at age four for "impulse control." This character trait ended up being a much greater predictor of future success than IQ. Evidently, brains and talent alone don't make someone successful. Those brains and talents need to be under control, or what Mischel calls "goal-directed self-imposed delay of gratification." Simply put, successful people self-regulate their activities to achieve a greater goal. They deny impulses that are not in service of the greater good.
This principle of success has a direct application to ministry and ministers. First, for ministry, we are often faced with competing demands for resources. For instance, the youth department would love to have a new big screen TV. There is also an opportunity to conduct an outreach to launch new small groups in a neighboring community. Is the ministry able to discipline itself into choosing the path that will advance Christ's kingdom? Or will we give in to the impulse to "feather our own nest?" Are we willing to put "our" needs on the back burner, so that the needs of others can be met? Many groups are not willing, and it becomes their undoing.
The challenge of impulse control that is faced on a macro scale for the ministry, is faced on a micro scale for the minister. For instance, there may be an opportunity presented to speak at a national conference. Unfortunately the timing of this invitation conflicts with an important season of ministry locally. Can the minister forego the opportunity for exposure (read: ego management) in order to "stick to the knitting?" Many can't, and it becomes their undoing.
"Non-gratifying" work often precedes gratifying work. The pilot has to go through the checklist before he gets to fly. The surgeon has to scrub down before she gets to operate. The manager has to do the reference checks before hiring. The wise couple goes through the pre-marital counseling before tying the knot. Likewise, successful small group leaders make reminder phone calls to their group members on Monday, so that they have a good attendance and group meeting on Wednesday. Successful teachers block out the time for study, so that their lessons are well documented and illustrated. Successful pastors invest the time in leader development, so that they can achieve a growing ministry.
Private success precedes public success. What impulses do you need to control in order to achieve a greater level of impact? What non-gratifying work do you need to do, in order to get to do the gratifying work?
-----------
There are little things that I check on each week that may seem trivial, but that I consider to be the important behind the scenes, non-gratifying "stuff" that allows me to enjoy the "stuff" that is gratifying, like teaching the word. For instance, I check the distance between rows in the auditorium so that there is sufficient room for people to get to seats. I check the temperature in the room, and make sure there is some air flow. I look in the bathrooms to make sure there are paper towels and toiler paper. I try to do a sound check with the lapel mic. I make sure that I have enough water to drink. Do I enjoy doing these things? Not really. My impulse would be to just get up, start talking, and hope for the best. But getting ready requires doing the "nongratifying" work before jumping in.
----------
"Paying it forward" has been an important aspect of CTK's success. We have restricted our impulses to achieve a greater good. We are paying a price now for opportunities we hope to enjoy in the future. For instance, we are sharing the costs of building a Central Services organization, so that there is a strong enough administrative backbone to support a movement. Is this easy to do? No. A couple years ago, Central Services was 15% of our budget. This year we have budgeted 11% for Central Services (it was actually 7% last month). In the future, with greater scale, we see Central Services consistently being a cost in the mid-single-digits. The future prospect is that all CTK groups and centers would have had a high degree of skilled administrative support (web, bookkeeping, advertising, etc.) for just pennies of each dollar. But for now, I have to admit that I have an occasional impulse to want to spend that money in a more short-sighted way! But I believe our long term success will based on our "goal-directed self-imposed delay of gratification." It is the nature of Christ's kingdom to make sacrifices for those who are about to come.
This principle of success has a direct application to ministry and ministers. First, for ministry, we are often faced with competing demands for resources. For instance, the youth department would love to have a new big screen TV. There is also an opportunity to conduct an outreach to launch new small groups in a neighboring community. Is the ministry able to discipline itself into choosing the path that will advance Christ's kingdom? Or will we give in to the impulse to "feather our own nest?" Are we willing to put "our" needs on the back burner, so that the needs of others can be met? Many groups are not willing, and it becomes their undoing.
The challenge of impulse control that is faced on a macro scale for the ministry, is faced on a micro scale for the minister. For instance, there may be an opportunity presented to speak at a national conference. Unfortunately the timing of this invitation conflicts with an important season of ministry locally. Can the minister forego the opportunity for exposure (read: ego management) in order to "stick to the knitting?" Many can't, and it becomes their undoing.
"Non-gratifying" work often precedes gratifying work. The pilot has to go through the checklist before he gets to fly. The surgeon has to scrub down before she gets to operate. The manager has to do the reference checks before hiring. The wise couple goes through the pre-marital counseling before tying the knot. Likewise, successful small group leaders make reminder phone calls to their group members on Monday, so that they have a good attendance and group meeting on Wednesday. Successful teachers block out the time for study, so that their lessons are well documented and illustrated. Successful pastors invest the time in leader development, so that they can achieve a growing ministry.
Private success precedes public success. What impulses do you need to control in order to achieve a greater level of impact? What non-gratifying work do you need to do, in order to get to do the gratifying work?
-----------
There are little things that I check on each week that may seem trivial, but that I consider to be the important behind the scenes, non-gratifying "stuff" that allows me to enjoy the "stuff" that is gratifying, like teaching the word. For instance, I check the distance between rows in the auditorium so that there is sufficient room for people to get to seats. I check the temperature in the room, and make sure there is some air flow. I look in the bathrooms to make sure there are paper towels and toiler paper. I try to do a sound check with the lapel mic. I make sure that I have enough water to drink. Do I enjoy doing these things? Not really. My impulse would be to just get up, start talking, and hope for the best. But getting ready requires doing the "nongratifying" work before jumping in.
----------
"Paying it forward" has been an important aspect of CTK's success. We have restricted our impulses to achieve a greater good. We are paying a price now for opportunities we hope to enjoy in the future. For instance, we are sharing the costs of building a Central Services organization, so that there is a strong enough administrative backbone to support a movement. Is this easy to do? No. A couple years ago, Central Services was 15% of our budget. This year we have budgeted 11% for Central Services (it was actually 7% last month). In the future, with greater scale, we see Central Services consistently being a cost in the mid-single-digits. The future prospect is that all CTK groups and centers would have had a high degree of skilled administrative support (web, bookkeeping, advertising, etc.) for just pennies of each dollar. But for now, I have to admit that I have an occasional impulse to want to spend that money in a more short-sighted way! But I believe our long term success will based on our "goal-directed self-imposed delay of gratification." It is the nature of Christ's kingdom to make sacrifices for those who are about to come.
Fatigue
One of the beautiful things about CTK is its focus. Early in CTK’s history Steve Mason decided that CTK would focus on three things. We have carried on with these three priorities: Worship, Small Groups, and Outreach.
One of the reasons these priorities have had such spiritual impact is that they connect directly with the “great commandments” of Jesus: to love God (Worship) and people (Small Groups, Outreach). But staying focused is a challenging proposition. Over time there is a tendency to become diluted and less clear. This happens to many well-meaning businesses and ministries. Some of the challenges to focus at CTK include:
• Additional programs (“program creep”)
• Accumulation of stuff (building, equipment)
• Drift from participants to spectators
Over time, with “focus fatigue,” people can no longer articulate the activities of the church succinctly. The only real response to “focus fatigue” is deliberate leadership. Leaders have to become more intentional about articulating the priorities. Leaders must occasionally “weed the garden” of activities that do not support the priorities. Some of the ways this can be done:
• Limiting announcements to what can fit in the program
• A moratorium on non-small-group activities
What have you done to combat focus fatigue? Has it worked?
One of the reasons these priorities have had such spiritual impact is that they connect directly with the “great commandments” of Jesus: to love God (Worship) and people (Small Groups, Outreach). But staying focused is a challenging proposition. Over time there is a tendency to become diluted and less clear. This happens to many well-meaning businesses and ministries. Some of the challenges to focus at CTK include:
• Additional programs (“program creep”)
• Accumulation of stuff (building, equipment)
• Drift from participants to spectators
Over time, with “focus fatigue,” people can no longer articulate the activities of the church succinctly. The only real response to “focus fatigue” is deliberate leadership. Leaders have to become more intentional about articulating the priorities. Leaders must occasionally “weed the garden” of activities that do not support the priorities. Some of the ways this can be done:
• Limiting announcements to what can fit in the program
• A moratorium on non-small-group activities
What have you done to combat focus fatigue? Has it worked?
Ten
This week I will be traveling to Panama to meet with one of our new overseas leaders. I'll have just a few days with him, so I want to make the time count. If you had only a short amount of time to convey important information to a key leader, what would you talk about? What ideas do you perceive to be critical to what God is doing through CTK? Here's the list I came up with so far:
1. People are the ministers. The pastors are to equip the people for the work of the ministry.
2. Small groups are the basic building block. Groups provide friendship, growth, encouragement and outreach.
3. Keep the arrows pointed out. The goal is not to get people to come to us, but to get us to go to them.
4. Learn to say "Yes, sure, you bet." Our goal is to cooperate with God in what He is doing.
5. Think "more" instead of "bigger." By decentralizing the ministry we can reach an unlimited number of people.
6. Relationships are the basic currency. The church is a people, not a building.
7. Our task is to Identify, Deploy, Train, and Support leaders. Deploy first, then train.
8. Keep it simple. Focus the ministry around the priorities of Worship, Small Groups, Outreach.
9. There's hope for the future, forgiveness for the past. We have a redemptive God.
10. Good enough is good enough. Do the simplest thing that could possibly work.
Would you add anything to this list?
1. People are the ministers. The pastors are to equip the people for the work of the ministry.
2. Small groups are the basic building block. Groups provide friendship, growth, encouragement and outreach.
3. Keep the arrows pointed out. The goal is not to get people to come to us, but to get us to go to them.
4. Learn to say "Yes, sure, you bet." Our goal is to cooperate with God in what He is doing.
5. Think "more" instead of "bigger." By decentralizing the ministry we can reach an unlimited number of people.
6. Relationships are the basic currency. The church is a people, not a building.
7. Our task is to Identify, Deploy, Train, and Support leaders. Deploy first, then train.
8. Keep it simple. Focus the ministry around the priorities of Worship, Small Groups, Outreach.
9. There's hope for the future, forgiveness for the past. We have a redemptive God.
10. Good enough is good enough. Do the simplest thing that could possibly work.
Would you add anything to this list?
