Monday, April 17, 2006

Book

I had Mormon missionaries pay me a visit recently. I warned them that we might end up having a “lively” conversation, but they proceeded into their presentation undeterred. I was a little disheveled in my Saturday morning pajamas, but I braved the open doorway for about a half hour exchange. At one point they asked me if I had read the book of Mormon. I told them I had. They asked me what I thought. I told them I was unimpressed. I said, “When you read the Bible and the Book of Mormon, you realize that one of these books is truly beautiful, and the other has a lot of makeup on in an attempt to look beautiful.” I don’t have any problem putting the Bible up head-to-head with any other purported revelation. It more than holds its own. It is quite clearly in a league of its own, intrinsically. The Bible has the “ring of truth” to it. It is its own best evidence for what it claims to be.

Emile Cailliet, in his book Journey into the Light, describes his first encounter with the Bible. He did not believe in God (he was a naturalist). He was not religious (he was a philosopher). He was writing a book as a kind of self therapy. His wife gave him a Bible as a source. He had never read it before. He rushed into his study and began to read. Later he wrote:

I read, and read and read with an indescribable warmth surging within. I could not find words to express my awe and wonder. And suddenly the realization dawned upon me: This was the Book that would understand me. The very clue to the secret of human life was disclosed right there in everyday language.

The Word of God is truly living, and powerful, and sharper than any two-edged sword. As we get into the Bible, it gets into us. We interpret it, but it also interprets us. Martin Luther once commented, “The Bible is alive. It speaks to me. It has feet. It runs after me. It has hands. It lays hold of me.”

It measures six-by-nine
But it can fill the largest hall.

It measures six-by-nine
But it can touch the deepest need.

It measures six-by-nine
But it can reach any heart,
Bridge any gap,
Open any door.

Yet it only measures six-by-nine.

John Wesley wrote “I am a spirit come from God, and returning to God. I want to know one thing; the way to heaven. God himself has condescended to teach me the way. He has written it down in a book. Oh, give me that book! At any price give me the book of God. Let me be a man of one book.”

How long has it been since you spent some time with the Book? Not for study or sermon preparation. But for you?


[In the 90s I took the time to write out a Personal Doctrinal Statement...if you would be interested in the entire statement, email me...following are the first several paragraphs, dealing with Presuppositions, and my Beliefs about the Bible...]

For as long as I can remember, I have been interested in God. There is a good reason for this: As long as I can remember, He has been interested in me (1 John 4:19).

For me, the discussion of God (“Theology” - theos, God + logos, discourse) is no mere academic exercise. God is my Father, and I am His child. I am fascinated by His love for me, and enjoy spending time in His presence, hearing his words.

I am thankful for parents, teachers, pastors, and professors who have helped me to know Him better. The following statements summarize what I’ve come to know thus far.

My Presuppositions

Prior to stating my beliefs it would seem appropriate to reveal the presuppositions which have been the foundation for my conclusions.

I hold three primary assumptions in this statement of belief:

1. There is a God (Genesis 1:1).

2. This God has disclosed Himself to man (Psalm 19, Romans 1, I John 5:9-12, John 1:14, Philippians 2:5-11).

3. Man, by reason of his being in the image of God, is able to receive and comprehend God's revelation (Romans 1:19,20).

I am prepared to concede that these propositions are non-demonstrable and that I cling to them as true on the basis of a sovereign work in me that has caused faith (Deuteronomy 7:6-11; Romans 8:28-30). Yet, these presuppositions have corresponded accurately with the facts of the world around me.

My Beliefs About the Bible

The sources of information from which I have derived my beliefs regarding the Bible are two-fold: 1) from statements within the text of Scripture that make self-disclosure as to the Book's nature, and 2) from an examination of the phenomena which we find as Scripture. While I see the value of both means of investigation, I have given priority here to an exegesis and understanding of the statements which Scripture makes itself respecting its nature. [This is consistent with my approach in other religious inquiries.] As aids in this endeavor I have called upon reason, tradition and previous statements of faith.

I believe the Holy Scriptures of the Old and New Testaments to be the verbally and plenarily inspired and inerrant Word of God (II Timothy 3:16). I hold the Bible, as originally given through human agents (II Peter 1:21), to be without fallacy or error in all that it states and see this as a most crucial article of faith with implications for the entire life and practice of Christians everywhere (II Timothy 3:16,17), being that the Bible contains the full content of the extant written revelation of God for mankind. With the great fathers of Christian history I declare my unreserved confidence in the total trustworthiness of the Scriptures, believing that any view which imputes to them a lesser degree of inerrancy than total is in conflict with the Bible's self-testimony in general and with the teachings of Jesus Christ in particular. Out of obedience to the Lord of the Church I seek to submit myself wholeheartedly to His authoritative view of Holy Writ, and, by God's grace, to subsequent compliance with the direction found therein. (Adapted from the Ligonier Statement of October, 1973)

I believe the 66 books of the Bible to be "God's Word" (Matthew 15:6; John 10:35; Hebrews 4:12). As such the Bible stands alone, and cannot be categorized with other literature as to its character and content. It is the unique and recognized record of God's revelation to man. Amazingly, the Bible was composed over a period of 1500 years by over 35 human authors. Yet it over and over again declares itself to be the Word of God and is without contradiction in what it says. Its authority, influence, subject matter and supreme character set it apart as "The Book." Archeology, geography, history, science, psychology and Christian experience all confirm what Christ himself said nearly 2000 years ago, "Thy Word is Truth" (John 17:17).