Revolution
George Barna recently wrote a book called Revolution. I enjoyed the book very much, although I thought he gave up on the church much too easily. But there is certainly a revolution going on. There are actually multiple revolutions going on:
• In tech/communications....where speed is critical
• In relationships....where there is less face to face interaction, and more impersonal ones (email, etc.)
• In worldview....where the mental filter is now post-modernism and mass media is the dominant
• In information....where mass media is the dominant teacher
• In demographics....where the population is getting more diverse
• In culture....where superficiality is predominant
• In lifestyles....where younger people are very tribal
• In work....where people want to have more leisure options
There is also a revolution coming to the church. People want more of God. They want to live their faith. They want God to be top priority. These type of people are "God crazy." They want everything they do to be an act of worship. They do not want to go to church. They want to be the church. They don't want political or religious games. They are looking for a transformational experience. They are reaching for what C.S. Lewis called "deep church."
Spiritual revolutionaries are getting involved in new forms of what we call church, and they are making a different kind of impact. They have a passion for growth and relationships. They are not interested in building an institution. They are wanting to change the world.
-------------
One thing that I heard Barna say is that "There is a difference between being a revolutionary and being a rebel." I thought that was a very insightful comment. Rebels see what is wrong, but don't offer preferable alternatives. There are a lot of young church leaders running around right now espousing what's wrong with the church. I think it is important to not just say, "The institutional church is broken" but to also say, "and this is how God's organic church can work."
-------------
Characteristic of revolutions is inefficiency and messiness. Revolutionaries advance into uncharted territory and face new problems. I have said through the years that it takes the ability to deal with "a high level of ambiguity" to function in the CTK story. It reminds me of the commercial where they are building the plane after it is already in the air.
-------------
If you are in a place where you have more questions than answers, be thankful. This is where you should be, at least at this point in history. This is where the revolutionaries are. In the cycle of "storming, forming, norming, performing" the organized church, after hundreds of years of norming, needs to get back to the drawing board.
• In tech/communications....where speed is critical
• In relationships....where there is less face to face interaction, and more impersonal ones (email, etc.)
• In worldview....where the mental filter is now post-modernism and mass media is the dominant
• In information....where mass media is the dominant teacher
• In demographics....where the population is getting more diverse
• In culture....where superficiality is predominant
• In lifestyles....where younger people are very tribal
• In work....where people want to have more leisure options
There is also a revolution coming to the church. People want more of God. They want to live their faith. They want God to be top priority. These type of people are "God crazy." They want everything they do to be an act of worship. They do not want to go to church. They want to be the church. They don't want political or religious games. They are looking for a transformational experience. They are reaching for what C.S. Lewis called "deep church."
Spiritual revolutionaries are getting involved in new forms of what we call church, and they are making a different kind of impact. They have a passion for growth and relationships. They are not interested in building an institution. They are wanting to change the world.
-------------
One thing that I heard Barna say is that "There is a difference between being a revolutionary and being a rebel." I thought that was a very insightful comment. Rebels see what is wrong, but don't offer preferable alternatives. There are a lot of young church leaders running around right now espousing what's wrong with the church. I think it is important to not just say, "The institutional church is broken" but to also say, "and this is how God's organic church can work."
-------------
Characteristic of revolutions is inefficiency and messiness. Revolutionaries advance into uncharted territory and face new problems. I have said through the years that it takes the ability to deal with "a high level of ambiguity" to function in the CTK story. It reminds me of the commercial where they are building the plane after it is already in the air.
-------------
If you are in a place where you have more questions than answers, be thankful. This is where you should be, at least at this point in history. This is where the revolutionaries are. In the cycle of "storming, forming, norming, performing" the organized church, after hundreds of years of norming, needs to get back to the drawing board.
Energy
It is always nice when a congregation possesses a certain "energy." You enter the Worship Center and you sense that something is "happening." You might describe the environment as "electric" or "alive." There's a "buzz" in the place. Over the years I've paid attention to this energy and come to a few conclusions.
1. It is better to have this energy in the room than not to have it. Everything is easier when you have it. Worshipping is easier. Teaching is easier. Even giving the announcements is easier when there is energy in the room. Conversely, when the room is dead, it is just that much harder to sing and teach.
2. The energy you experience may be quite natural instead of supernatural. I could be wrong here. But I do have a sense for God's presence, and I'm unconvinced that the "buzz" you experience when a group of people come together to worship is necessarily a supernatural manifestation. It may be a very natural phenomena. I say this because I've sensed the same energy at super bowl parties, crowded coffee shops, school plays, family reunions, basketball games and concerts. In other words the energy may be a natural consequence of people getting together, and not just for spiritual purposes.
3. The energy we like to experience can come from more than one source. As I've reflected on this energy, I've come to believe that it comes in two varieties: 1) the "energy of community" and 2) the "energy of crowd." The energy of community is the buzz you sense at a superbowl party, crowded coffee shop or family reunion. The energy of crowd is the electricity you experience at a school play, basketball game or concert. It is easy to think that the energy of community and crowd are the same. They aren't the same. They feel similar, but for different reasons. The energy of community comes from reunion. The energy of crowd comes from anticipation. The energy of community finds its locus in the back of the room. The locus of crowd is the front of the room. Relationships are the star of the show with community; performers star with crowd. Community is bottom up. Crowd is top down.
4. The biggest difference between the energy of community and the energy of crowd is who brings the energy. With community, you bring the energy with you - you are an active participant, a prosumer. With crowd, the energy is brought to you - you are a passive spectator, a consumer. You hear pastors of large ministries saying things like, "It takes so much energy to lead this church." This power-demand is a "load" for the pastor and staff.
5. I much prefer to have the energy in a church come from community than crowd. Actually, I'd like to have both. But if I can only have one, I like to see the energy of community be primary. The best way to know whether you are dealing with the energy of community is to ask, "What happens to the energy level when the performers are not here to perform (pastor is away, etc.)?" When the energy comes from community the answer is, "There's still a buzz in the room." As an example, there's energy in the gymnasium until the announcer says the game is cancelled. Once the game is cancelled "the air goes out of the room." The energy of crowd is fickle like that. But let's say you show up at your family reunion, and discover that someone couldn't make it. It might put a slight damper on the energy in the room, but it will still be there, because there are a lot of other people with whom you can fellowship.
--------------
I have had two fairly high-energy experiences at CTK (Bellingham, Mount Vernon) in which we "switched power sources" (from community to crowd) as the ministry grew in size. With size there tends to come more passivity on the part of people. This not what we want, it's just the way it is. People come for "the show." Having a lot of people in the room is a different type of attraction than community, but it is an attraction. I think the attraction shifted from community to crowd in both Bellingham and Mount Vernon (to a lesser extent), and in both cases we got confused by thinking that the people were still coming because of community, and didn't pick up on the subtle shift until we were behind the curve.
Another thing that starts to happen when you get into hundreds of people is that people coming in from the outside start to push you (if you let them) toward a more programmatic model (this is what I believe snuck up on us in Bellingham). They expect there to be programs based on other large churches with which they are familiar. It takes a lot of intentionality on the part of the leadership to say, "No, this is a church of small groups. Small groups are our plan A and we don't have a plan B."
With a larger group that are subtle changes in style that can creep in as well. Communication tends to be more "broadcast" than "reciprocal/engaging." The pastor can start to be viewed as more of a celebrity instead of a fellow-struggler. Instead of a sense that "we all have answers we can bring to the table" it can start to feel like "the pastor is above us, obviously....just look at how many people are listening to him."
One of the reasons why I value launching additional Worship Centers, is because the energy of community (by percentage) crests and begins to fall somewhere around 300 people.
---------------
Another phenomenon I have observed is that by the time the church hits critical mass and momentum - hitting on all 8 cyclinders - there has been so much emphasis given to small groups (perhaps the fundamental cause of the momentum!) that fatigue starts to set in around a) talking about small groups, b) identifying new leaders, c) doing the social architecture of getting people into groups. You start to feel like you've said this stuff a thousand times (which you have), but the new people who are coming in (the most recent 100-150 people) haven't heard it yet. I think you have to "push through" the fatigue and talk about small groups as if you never have before.
1. It is better to have this energy in the room than not to have it. Everything is easier when you have it. Worshipping is easier. Teaching is easier. Even giving the announcements is easier when there is energy in the room. Conversely, when the room is dead, it is just that much harder to sing and teach.
2. The energy you experience may be quite natural instead of supernatural. I could be wrong here. But I do have a sense for God's presence, and I'm unconvinced that the "buzz" you experience when a group of people come together to worship is necessarily a supernatural manifestation. It may be a very natural phenomena. I say this because I've sensed the same energy at super bowl parties, crowded coffee shops, school plays, family reunions, basketball games and concerts. In other words the energy may be a natural consequence of people getting together, and not just for spiritual purposes.
3. The energy we like to experience can come from more than one source. As I've reflected on this energy, I've come to believe that it comes in two varieties: 1) the "energy of community" and 2) the "energy of crowd." The energy of community is the buzz you sense at a superbowl party, crowded coffee shop or family reunion. The energy of crowd is the electricity you experience at a school play, basketball game or concert. It is easy to think that the energy of community and crowd are the same. They aren't the same. They feel similar, but for different reasons. The energy of community comes from reunion. The energy of crowd comes from anticipation. The energy of community finds its locus in the back of the room. The locus of crowd is the front of the room. Relationships are the star of the show with community; performers star with crowd. Community is bottom up. Crowd is top down.
4. The biggest difference between the energy of community and the energy of crowd is who brings the energy. With community, you bring the energy with you - you are an active participant, a prosumer. With crowd, the energy is brought to you - you are a passive spectator, a consumer. You hear pastors of large ministries saying things like, "It takes so much energy to lead this church." This power-demand is a "load" for the pastor and staff.