I believe that God has manifested His Word to us in accord with the supreme purpose that He should receive the honor, glory and praise of His created order (Romans 5:2,11). The revelation of God (or about God) has provided man with a worthy object for love and devotion, has given him ground for faith and peace of mind, and has given him assurance of salvation in time and eternity.

Revelation

By revelation I mean "unveiling" (from Greek apocalypto), and in the realm of theology, the whole process by which God has made Himself known to man. This includes the general revelation of God in the human conscience (Romans 2:14-16), in nature (Psalm 19:1-4), in history (Acts 14:17; 17:24-30) and in man's thinking ability (Romans 1:18-20). It also incorporates several special forms of divine self-disclosure, such as Theophanies (Exodus 3:2f), dreams and visions (Numbers 12:6-10), miraculous events (Genesis 9), prophets (Exodus 4,7), apostles (Acts 1,10; I Corinthians 9,15), Jesus Christ (John 1:14,18; Hebrews 1:1f) and the Scriptures, which not only bear witness to the other modes of revelation but are themselves God's revelation.

These various methods of mediation are necessitated by the fact that God is transcendent (Isaiah 45:15), and man, by reason of the fall, has been impaired in his ability to receive Divine disclosure (I Corinthians 2:14; II Corinthians 4:4; Ephesians 2:1f; Romans 1:28). God has, then, by His grace, chosen to communicate propositionally and personally with sinful man (Titus 2:11-14); not simply to unleash facts, but to bring man into fellowship with God.

Inspiration

"Inspiration is that inexplicable working of the Holy Spirit whereby He guided the human authors of the Bible in choosing the very words they used in writing every portion of the original manuscripts, so that the Bible is in all parts infallible as to truth and final as to authority." The very writings are the product of God's creative breath (II Timothy 3:16), though the human imprint is unmistakable throughout. While there are various theories which have been proposed as a solution to this tension (that it is a divine product, yet produced by man) the position which reflects most accurately the teaching of Scripture is that inspiration is "concursive", involving the divine involvement of the Holy Spirit throughout the writing process (II Peter 1:21) so that the very words which were placed on the original manuscripts could be said to be "God-breathed." I believe that, in addition to at times revealing supernatural truth to the writers, the Holy Spirit was in sovereign control of the varied aspects of the literary process, including the author's background, experiences, literary ability, selection of sources (if utilized), vocabulary and emotions. Yet, the Holy Spirit at no point impaired human personality.

The extent of inspiration is clearly plenary, applying to all portions of Scripture (II Timothy 3:16) in both Testaments (I Timothy 5:18). The intensiveness of inspiration is definitely verbal, as this is evidenced by the claim of the classical text (II Timothy 3:16), emphasized in the testimony of Paul, that he spoke with "words...taught by the Spirit" (I Corinthians 2:13), and indicated by Christ when He declared that even the smallest part of a Hebrew word or letter could not be broken (Matthew 5:18).

Inerrancy

I believe that the Bible is inerrant, and that in all that it intends to assert there is not contradiction between it and truth (fact). Since the very words of Scripture are the product of God's creative breath, and since God's character is without flaw, error or imperfection (Titus 1:2; Numbers 23:19; Hebrews 6:18), the Scriptures likewise are without error. This fact is evidenced over and again from even the closest scrutiny of the sacred text. What difficulties that may remain (though few indeed) I believe can and will be accounted for when either more facts are uncovered, our interpretative processes are more properly applied, or we are enlightened in glorification. Until that time I choose to unflinchingly uphold the total inerrancy of Scripture. Within the structure of my theocentric (God-centered) world view, I will trust God and admit my own finiteness rather that set my reason up as judge and impugn Scripture.

Canonicity

The word "canon" means a rule or standard, and "in relation to the Bible it refers to the collection of books which passed a test of authenticity and authority" (Ryrie). The canonicity of the books of the Bible is not ultimately determined by man as much as it is observed by him. Man simply recognized the intrinsic properties within the 66 books of Scripture which set it apart as God-breathed, and thereby the infallible Word of God. This is possible due to the fact that God has throughout history made it clear when He is communicating, by self-authenticating that correspondence. Scripture likewise bears those inherent qualities by which it is evident that it is a divinely "expired" document. We may recognize that Scripture is God's Word as well as we would recognize that a diamond is a diamond. The substance of the authenticity is not external, but internal (I Thessalonians 1:5).

A priority of faith is necessary in the process of canonicity. The Holy Spirit bears witness with my spirit that these are God's Words (I Thessalonians 2:13; I John 5:9; 2:20,27; John 16:13,14).