5. I much prefer to have the energy in a church come from community than crowd. Actually, I'd like to have both. But if I can only have one, I like to see the energy of community be primary. The best way to know whether you are dealing with the energy of community is to ask, "What happens to the energy level when the performers are not here to perform (pastor is away, etc.)?" When the energy comes from community the answer is, "There's still a buzz in the room." As an example, there's energy in the gymnasium until the announcer says the game is cancelled. Once the game is cancelled "the air goes out of the room." The energy of crowd is fickle like that. But let's say you show up at your family reunion, and discover that someone couldn't make it. It might put a slight damper on the energy in the room, but it will still be there, because there are a lot of other people with whom you can fellowship.
--------------
I have had two fairly high-energy experiences at CTK (Bellingham, Mount Vernon) in which we "switched power sources" (from community to crowd) as the ministry grew in size. With size there tends to come more passivity on the part of people. This not what we want, it's just the way it is. People come for "the show." Having a lot of people in the room is a different type of attraction than community, but it is an attraction. I think the attraction shifted from community to crowd in both Bellingham and Mount Vernon (to a lesser extent), and in both cases we got confused by thinking that the people were still coming because of community, and didn't pick up on the subtle shift until we were behind the curve.
Another thing that starts to happen when you get into hundreds of people is that people coming in from the outside start to push you (if you let them) toward a more programmatic model (this is what I believe snuck up on us in Bellingham). They expect there to be programs based on other large churches with which they are familiar. It takes a lot of intentionality on the part of the leadership to say, "No, this is a church of small groups. Small groups are our plan A and we don't have a plan B."
With a larger group that are subtle changes in style that can creep in as well. Communication tends to be more "broadcast" than "reciprocal/engaging." The pastor can start to be viewed as more of a celebrity instead of a fellow-struggler. Instead of a sense that "we all have answers we can bring to the table" it can start to feel like "the pastor is above us, obviously....just look at how many people are listening to him."
One of the reasons why I value launching additional Worship Centers, is because the energy of community (by percentage) crests and begins to fall somewhere around 300 people.
---------------
Another phenomenon I have observed is that by the time the church hits critical mass and momentum - hitting on all 8 cyclinders - there has been so much emphasis given to small groups (perhaps the fundamental cause of the momentum!) that fatigue starts to set in around a) talking about small groups, b) identifying new leaders, c) doing the social architecture of getting people into groups. You start to feel like you've said this stuff a thousand times (which you have), but the new people who are coming in (the most recent 100-150 people) haven't heard it yet. I think you have to "push through" the fatigue and talk about small groups as if you never have before.
Ministry
Have you ever had a "hard week" in ministry, where things and people seem to conspire against you? If you haven't had one of these lately, get ready! I have been amazed over the years at the experiences I've had. After a period of "perfect sailing" you can crash headlong into "the perfect storm."
At times like these it is good to remember that there have always been "times like these." The Apostle Paul seems to share our experience in 2 Corinthians 4:1, "Therefore, since through God's mercy we have this ministry, we do not lost heart." If I'm reading him right, he seems to be make a conscious choice at the end of that statement to not lose heart, which implies that he had every reason in the moment to do so. But maybe that's Paul's secret, he didn't just live in the moment. He stepped back and saw a much-bigger picture. He saw bigger patterns in the weather, and didn't get stuck in the current storm.
To keep perspective on ministry, I remind myself that....
Ministry is a great place to be….
The work is meaningful
The work is relational
The work is flexible
The work is compensated
Ministry is a tough place to be….
The work is spiritual war
The work is with people
The work is intense
The work is demanding
To survive in ministry….
You must keep your spiritual senses sharp.
You must occasionally get away from people and find some who will not just take from you.
You must manage IMAs. (IMAs are "Intensive Ministry Activities" like funerals, intensive counseling, etc.)
You must think “ministry” and not just “job.”
Seasoned pastors will tell you, "Never resign on a Monday." This is because you probably don't have perspective on a Monday. One thing that has helped me keep perspective is taking one day a month away with God as a day of prayer and fasting. I find that hearing my Father's voice gives me the comfort and assurance to go on. As Paul says in 2 Corinthians 5:18, "All this is from God, who reconciled us to himself through Christ and gave us the ministry of reconciliation."
At times like these it is good to remember that there have always been "times like these." The Apostle Paul seems to share our experience in 2 Corinthians 4:1, "Therefore, since through God's mercy we have this ministry, we do not lost heart." If I'm reading him right, he seems to be make a conscious choice at the end of that statement to not lose heart, which implies that he had every reason in the moment to do so. But maybe that's Paul's secret, he didn't just live in the moment. He stepped back and saw a much-bigger picture. He saw bigger patterns in the weather, and didn't get stuck in the current storm.
To keep perspective on ministry, I remind myself that....
Ministry is a great place to be….
The work is meaningful
The work is relational
The work is flexible
The work is compensated
Ministry is a tough place to be….
The work is spiritual war
The work is with people
The work is intense
The work is demanding
To survive in ministry….
You must keep your spiritual senses sharp.
You must occasionally get away from people and find some who will not just take from you.
You must manage IMAs. (IMAs are "Intensive Ministry Activities" like funerals, intensive counseling, etc.)
You must think “ministry” and not just “job.”
Seasoned pastors will tell you, "Never resign on a Monday." This is because you probably don't have perspective on a Monday. One thing that has helped me keep perspective is taking one day a month away with God as a day of prayer and fasting. I find that hearing my Father's voice gives me the comfort and assurance to go on. As Paul says in 2 Corinthians 5:18, "All this is from God, who reconciled us to himself through Christ and gave us the ministry of reconciliation."
Loyalty
Anyone who leads an organization will seek loyalty from those who participate. This is normal and natural. The question, however, for a Christian leader is "loyalty to what or whom?"
May I suggest a few inadequate objects of loyalty?
1. Personality
Some Christian leaders build their organization on personal loyalty. They want participants to be loyal to them - to their personality, winsomeness, agenda, success, etc. It has been proven over and again that Christian ministries can indeed be built this way. Recipe: find one charismatic leader, add water, stir, enjoy. This has also proven to be a recipe for disaster. When charismatic leaders fall or move on, the entire organization crumbles, because the organization was based on the charisma of that leader. Avoid the cult of personality. Remember John the baptizer's words, "He must increase, I must decrease."
2. Program
It is tempting to want to build your organization around programs - particularly if you have good programs. There is a fine line between celebrating programs because they are "working" and championing these programs as the reason why things are "working." The program, after all, is just the carton. It is not the real "stuff." The real stuff is always God's personal work in people's lives. The program - the carrier for this work - can change. No, I understated that: The program must change; if not now, then soon. This is the wine v. wineskins deal that Jesus was talking about. Love the pitcher less, the water more.
3. The Organization
When a ministry is "successful" it acquires a fan base. People love to be a part of something that is on a positive trajectory. As the organization "delivers" there is growing brand loyalty. But loyalty to the brand can be short-lived. What happens when a better "brand" comes along? Well, the answer is often that people move on. Building your ministry around brand loyalty creates fickleness, and may be the basis of much of the "church transfer" growth that you see. Studies show that the vast majority of mega-church constituents are people who have come in from other other less-popular churches; that is transfer growth, not conversion growth.
So what are adequate objects of loyalty?
1. Christ
Christ is not just worthy of loyalty, but worship. Call people to Christ. When people center their lives on Christ they find true, deep satisfaction. Christ said, "If I be lifted up, I will draw all men to me." Christ is alluring, beautiful, fascinating. There is no one who compares. There is nothing that compares. There is no suitable substitute. When you drink of Him, you never thirst again. Jesus offers the best answers to the most important questions. You can't go wrong by building your ministry around Christ.
2. The Mission
The mission that God has given to us is the greatest enterprise on planet earth. His Kingdom dwarfs all others kingdoms (small k) in comparison. Build your ministry around eternal goals and objectives. As Christ said, "Seek first the Kingdom of God and His righteousness." Call people to the mission. Call people to service and sacrifice. Ask people to invest their lives in something that will outlast their lives. It is the highest calling and the most thrilling adventure people can know.
__________________
You might ask, "Well what do I do if I have developed strong personality, programs or organization? I would say, first of all, thank God for this, and second, use your strong personality, programs and organization to direct people to Christ and His kingdom. Godly people are inspired when they see strong personalities pointing humbly toward Christ. Participants love it when programs are really just conduits for learning to love the Lord. Adherents are blessed when organizations serve as hand-maidens to the mission. There's nothing wrong with personality, programs or organization. But reach for something higher. Don't settle for playing the notes. Make music!
May I suggest a few inadequate objects of loyalty?
1. Personality
Some Christian leaders build their organization on personal loyalty. They want participants to be loyal to them - to their personality, winsomeness, agenda, success, etc. It has been proven over and again that Christian ministries can indeed be built this way. Recipe: find one charismatic leader, add water, stir, enjoy. This has also proven to be a recipe for disaster. When charismatic leaders fall or move on, the entire organization crumbles, because the organization was based on the charisma of that leader. Avoid the cult of personality. Remember John the baptizer's words, "He must increase, I must decrease."
2. Program
It is tempting to want to build your organization around programs - particularly if you have good programs. There is a fine line between celebrating programs because they are "working" and championing these programs as the reason why things are "working." The program, after all, is just the carton. It is not the real "stuff." The real stuff is always God's personal work in people's lives. The program - the carrier for this work - can change. No, I understated that: The program must change; if not now, then soon. This is the wine v. wineskins deal that Jesus was talking about. Love the pitcher less, the water more.
3. The Organization
When a ministry is "successful" it acquires a fan base. People love to be a part of something that is on a positive trajectory. As the organization "delivers" there is growing brand loyalty. But loyalty to the brand can be short-lived. What happens when a better "brand" comes along? Well, the answer is often that people move on. Building your ministry around brand loyalty creates fickleness, and may be the basis of much of the "church transfer" growth that you see. Studies show that the vast majority of mega-church constituents are people who have come in from other other less-popular churches; that is transfer growth, not conversion growth.
So what are adequate objects of loyalty?
1. Christ
Christ is not just worthy of loyalty, but worship. Call people to Christ. When people center their lives on Christ they find true, deep satisfaction. Christ said, "If I be lifted up, I will draw all men to me." Christ is alluring, beautiful, fascinating. There is no one who compares. There is nothing that compares. There is no suitable substitute. When you drink of Him, you never thirst again. Jesus offers the best answers to the most important questions. You can't go wrong by building your ministry around Christ.
2. The Mission
The mission that God has given to us is the greatest enterprise on planet earth. His Kingdom dwarfs all others kingdoms (small k) in comparison. Build your ministry around eternal goals and objectives. As Christ said, "Seek first the Kingdom of God and His righteousness." Call people to the mission. Call people to service and sacrifice. Ask people to invest their lives in something that will outlast their lives. It is the highest calling and the most thrilling adventure people can know.
__________________
You might ask, "Well what do I do if I have developed strong personality, programs or organization? I would say, first of all, thank God for this, and second, use your strong personality, programs and organization to direct people to Christ and His kingdom. Godly people are inspired when they see strong personalities pointing humbly toward Christ. Participants love it when programs are really just conduits for learning to love the Lord. Adherents are blessed when organizations serve as hand-maidens to the mission. There's nothing wrong with personality, programs or organization. But reach for something higher. Don't settle for playing the notes. Make music!
Focus
From Mark Sanborn's You Don't Need A Title To Be A Leader (a great title, by the way)....
Focus and determination beat brains and intellect every time. You don't necessarily have to be smarter or better educated to succeed. Your power lies in your ability to focus on doing what is important. If you focus on the right things, and work at them often, you will achieve exceptional results.
One of the most important qualities of effective leadership is focus. Without focus, it is impossible to move forward to achieve your goals. Effective leaders, whatever their title, are able to keep themselves and those around them on task. Those who lack focus in their personal lives and in their careers tend to drift...
Drifting
In acting as a leader, you can handle just about everything that comes your way as long as you don't lose power and drift. Power, in this sense, is the ability to stay engaged in what is going on. It doesn't mean you have control over every situation, any more than a boat has control over the waves. Rather it is the ability to engage the situation with intent, with focus.
Drifting and waiting are two different things. Waiting is an intentional choice. It requires patience and deliberation. Drifting takes away your power of choice. When you wait, you believe that something will happen, although you may not know when. Instead of acting rashly or impetuously, you pause to gather information and seek insight. Drifting results from rudderlessness and lack of direction. When you drift, it doesn't even take a particularly large waves to capsize the boat.
It's all too easy to become distracted or lulled into complacency. Before you know it, you are drifting. A simple lack of attention can cause you to lose the power of purpose and engagement. Instead of initiating action, you become paralyzed. Rather than acting, you find yourself acted upon.
Distraction
According to the National Association of Professional Planners, the average American's desk has about fifty-two hours of unfinished work on it. A recent study of knowledge workers found that they face a distraction every eleven minutes on average, and that once distracted, it takes them twenty-five minutes to get back to the task at hand. According to a study conducted at the University of Michigan in 2005, 20 to 40 percent of a worker's productivity is eaten up by "task switching" - that is, the time it takes to mentally reengage when shifting from one task to another.
------------
A goal that I have for myself, and every person who is on the staff of CTK, is 50 minutes of productivity for every hour of work. Admittedly, this is a high level to shoot for. But I want to see us work smarter, not harder. I talk with some pastors who seem to boast about 70 hour weeks. I have to question their productivity in these hours. If you are 80% productive in a 40 hour week (32 hours of actual productivity), you are nearly as productive as someone who is 50% productive in a 70 hour week (35 hours of actual productivity).
------------
It's not about the time you put in, it's about what you put in the time. What can you do to eliminate drifting and distraction?
Focus and determination beat brains and intellect every time. You don't necessarily have to be smarter or better educated to succeed. Your power lies in your ability to focus on doing what is important. If you focus on the right things, and work at them often, you will achieve exceptional results.
One of the most important qualities of effective leadership is focus. Without focus, it is impossible to move forward to achieve your goals. Effective leaders, whatever their title, are able to keep themselves and those around them on task. Those who lack focus in their personal lives and in their careers tend to drift...
Drifting
In acting as a leader, you can handle just about everything that comes your way as long as you don't lose power and drift. Power, in this sense, is the ability to stay engaged in what is going on. It doesn't mean you have control over every situation, any more than a boat has control over the waves. Rather it is the ability to engage the situation with intent, with focus.
Drifting and waiting are two different things. Waiting is an intentional choice. It requires patience and deliberation. Drifting takes away your power of choice. When you wait, you believe that something will happen, although you may not know when. Instead of acting rashly or impetuously, you pause to gather information and seek insight. Drifting results from rudderlessness and lack of direction. When you drift, it doesn't even take a particularly large waves to capsize the boat.
It's all too easy to become distracted or lulled into complacency. Before you know it, you are drifting. A simple lack of attention can cause you to lose the power of purpose and engagement. Instead of initiating action, you become paralyzed. Rather than acting, you find yourself acted upon.
Distraction
According to the National Association of Professional Planners, the average American's desk has about fifty-two hours of unfinished work on it. A recent study of knowledge workers found that they face a distraction every eleven minutes on average, and that once distracted, it takes them twenty-five minutes to get back to the task at hand. According to a study conducted at the University of Michigan in 2005, 20 to 40 percent of a worker's productivity is eaten up by "task switching" - that is, the time it takes to mentally reengage when shifting from one task to another.
------------
A goal that I have for myself, and every person who is on the staff of CTK, is 50 minutes of productivity for every hour of work. Admittedly, this is a high level to shoot for. But I want to see us work smarter, not harder. I talk with some pastors who seem to boast about 70 hour weeks. I have to question their productivity in these hours. If you are 80% productive in a 40 hour week (32 hours of actual productivity), you are nearly as productive as someone who is 50% productive in a 70 hour week (35 hours of actual productivity).
------------
It's not about the time you put in, it's about what you put in the time. What can you do to eliminate drifting and distraction?
Blessing
Following is a blessing I gave to the leaders of CTK at the past Arrows Out Conference:
May you be filled with God’s love, so much so that you spread the fragrance of Christ wherever you go. May you do everything in love.
May you understand deeply that love is the essential characteristic of Christ’s followers - that it is not optional, but essential. May you become convinced of this at the very core of your being.
May God keep you from being seduced by Appearance, Achievement, Abilities and Accumulations; Pride, Position, Power and Prestige. May He remind us that it is not about us, it is about those who are about to come.
And in the expression of your giftedness, may you always remember that love is the greatest gift we can receive or give. May our teaching, our information, our worship and our ministries be laced with love, driven by love.
May your ministry be highly relational. May you win the world one person at a time. May you not become too busy to have the time, to take the time to love the people that God has placed around your life.
May you grow in your capacity to love; loving more people than you’ve loved before, growing in the kinds of people you love, loving over longer periods of time, loving in more ways than you’ve loved before and loving in spite of challenges. May you not quit at quitting time. May you just keep on loving.
May you keep the main thing the main thing. May you keep the arrows pointed out. May you stay out of God’s way. And may you be an instrument of God’s peace, sowing love where there is hatred, pardon where there is injury, faith where there is doubt, hope where there is despair, light where there is darkness, and joy where there is sadness.
May God grant that you would not so much seek to be consoled as to console, to be understood as to understand, to be loved as to love.
May you follow God’s script for your story. May it be a love story – God-directed, others-centered, self-sacrificing.
May you be loving like Jesus was loving. Patient, kind, never envying or boasting, proud or rude. May Jesus help you to keep from being self-seeking, or easily angered, or from recording wrongs when they are done to you. My He give you great delight in the truth, and disdain for evil. May you be the protective, trusting, hopeful, perseverant servant that would remind the world of Christ Himself.
And may you know that love will not fail. Love never fails. Love will do the job in you and through you. May you bring glory to God and blessing to those in the world.
Amen.
May you be filled with God’s love, so much so that you spread the fragrance of Christ wherever you go. May you do everything in love.
May you understand deeply that love is the essential characteristic of Christ’s followers - that it is not optional, but essential. May you become convinced of this at the very core of your being.
May God keep you from being seduced by Appearance, Achievement, Abilities and Accumulations; Pride, Position, Power and Prestige. May He remind us that it is not about us, it is about those who are about to come.
And in the expression of your giftedness, may you always remember that love is the greatest gift we can receive or give. May our teaching, our information, our worship and our ministries be laced with love, driven by love.
May your ministry be highly relational. May you win the world one person at a time. May you not become too busy to have the time, to take the time to love the people that God has placed around your life.
May you grow in your capacity to love; loving more people than you’ve loved before, growing in the kinds of people you love, loving over longer periods of time, loving in more ways than you’ve loved before and loving in spite of challenges. May you not quit at quitting time. May you just keep on loving.
May you keep the main thing the main thing. May you keep the arrows pointed out. May you stay out of God’s way. And may you be an instrument of God’s peace, sowing love where there is hatred, pardon where there is injury, faith where there is doubt, hope where there is despair, light where there is darkness, and joy where there is sadness.
May God grant that you would not so much seek to be consoled as to console, to be understood as to understand, to be loved as to love.
May you follow God’s script for your story. May it be a love story – God-directed, others-centered, self-sacrificing.
May you be loving like Jesus was loving. Patient, kind, never envying or boasting, proud or rude. May Jesus help you to keep from being self-seeking, or easily angered, or from recording wrongs when they are done to you. My He give you great delight in the truth, and disdain for evil. May you be the protective, trusting, hopeful, perseverant servant that would remind the world of Christ Himself.
And may you know that love will not fail. Love never fails. Love will do the job in you and through you. May you bring glory to God and blessing to those in the world.
Amen.
Charismatic
I am occasionally asked about how CTK handles the expression of charismatic gifts, such as tongues, in our worship services. The answer is not very complicated. I say, “We have a mission statement that dictates our behavior. It calls for us to create an authentic Christian community that effectively reaches out to unchurched people in love, acceptance and forgiveness.” The implication is clear. The way we worship must be understandable to those we are attempting to reach.
Occasionally someone will express the wish that we would "take it further." I am all for that if “take it further" means a deeper sense of awe, reverence, and love for God. If however, "take it further" means behaving in a way that is comfortable for those from a Pentecostal or charismatic background, but not for others, then the answer is no. This is not because we don't appreciate our Pentecostal and charismatic friends. We do. They have a rich spiritual heritage and have contributed much to the body of Christ. It is just that the practice of a physically demonstrative or emotionalIy driven form of worship is not in harmony with our mission of effectively presenting the "good news" to unchurched people in an environment of love, acceptance, and forgiveness.
I believe that God has led us to be sensitive to the fears, hang-ups, and needs of unbelievers in our small group meetings and worship services. The Apostle Paul advised that speaking in tongues seems Iike foolishness to unbelievers. Paul didn't say tongues were foolish, only that they appear foolish to unbelievers. Paul said in 1 Corinthians 13 that if I speak in the tongue of an angel but don’t have love, it ends up being noise. I take this to mean that the supernatural gift of love must be subordinated to the common gift of love.
The fruit of the spirit is, first of all, love. Love is what seeks the best for its object. If the exercise of a spiritual gift (any gift: teaching, tongues, wisdom, etc.) is not going to be in the best interests of the person that I am called to love, then I need to set aside the exercise of that gift. All of God’s gifts have to be exercised under God’s control. Spirit control trumps spiritual giftedness - always, and for every gift.
God seeks worshippers that worship Him in spirit and truth (John 4:23). Worship that is in spirit and truth comes from the heart. I believe we can express our deep love and appreciation to God in a way that makes sense to the unchurched who are our guests. As newcomers in an unknown environment they interpret what they see and hear. Other churches embrace a mission that is different from ours. I think every church needs to prayerfully discover God's direction for their story and stick with it.
_________________________________________
There has probably been no issue more divisive in the body of Christ than the expression of Charismatic gifts. I encourage pastors to be proactive on this subject. An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure. Here are some things I have done over the years to keep these issues from derailing what God wants to do through CTK:
1. I have used the shorthand “no weirdness” to inoculate the environment from extreme elements. In some cases people have been offended by this phrase, but I have to question how anyone could be. The opposite of “no weirdness” of course is “weirdness.” God is the author of the supernatural, but not the strange.
2. I try to correct privately whenever possible. I have found that when people come into our services and prophecy, speak in tongues, play tambourines, et al that it works best on most occasions to meet with them privately and gently instruct them on the nature of CTK, and what God has been calling us to. 99% of the time I have seen good results from these meetings. People appreciate knowing what the boundaries are, and often are very happy to comply.
3. I think it is important to have a response ready for questions on this topic. Become conversant in the five paragraphs above. I believe it is also wise to have a plan in your mind for how you will handle Charismatic expressions if they occur in your public worship. When there is a manifestation you will have a “teachable moment” in which you can show great leadership if you are prepared.
A hallmark of CTK is group before individual welfare. This is actually a very significant commitment. In some churches, the entire body suffers so as to not offend a particular individual and what they perceive to be their needs. This is not body life, this is cancer. Better to deal directly with individuals, to provide the opportunities needed for the greater group. In keeping with the heart of Christ, the needs of others come first.
_____________________________________
One time there was a lady in one of our Worship Centers who was doing “arm art” during worship. By “arm art” I mean her arms were flailing in strange contortions in sync with the music. She sat up front where no one could possibly miss her. She was a huge distraction to meaningful, heartfelt worship. I met with her and lovingly informed her of how distracting her worship style was. I also asked her from then on to not allow her arms to come above her waist during the music. Was this an awkward conversation? You bet. But I believe that most people at CTK appreciated that I showed some leadership and dealt with the situation. I put the good of the group ahead of the needs of an individual. I put feet to our mission statement, especially the part about “reaching out effectively to unchurched people.”
________________________________
The job of a good leader is to articulate a vision that others are inspired to follow. The definition of good leadership always comes back to what the leader says we stand for and how that leader makes everybody in an organization understand how to make that vision active. A lot of people write mission statements, but their words don’t come off the page. Leadership is about making a vision happen – what I call “vision acts.” If you say you’re about something, then what activities in your company indicate the reality behind these words?
- Lorraine Monroe
Occasionally someone will express the wish that we would "take it further." I am all for that if “take it further" means a deeper sense of awe, reverence, and love for God. If however, "take it further" means behaving in a way that is comfortable for those from a Pentecostal or charismatic background, but not for others, then the answer is no. This is not because we don't appreciate our Pentecostal and charismatic friends. We do. They have a rich spiritual heritage and have contributed much to the body of Christ. It is just that the practice of a physically demonstrative or emotionalIy driven form of worship is not in harmony with our mission of effectively presenting the "good news" to unchurched people in an environment of love, acceptance, and forgiveness.
I believe that God has led us to be sensitive to the fears, hang-ups, and needs of unbelievers in our small group meetings and worship services. The Apostle Paul advised that speaking in tongues seems Iike foolishness to unbelievers. Paul didn't say tongues were foolish, only that they appear foolish to unbelievers. Paul said in 1 Corinthians 13 that if I speak in the tongue of an angel but don’t have love, it ends up being noise. I take this to mean that the supernatural gift of love must be subordinated to the common gift of love.
The fruit of the spirit is, first of all, love. Love is what seeks the best for its object. If the exercise of a spiritual gift (any gift: teaching, tongues, wisdom, etc.) is not going to be in the best interests of the person that I am called to love, then I need to set aside the exercise of that gift. All of God’s gifts have to be exercised under God’s control. Spirit control trumps spiritual giftedness - always, and for every gift.
God seeks worshippers that worship Him in spirit and truth (John 4:23). Worship that is in spirit and truth comes from the heart. I believe we can express our deep love and appreciation to God in a way that makes sense to the unchurched who are our guests. As newcomers in an unknown environment they interpret what they see and hear. Other churches embrace a mission that is different from ours. I think every church needs to prayerfully discover God's direction for their story and stick with it.
_________________________________________
There has probably been no issue more divisive in the body of Christ than the expression of Charismatic gifts. I encourage pastors to be proactive on this subject. An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure. Here are some things I have done over the years to keep these issues from derailing what God wants to do through CTK:
1. I have used the shorthand “no weirdness” to inoculate the environment from extreme elements. In some cases people have been offended by this phrase, but I have to question how anyone could be. The opposite of “no weirdness” of course is “weirdness.” God is the author of the supernatural, but not the strange.
2. I try to correct privately whenever possible. I have found that when people come into our services and prophecy, speak in tongues, play tambourines, et al that it works best on most occasions to meet with them privately and gently instruct them on the nature of CTK, and what God has been calling us to. 99% of the time I have seen good results from these meetings. People appreciate knowing what the boundaries are, and often are very happy to comply.
3. I think it is important to have a response ready for questions on this topic. Become conversant in the five paragraphs above. I believe it is also wise to have a plan in your mind for how you will handle Charismatic expressions if they occur in your public worship. When there is a manifestation you will have a “teachable moment” in which you can show great leadership if you are prepared.
A hallmark of CTK is group before individual welfare. This is actually a very significant commitment. In some churches, the entire body suffers so as to not offend a particular individual and what they perceive to be their needs. This is not body life, this is cancer. Better to deal directly with individuals, to provide the opportunities needed for the greater group. In keeping with the heart of Christ, the needs of others come first.
_____________________________________
One time there was a lady in one of our Worship Centers who was doing “arm art” during worship. By “arm art” I mean her arms were flailing in strange contortions in sync with the music. She sat up front where no one could possibly miss her. She was a huge distraction to meaningful, heartfelt worship. I met with her and lovingly informed her of how distracting her worship style was. I also asked her from then on to not allow her arms to come above her waist during the music. Was this an awkward conversation? You bet. But I believe that most people at CTK appreciated that I showed some leadership and dealt with the situation. I put the good of the group ahead of the needs of an individual. I put feet to our mission statement, especially the part about “reaching out effectively to unchurched people.”
________________________________
The job of a good leader is to articulate a vision that others are inspired to follow. The definition of good leadership always comes back to what the leader says we stand for and how that leader makes everybody in an organization understand how to make that vision active. A lot of people write mission statements, but their words don’t come off the page. Leadership is about making a vision happen – what I call “vision acts.” If you say you’re about something, then what activities in your company indicate the reality behind these words?
- Lorraine Monroe
Air
One of our priorities at CTK is worship. We say that we want to make worship our lifestyle, not just what we do when we come together to sing, teach and pray. But there is no question that what happens when we come together in our worship services sets a tone for the worship we want to see during the week. This means that the worship leaders must be the lead worshippers.
Elijah Tadema, our new Director of Worship at the CTK Burlington Worship Center, recently sat down with the members of the worship team and told them "When we get together for worship practice we are not just going to practice our music, we are going to practice our worship - we are going to practice worshipping." I like that. After dealing with the technical details of the upcoming service (transitions, etc.) the team spends time worshipping together. Elijah understands that skillful worship leading involves both hands and heart. To be tuned up instrumentally, but not tuned up spiritually, is to be half-prepared. Spiritual ends require spiritual means.
To mount an effective attack on the enemy, you must develop both an "air war" and "ground war." The air war is your weekly service; your presentation ministry. The ground war is your small groups; your personal ministry. Your air attack gives cover for your ground attack. Your ground attack retains the advances made from the air (spiritually, things are softened up by preaching, but the ground is won and held in community). Worship Centers lacking a strong air attack (teaching, worship) will have few newcomers. Worship Centers lacking a strong ground attack (small groups) will have poor retention (the revolving door).
Elijah Tadema, our new Director of Worship at the CTK Burlington Worship Center, recently sat down with the members of the worship team and told them "When we get together for worship practice we are not just going to practice our music, we are going to practice our worship - we are going to practice worshipping." I like that. After dealing with the technical details of the upcoming service (transitions, etc.) the team spends time worshipping together. Elijah understands that skillful worship leading involves both hands and heart. To be tuned up instrumentally, but not tuned up spiritually, is to be half-prepared. Spiritual ends require spiritual means.
To mount an effective attack on the enemy, you must develop both an "air war" and "ground war." The air war is your weekly service; your presentation ministry. The ground war is your small groups; your personal ministry. Your air attack gives cover for your ground attack. Your ground attack retains the advances made from the air (spiritually, things are softened up by preaching, but the ground is won and held in community). Worship Centers lacking a strong air attack (teaching, worship) will have few newcomers. Worship Centers lacking a strong ground attack (small groups) will have poor retention (the revolving door).
Bar
Where you set "the bar" for leadership in your ministry is one of the most important decisions you will make. May I suggest that you consider setting the bar lower instead of higher? Before you burn me at the stake as a heretic, let me explain by first telling you a story:
I was once in a doctoral class led by John Maxwell, who has written numerous books on leadership. In a particular class session we got on the subject of small groups and Maxwell, who at the time was pastoring a large church in San Diego, California, USA, said emphatically (not sure he ever says anything differently), "Small groups don't work." He went on to explain: "You cannot find enough qualified leaders to sustain a church organized by small groups. You'll run out of qualified people to lead groups long before you run out of people who need to be in groups." I hope you "listened" carefully to what he just said. Did you pick up on the key word? It's the word that I would say doesn't describe the leadership limitation, but actually creates it. It's the word "qualified."
The word "qualified" speaks to the bar for entry to leadership. It may be code for the bar being set artificially too high. "Qualified" says that we (the organized church) have set a standard for leadership that goes beyond the person being a follower of Christ. So here is what I actually heard Maxwell say, "As high as I want to set the bar for leadership - and I want to set it pretty high - there are not enough people in the average church who can clear that bar; certainly not enough of them to organize in groups of ten."
I have agreed and benefitted greatly from John Maxwell's insights into leadership and organizations, but this is a place where I part company with him, and many other evangelical leaders. I believe that the lack of "qualified" people is not the real problem. The real problem is between our ears, in the expectations that we have for people. We do not trust God to use real, broken, average - and dare I say it? - unqualified people to do His work. When it comes to leadership potential in the body of Christ, we have a scarcity mentality. That is, unless we don't set the bar that high.
There is an abundance of potential leaders for small groups, but only if you make the job description "do-able" for the average person. This is why I am careful to speak of "facilitating" a group, not "leading" it. (There are a limited number of people who feel they can "lead" others; there is a much larger group of people who can "facilitate" a group meeting.) This is why I am intentional to call the Bible portion of the group meeting a "Bible discussion" and not a "Bible study." (There are a limited number of people who know the Bible well enough to study and teach it; there are a lot of people who can lead a discussion about it.) Steve Mason, the founding pastor of CTK in Bellingham, used to say, "If you can invite your friends over for a BBQ and figure out how many hot dog buns you need, you have what it takes to facilitate a small group." When you set the bar low enough, you can get a lot of people over it.
This business of setting the bar lower is counter-intuitive. There is something in us that wants to "raise the bar." But "raising the bar" can have the opposite effect on followers as we might imagine. For instance, if you say, "We need godly, dedicated Christian leaders to lead small groups" you might imagine that most Christians will respond by thinking, "Yes, and I will rise up to be that person you are talking about." In reality, most Christians respond by saying, "Well count me out then, because I'm not there yet." You see, people have inside information on themselves, and they do not perceive themselves to be "qualified." Quite the contrary. The challenge before us as leaders is to let them know that God can use them just as they are, right where they are. Raising the bar, instead of elevating their estimation of their leadership potential, can diminish it.
How do you set the bar appropriately - for most people to clear it? One way is through stories. The stories you tell help to "set the bar." If, for instance, you tell a story about a small group leader who has a Bible college education and is leading his group through a verse-by-verse study of the book of Revelation (and how wonderful that is), you have subliminally communicated what you view to be "success." Do you know what else you have done? You have unwittingly just caused 75% of the adults in your ministry to check the "No" box under "Am I qualified (there's the word again!) to lead a small group?" If on the other hand you tell the story of a person who, though only a few months old in their faith, is facilitating a group of friends who are discussing their faith and sharing what they're learning, you have now pre-qualified 75% of the adults in your ministry to say, "I could do that."
When I tell stories from my own small group experience, I try to share openly about my own lack of qualifiedness (not sure this is a word). I tell about how questions came up in the group that I could not answer, or of times when needs surfaced to which no one knew how to respond (reality for many small group leaders). By sharing from a point of weakness, not strength, I validate the "normal" small group experience and let small group leaders know that they don't need to be "The Bible Answer Man," only a vessel for the Lord to use. In effect, I am keeping the bar low enough where they can continue to clear it.
I am well aware that I may be the only pastor in America suggesting that you set the bar for entry to leadership lower instead of higher. But as exhibit A in my defense I would present Jesus. If he believed in the leadership potential of Peter, James and me, then I have to believe that I can believe in the Petes and Jims that I'm working with.
----------
The last two decades have proven Maxwell absolutely wrong. There are churches around the world now approaching millions of people and they are ALL organized around the volunteer leadership of small group leaders. The largest churches in the world are cell churches. These churches are not churches of thousands or even tens of thousands, but churches of hundreds of thousands. Movements are always decentralized and spread through the masses of average people. There are plenty of potential leaders out there.
------------
Ok, I hear the question already. "Aren't there any qualification for leadership?" Yes. The guide that has served me well over the years is the "pointed in the right direction" guide. I ask, "Is this person pointed in the right direction?" That is, are they a follower of Christ? They may not have arrived yet. They may actually have a long way to go. But if they are pointed in the right direction, time is on their side. And when you take a view of leadership that says that "leaders are fellow-strugglers" it says that they can facilitate a group, even though they may not be as far down the path as others in the group. That approach would not be possible in a context where it is implied that the group leader must be advanced in his faith from those attending the group. This is why it is so important that you take care where you set the bar!
I was once in a doctoral class led by John Maxwell, who has written numerous books on leadership. In a particular class session we got on the subject of small groups and Maxwell, who at the time was pastoring a large church in San Diego, California, USA, said emphatically (not sure he ever says anything differently), "Small groups don't work." He went on to explain: "You cannot find enough qualified leaders to sustain a church organized by small groups. You'll run out of qualified people to lead groups long before you run out of people who need to be in groups." I hope you "listened" carefully to what he just said. Did you pick up on the key word? It's the word that I would say doesn't describe the leadership limitation, but actually creates it. It's the word "qualified."
The word "qualified" speaks to the bar for entry to leadership. It may be code for the bar being set artificially too high. "Qualified" says that we (the organized church) have set a standard for leadership that goes beyond the person being a follower of Christ. So here is what I actually heard Maxwell say, "As high as I want to set the bar for leadership - and I want to set it pretty high - there are not enough people in the average church who can clear that bar; certainly not enough of them to organize in groups of ten."
I have agreed and benefitted greatly from John Maxwell's insights into leadership and organizations, but this is a place where I part company with him, and many other evangelical leaders. I believe that the lack of "qualified" people is not the real problem. The real problem is between our ears, in the expectations that we have for people. We do not trust God to use real, broken, average - and dare I say it? - unqualified people to do His work. When it comes to leadership potential in the body of Christ, we have a scarcity mentality. That is, unless we don't set the bar that high.
There is an abundance of potential leaders for small groups, but only if you make the job description "do-able" for the average person. This is why I am careful to speak of "facilitating" a group, not "leading" it. (There are a limited number of people who feel they can "lead" others; there is a much larger group of people who can "facilitate" a group meeting.) This is why I am intentional to call the Bible portion of the group meeting a "Bible discussion" and not a "Bible study." (There are a limited number of people who know the Bible well enough to study and teach it; there are a lot of people who can lead a discussion about it.) Steve Mason, the founding pastor of CTK in Bellingham, used to say, "If you can invite your friends over for a BBQ and figure out how many hot dog buns you need, you have what it takes to facilitate a small group." When you set the bar low enough, you can get a lot of people over it.
This business of setting the bar lower is counter-intuitive. There is something in us that wants to "raise the bar." But "raising the bar" can have the opposite effect on followers as we might imagine. For instance, if you say, "We need godly, dedicated Christian leaders to lead small groups" you might imagine that most Christians will respond by thinking, "Yes, and I will rise up to be that person you are talking about." In reality, most Christians respond by saying, "Well count me out then, because I'm not there yet." You see, people have inside information on themselves, and they do not perceive themselves to be "qualified." Quite the contrary. The challenge before us as leaders is to let them know that God can use them just as they are, right where they are. Raising the bar, instead of elevating their estimation of their leadership potential, can diminish it.
How do you set the bar appropriately - for most people to clear it? One way is through stories. The stories you tell help to "set the bar." If, for instance, you tell a story about a small group leader who has a Bible college education and is leading his group through a verse-by-verse study of the book of Revelation (and how wonderful that is), you have subliminally communicated what you view to be "success." Do you know what else you have done? You have unwittingly just caused 75% of the adults in your ministry to check the "No" box under "Am I qualified (there's the word again!) to lead a small group?" If on the other hand you tell the story of a person who, though only a few months old in their faith, is facilitating a group of friends who are discussing their faith and sharing what they're learning, you have now pre-qualified 75% of the adults in your ministry to say, "I could do that."
When I tell stories from my own small group experience, I try to share openly about my own lack of qualifiedness (not sure this is a word). I tell about how questions came up in the group that I could not answer, or of times when needs surfaced to which no one knew how to respond (reality for many small group leaders). By sharing from a point of weakness, not strength, I validate the "normal" small group experience and let small group leaders know that they don't need to be "The Bible Answer Man," only a vessel for the Lord to use. In effect, I am keeping the bar low enough where they can continue to clear it.
I am well aware that I may be the only pastor in America suggesting that you set the bar for entry to leadership lower instead of higher. But as exhibit A in my defense I would present Jesus. If he believed in the leadership potential of Peter, James and me, then I have to believe that I can believe in the Petes and Jims that I'm working with.
----------
The last two decades have proven Maxwell absolutely wrong. There are churches around the world now approaching millions of people and they are ALL organized around the volunteer leadership of small group leaders. The largest churches in the world are cell churches. These churches are not churches of thousands or even tens of thousands, but churches of hundreds of thousands. Movements are always decentralized and spread through the masses of average people. There are plenty of potential leaders out there.
------------
Ok, I hear the question already. "Aren't there any qualification for leadership?" Yes. The guide that has served me well over the years is the "pointed in the right direction" guide. I ask, "Is this person pointed in the right direction?" That is, are they a follower of Christ? They may not have arrived yet. They may actually have a long way to go. But if they are pointed in the right direction, time is on their side. And when you take a view of leadership that says that "leaders are fellow-strugglers" it says that they can facilitate a group, even though they may not be as far down the path as others in the group. That approach would not be possible in a context where it is implied that the group leader must be advanced in his faith from those attending the group. This is why it is so important that you take care where you set the bar!
Balance
Balance is not very sexy, or cool. What is deemed newsworthy is often extreme in one direction or the other. This is true in ministry, as well. The ministry that is extremely (and then fill-in-the-blank)….evangelistic, Calvinistic, dogmatic….gets noticed. But for long-term effectiveness balance yields the best results, in your personal life and in your ministry.
Here are some areas in which to strike a balance:
*Broad *Deep
*Fellowship *Worship
*Freedom *Accountability
*Grace *Holiness
*Evangelism *Discipleship
*Community *Outreach
A wise, older leader once gave me a good piece of advice: “Lean against the prevailing wind.” If you find yourself preaching about grace all the time, maybe balance that with a message on holiness, etc. So much of spirituality is both/and.
One of the things I like about our mission statement at CTK is its sense of balance. Our mission defines who we want to be, and what we want to do. It calls for us be an authentic Christian community that effectively reaches out. It balances community with outreach.
It was said of Abraham Lincoln that he was “a man of steel and velvet.” That is the same sort of balance we see in Christ (full of grace and truth) and in His expectations for His church (speaking the truth in love).
Why don’t we see a greater emphasis on balance in the body of Christ?
In what areas of your personal life do you need to find a better balance?
In what areas of your ministry are you seeking greater balance?
Read the following excerpt from Mark Eberhart’s book Why Things Break, discussing “what went wrong” in the Space Shuttle Challenger disaster. What application does this have to your ministry?
When ignited, each section of the booster expands in response to the tremendous heat and pressure of the exhaust gases produced through the burning of the solid rocket fuel. During this expansion, something has to seal the joints between the sections of the booster, if hot gases are to be prevented from pouring through the joints. Two quarter-inch rubber O-rings were used for this purpose. They were to expand rapidly, sealing any gaps between the sections.
For about six months before the Challenger explosion, Roger Boisjoly had been concerned that as the O-rings became cold they would expand more slowly than required to seal the booster sections. If this were to occur, the escaping gases could burn into the external fuel tank containing the liquid hydrogen and oxygen, causing it to explode.
Here are some areas in which to strike a balance:
*Broad *Deep
*Fellowship *Worship
*Freedom *Accountability
*Grace *Holiness
*Evangelism *Discipleship
*Community *Outreach
A wise, older leader once gave me a good piece of advice: “Lean against the prevailing wind.” If you find yourself preaching about grace all the time, maybe balance that with a message on holiness, etc. So much of spirituality is both/and.
One of the things I like about our mission statement at CTK is its sense of balance. Our mission defines who we want to be, and what we want to do. It calls for us be an authentic Christian community that effectively reaches out. It balances community with outreach.
It was said of Abraham Lincoln that he was “a man of steel and velvet.” That is the same sort of balance we see in Christ (full of grace and truth) and in His expectations for His church (speaking the truth in love).
Why don’t we see a greater emphasis on balance in the body of Christ?
In what areas of your personal life do you need to find a better balance?
In what areas of your ministry are you seeking greater balance?
Read the following excerpt from Mark Eberhart’s book Why Things Break, discussing “what went wrong” in the Space Shuttle Challenger disaster. What application does this have to your ministry?
When ignited, each section of the booster expands in response to the tremendous heat and pressure of the exhaust gases produced through the burning of the solid rocket fuel. During this expansion, something has to seal the joints between the sections of the booster, if hot gases are to be prevented from pouring through the joints. Two quarter-inch rubber O-rings were used for this purpose. They were to expand rapidly, sealing any gaps between the sections.
For about six months before the Challenger explosion, Roger Boisjoly had been concerned that as the O-rings became cold they would expand more slowly than required to seal the booster sections. If this were to occur, the escaping gases could burn into the external fuel tank containing the liquid hydrogen and oxygen, causing it to explode.
Counseling
I should have seen it coming. Sunday, following the service, several people lined up to see if they could "get some time with me" this week. Why should I have seen this coming? Because the holidays are over, the winter is getting long, and depression is setting in. All the "stuff" that people put on the back burner during the holidays piles up and makes for a counseling-filled January.
Pastors and other Christian leaders, if they are not careful, can soon find their schedules filled to overflowing meeting with folks. I say "if they are not careful" because I believe that leaders should take care to not allow this to happen. First, because there are others in the body who are better equipped (I find that very few pastors feel qualified as counselors in spite of the Competent to Counsel course available through CTKU!). Second, because a leader's time needs to be balanced between working "in" the ministry, and working "on" the ministry.
I think a good rule of thumb is that a pastor should not spend more than six hours per week counseling. Six hours would mean two one-hour session on three different days, or three one-hour session on two different days. Most professional counselors will tell you that six hours is a lot because for every hour spent counseling there is additional time spent preparing and processing. Plus there is an emotional "weight" to some counseling sessions that far outweighs the hour.
How can a pastor care for increasing numbers of people, yet limit his counseling load? The answer is found in this principle: A pastor's job is not so much to do the ministry, as to see that the ministry gets done. Along these lines, it is not necessary for the pastor to counsel all the people, but to see to it that all of the people get the counsel they need.
It's important for a pastor to have a relationship with a Christian Counselor. If you do not know of a good Christian counselor in the area, do some research. Ask some veteran pastors in the area whom they refer to when they do. Contact Christian counseling associations to find counselors who may practice in your area.
Once you identify a trustworthy counselor, spend some time building the relationship with the counselor so that you feel comfortable sending folks to him/her when needed. Go to coffee and share your vision for ministry and outreach. Let them do the same. See if you have a connection. If not, keep looking.
Here are some of the ways I've worked out the financial arrangements with a Christian counselor:
1) The individual/couple pays for the sessions. In many cases people are able to afford counseling even when they think they can't (and maybe they can't NOT AFFORD counseling). In some cases you may have to counsel them to rearrange their budget to afford it (no going out to eat, etc.). If you are unsure, ask: "Are you in a position to pay for counseling?" If so, your job is going to be to point them in the direction of a counselor that will be trustworthy.
2) CTK pays for the sessions. There are times when folks really can't afford counseling, but nevertheless need to be able to see one. This is a great opportunity for CTK to have a significant ministry. Just have the counselor send the bill to CTK HQ marked for your Worship Center.
3) Coupons. See if the counselor will sell you a few coupons you can give to the couple for free counseling sessions. If you are referring a lot of people to a counselor you might recommend 10 coupons for the cost of 8, or something like that. The thing that is nice about coupons is that you can have them in your possession and give a troubled person something tangible when they walk out of your office. The bad part is that they may not actually go and redeem the coupon.
One counselor I worked with gave me some "freebie" coupons. Under normal circumstances I would refer individuals and couples to him and they would pay him on a sliding-scale fee (based on their income). In extreme cases the counselor trusted me to give out a "freebie" coupon, where the counselor would counsel them gratis. I think this was the counselor's way of participating in CTK ministry, and a way of appreciating our support of his.
4) Co-op. Pay half of the counseling session cost (or some other ratio). Have the counselor bill the individual/couple for part, and us for part. I like this idea when it is possible, because studies show that people take counseling more seriously even if the individual has a minor buy-in financially.
As a rule of thumb, I've used 1% of giving as monies that can be given away to help others. So in a
Center where there is $5000/mo. giving, then $50/mo. would just be given away with no strings attached. You might not be able to get even one counseling session for $50, but you might want to do something similar in terms of picking a percentage that you want to go toward helping people.
The frequency of counseling is usually front-loaded - more frequency to begin with, and then backing off. In some extremely dramatic cases people may need to see a counselor more than once a week to get through the trauma. Often a once-a-week meeting is appropriate, tapering to every other week, and then monthly. It is important for you as the pastor to be clear about the commitments you are making, as the individuals needing counseling and the counselor will be happy to meet as frequently as possible, and there is little resistance to that notion if the church is picking up the tab.
----------------
Having spent too much time in counseling myself during some seasons of my ministry, I've reflected on why I allowed that to happen. Here are some of my conclusions:
1. Counseling is a buzz. The immediacy of helping someone, of entering into the crisis, can be intoxicating. It makes you feel needed. It makes you feel important. It makes you feel helpful. Be careful here. Don't get sucked in by your own neediness.
2. Inability to say no. When someone asks, "Pastor, can I meet with you this week?" how do you say "No."? After all, you're the pastor. The answer is "gracefully" but you have to be prepared. I've learned to follow up with some questions of my own, like, "What would you like to talk about?" If their answer tells me it's counseling they need, I often say, "Well, you need to know that I do not consider my self a trained counselor. The main things I'm equipped to help folks with are common sense, biblical solutions. If you feel that you need a therapist I would be glad to point you in the direction of a friend of mine."
Pastors and other Christian leaders, if they are not careful, can soon find their schedules filled to overflowing meeting with folks. I say "if they are not careful" because I believe that leaders should take care to not allow this to happen. First, because there are others in the body who are better equipped (I find that very few pastors feel qualified as counselors in spite of the Competent to Counsel course available through CTKU!). Second, because a leader's time needs to be balanced between working "in" the ministry, and working "on" the ministry.
I think a good rule of thumb is that a pastor should not spend more than six hours per week counseling. Six hours would mean two one-hour session on three different days, or three one-hour session on two different days. Most professional counselors will tell you that six hours is a lot because for every hour spent counseling there is additional time spent preparing and processing. Plus there is an emotional "weight" to some counseling sessions that far outweighs the hour.
How can a pastor care for increasing numbers of people, yet limit his counseling load? The answer is found in this principle: A pastor's job is not so much to do the ministry, as to see that the ministry gets done. Along these lines, it is not necessary for the pastor to counsel all the people, but to see to it that all of the people get the counsel they need.
It's important for a pastor to have a relationship with a Christian Counselor. If you do not know of a good Christian counselor in the area, do some research. Ask some veteran pastors in the area whom they refer to when they do. Contact Christian counseling associations to find counselors who may practice in your area.
Once you identify a trustworthy counselor, spend some time building the relationship with the counselor so that you feel comfortable sending folks to him/her when needed. Go to coffee and share your vision for ministry and outreach. Let them do the same. See if you have a connection. If not, keep looking.
Here are some of the ways I've worked out the financial arrangements with a Christian counselor:
1) The individual/couple pays for the sessions. In many cases people are able to afford counseling even when they think they can't (and maybe they can't NOT AFFORD counseling). In some cases you may have to counsel them to rearrange their budget to afford it (no going out to eat, etc.). If you are unsure, ask: "Are you in a position to pay for counseling?" If so, your job is going to be to point them in the direction of a counselor that will be trustworthy.
2) CTK pays for the sessions. There are times when folks really can't afford counseling, but nevertheless need to be able to see one. This is a great opportunity for CTK to have a significant ministry. Just have the counselor send the bill to CTK HQ marked for your Worship Center.
3) Coupons. See if the counselor will sell you a few coupons you can give to the couple for free counseling sessions. If you are referring a lot of people to a counselor you might recommend 10 coupons for the cost of 8, or something like that. The thing that is nice about coupons is that you can have them in your possession and give a troubled person something tangible when they walk out of your office. The bad part is that they may not actually go and redeem the coupon.
One counselor I worked with gave me some "freebie" coupons. Under normal circumstances I would refer individuals and couples to him and they would pay him on a sliding-scale fee (based on their income). In extreme cases the counselor trusted me to give out a "freebie" coupon, where the counselor would counsel them gratis. I think this was the counselor's way of participating in CTK ministry, and a way of appreciating our support of his.
4) Co-op. Pay half of the counseling session cost (or some other ratio). Have the counselor bill the individual/couple for part, and us for part. I like this idea when it is possible, because studies show that people take counseling more seriously even if the individual has a minor buy-in financially.
As a rule of thumb, I've used 1% of giving as monies that can be given away to help others. So in a
Center where there is $5000/mo. giving, then $50/mo. would just be given away with no strings attached. You might not be able to get even one counseling session for $50, but you might want to do something similar in terms of picking a percentage that you want to go toward helping people.
The frequency of counseling is usually front-loaded - more frequency to begin with, and then backing off. In some extremely dramatic cases people may need to see a counselor more than once a week to get through the trauma. Often a once-a-week meeting is appropriate, tapering to every other week, and then monthly. It is important for you as the pastor to be clear about the commitments you are making, as the individuals needing counseling and the counselor will be happy to meet as frequently as possible, and there is little resistance to that notion if the church is picking up the tab.
----------------
Having spent too much time in counseling myself during some seasons of my ministry, I've reflected on why I allowed that to happen. Here are some of my conclusions:
1. Counseling is a buzz. The immediacy of helping someone, of entering into the crisis, can be intoxicating. It makes you feel needed. It makes you feel important. It makes you feel helpful. Be careful here. Don't get sucked in by your own neediness.
2. Inability to say no. When someone asks, "Pastor, can I meet with you this week?" how do you say "No."? After all, you're the pastor. The answer is "gracefully" but you have to be prepared. I've learned to follow up with some questions of my own, like, "What would you like to talk about?" If their answer tells me it's counseling they need, I often say, "Well, you need to know that I do not consider my self a trained counselor. The main things I'm equipped to help folks with are common sense, biblical solutions. If you feel that you need a therapist I would be glad to point you in the direction of a friend of mine."
Buildings
At CTK 95% of our worship services take place in rented facilities. This is opposite the traditional church, where 95% of worship services happen in owned facilities. Why do we go against the flow? One of the reasons is financial. It cost much less to rent facilities one day a week, than to own them seven days a week. This frees up more resources for ministry and outreach. But probably the bigger reason is philosophical. Buildings can get in the way. Buildings end up being the focus of a lot of attention (instead of people). In the process, buildings say something about where and when ministry happens, that is contrary to the "real people are the ministers" and "ministry happens out there" ideas that we want to propagate.
In his book "Radical Renewal: The problem of wineskins today", Howard A. Snyder lists five ways in which church buildings bear witness about the condition of the traditional church.
1. Church buildings are a witness to our immobility. What is more immovable than a church building? Christians are to be a mobile people. The gospel says, "Go," but our church buildings say, "Stay." The gospel says, "Seek the lost," but our temples say, "Let the lost seek the church."
2. Church buildings are a witness to our inflexibility. As soon as we erect a building, we cut down on our options by at least seventy-five percent. Once the building is up and in use, the church program and budget are largely determined. The problem, at heart, is not one of poor planning. It is a matter of the inherent limitations of church buildings. Buildings are by nature, inflexible and encourage inflexibility - or worse, stagnation.
3. Church buildings are a witness to our lack of fellowship. Church buildings may be wonderful places, but usually they are not friendly places. They are uncomfortable and impersonal. Church buildings are not made for fellowship, for koinonia in the biblical sense. Homes are. Church buildings are made for worship, but worship without fellowship becomes something cold and divorced from reality.
4. Church buildings are a witness to our pride. We insist that our church structures must be beautiful and well appointed - which usually means expensive - and justify this on the grounds that God deserves the best. But such thinking may be little more than the rationalizing of carnal pride. In fact, a fine church building may simply attract the Pharisees and repel the poor.
5. Church buildings are a witness to our divisions of class and race. The early church was a mix of rich and poor, Jew and Greek, black and white, ignorant and educated. But our church buildings are public advertisements that this is not true today. The fault here, of course, lies much deeper than mere architecture. But the building is a witness. It is a signpost telling the world of the church's class consciousness and exclusiveness.
At CTK we don't believe that there is anything wrong with owning buildings, but we recognize that there are trade-offs that come with a "permanent" home.
In his book "Radical Renewal: The problem of wineskins today", Howard A. Snyder lists five ways in which church buildings bear witness about the condition of the traditional church.
1. Church buildings are a witness to our immobility. What is more immovable than a church building? Christians are to be a mobile people. The gospel says, "Go," but our church buildings say, "Stay." The gospel says, "Seek the lost," but our temples say, "Let the lost seek the church."
2. Church buildings are a witness to our inflexibility. As soon as we erect a building, we cut down on our options by at least seventy-five percent. Once the building is up and in use, the church program and budget are largely determined. The problem, at heart, is not one of poor planning. It is a matter of the inherent limitations of church buildings. Buildings are by nature, inflexible and encourage inflexibility - or worse, stagnation.
3. Church buildings are a witness to our lack of fellowship. Church buildings may be wonderful places, but usually they are not friendly places. They are uncomfortable and impersonal. Church buildings are not made for fellowship, for koinonia in the biblical sense. Homes are. Church buildings are made for worship, but worship without fellowship becomes something cold and divorced from reality.
4. Church buildings are a witness to our pride. We insist that our church structures must be beautiful and well appointed - which usually means expensive - and justify this on the grounds that God deserves the best. But such thinking may be little more than the rationalizing of carnal pride. In fact, a fine church building may simply attract the Pharisees and repel the poor.
5. Church buildings are a witness to our divisions of class and race. The early church was a mix of rich and poor, Jew and Greek, black and white, ignorant and educated. But our church buildings are public advertisements that this is not true today. The fault here, of course, lies much deeper than mere architecture. But the building is a witness. It is a signpost telling the world of the church's class consciousness and exclusiveness.
At CTK we don't believe that there is anything wrong with owning buildings, but we recognize that there are trade-offs that come with a "permanent" home.
Few
Vilfredo Pareto was an Italian economist who developed what has been known as the Pareto Principle, also known as the law of the vital few. He noticed that 80% of the income in Italy came from 20% of the population. The Pareto Principle is the 80/20 rule, which says that 80% of the consequences come from 20% of the causes. It also implies that 20% of the results come from 80% of your efforts.
The Pareto Principle has various applications to ministry:
Activities: 20% of your events will yield 80% of the outreach
People: 20% of your leaders will yield 80% of the impact
Time: 20% of your hours will yield 80% of the results
Groups: 20% of your meetings will yield 80% of the productivity
Communications: 20% of your messages will yield 80% of the insights
Finance: 20% of your givers will yield 80% of your income
Marketing: 20% of your ads will yield 80% of your exposure
Wise leaders are aware of the disproportional impact of the vital few. Consequently, they do not treat all activities, people, time, groups, communications, finance, and marketing the same. They seek to leverage the 20/80 scenarios, and minimize 80/20 scenarios.
How does the Pareto Principle apply to your current ministry? What high-leverage aspects of the ministry need cultivation? What low-leverage aspects need pruning?
--------------
The Pareto Principle is a "rule of thumb" and should be kept in balance, particularly when it comes to people. It is not consistent with the Spirit of Christ to only give your attention to those who are "high producers." On the other hand, a good question is, "Where is God at work, and how can I cooperate with Him in what He's doing?"
The Pareto Principle has various applications to ministry:
Activities: 20% of your events will yield 80% of the outreach
People: 20% of your leaders will yield 80% of the impact
Time: 20% of your hours will yield 80% of the results
Groups: 20% of your meetings will yield 80% of the productivity
Communications: 20% of your messages will yield 80% of the insights
Finance: 20% of your givers will yield 80% of your income
Marketing: 20% of your ads will yield 80% of your exposure
Wise leaders are aware of the disproportional impact of the vital few. Consequently, they do not treat all activities, people, time, groups, communications, finance, and marketing the same. They seek to leverage the 20/80 scenarios, and minimize 80/20 scenarios.
How does the Pareto Principle apply to your current ministry? What high-leverage aspects of the ministry need cultivation? What low-leverage aspects need pruning?
--------------
The Pareto Principle is a "rule of thumb" and should be kept in balance, particularly when it comes to people. It is not consistent with the Spirit of Christ to only give your attention to those who are "high producers." On the other hand, a good question is, "Where is God at work, and how can I cooperate with Him in what He's doing?"
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)