While I admit to a certain subjectivity in this matter, I do not hold to a blind faith or faith in a vacuum, for there seem to be objective, identifiable evidences which have served as criteria by which the books were "discovered." Though none of these principles stand alone, together I believe they weave a formidable grid for man to recognize the special authority of God's Word:

1. Is the book AUTHORITATIVE? Does it ring with "Thus saith the Lord?"

2. Is the book PROPHETIC? Was it written by a prophet or apostle (or under them?)

3. Is the book AUTHENTIC? Was it written where, when and by whom it claims?

4. Is the book DYNAMIC? Does it change lives?

5. Is the book RECEIVED? Has the book been generally received by God's people?

6. Is the book ACCURATE? Is is free from any demonstrable, factual error?

7. Is the book CONGRUENT? Does it correlate with other scripture?

I believe that special strength is found within a synthesis of the first two principles so that we can say that those books which claim to be the Word of God and were written by an apostle or prophet (or someone under their auspices) are canonical (John 16:13). Likewise principle 5 has merit in that our belief in a sovereign God who is personally involved in the lives of believers would presuppose an overwhelming unanimity among God's people; something which has indeed occurred in relationship to the canonicity of Scripture.

As to whether the canon is closed, I concur with those throughout history who have thought that it is. This comes from an integration of Scriptural and Theological evidence. Particular Biblical evidence is gleaned from the contexts of Genesis 1,2 and Revelation 21,22. The parallels and fulfillments that are found in these passages, and the statement of Revelation 22:18,19, hint at limits of the canon. The book of Revelation appears to be the natural literary conclusion to the Bible, and is believed by many to be the last book written.

Theologically it would logically follow that if God has indeed preserved additional material to that which we presently have in our possession He would have revealed such to His church. But this has not taken place. Furthermore, because of the nature of the apostles and prophets as foundational in the initial organization of the church (Ephesians 2:20), I do not believe additional inscripturation to be a possibility at this later date, since the apostolic and prophetic offices were temporary and were not continued beyond the first century.

Authority

I believe that the Bible, when properly interpreted, asserts the ultimate and final standard of truth for faith, practice and understanding. As such it demands our inquiry (Acts 17:11), our submission (Hebrews 4:12), and our obedience (James 1:22; John 10:35). It is completely accurate and trustworthy in all matters to which it speaks, whether these be religious or not. While the Bible may be considered to be great literature, it is much more than this; it is the Word of God to us and our supreme, unchanging authority in a lawless age. Scripture is something with which we cannot enjoy the privilege of indifference; its divine character demands our allegiance.

Interpretation

Interpretation is the process of explicating the meaning of Scripture. It is both a science and an art since it involves both principle and skillful technique. "The basic principle of interpretation is to interpret plainly" (Ryrie). Normative interpretation begins with the concept that "When the plain sense makes good sense, seek no other sense." This involves an understanding of the words, context (both grammatical and historical) and the theme of the writing. It does not negate the use of figures of speech, idioms and phenomenal language, but instead allows for the complexities of human language with special hermeneutics. The believer can depend upon the Spirit to guide him "into all the truth" (John 16:13; I Cor. 2:6-16) so that he can enjoy the great profit of Scripture (II Timothy 3:15-17; John 17:17).

Preservation

Scripture clearly teaches that the Word of God will be eternally preserved (Psalm 119:89,152,160; Matthew 24:35; I Peter 1:23). God will evidently see to it that His Word will not be eliminated but will be perpetuated to all generations. Approximately 5000 New Testament manuscripts give evidence that God's Word has indeed been carefully preserved, and, in a trustworthy manner. It can be maintained safely that the Holy Spirit has guided and superintended the preservation of His Book throughout the centuries. To the extent that our Bible texts reflect the words and sense of the original manuscripts, we have God’s Word.

Pressure

All tasks carry with them a certain amount of pressure. Ministry has it’s unique combination of stresses. How you handle these stresses can “make or break” you. To better manage the pressure of ministry....

1. Understand where the pressure is coming from.

While stresses may feel similar, the origins may differ. Some possibilities:
• Spiritual opposition (we’re in a war)
• Personal life issues (challenges with spouse, kids, etc.)
• Organizational growth (more people, being understaffed, etc.)
• Personal work habits (laziness, poor planning, etc.)

The appropriate response to pressure will depend on where the pressure is coming from. Organizational stresses need organizational solutions. Spiritual stresses need spiritual solutions. Don’t try to organize your way out of a spiritual attack. Conversely, don’t try to pray your way out of disorganization. Proper diagnosis precedes proper remedy.

By the way, the enemy will exploit all of these pressures and more to get at you. I am convinced that many of his firy darts are natural, instead of supernatural. He knows that things as mundane as the laundry not being done can frustrate us. Don’t think that He doesn’t leverage any and all forms of pressure in our lives. He loves to use “the predictability of human nature” to his advantage.

2. Maintain your spiritual health at all times.

There is no substitute for a growing, vibrant personal life, particularly when you are under pressure. You are too busy not to pray. Ten minutes a day in the word, plus ten minutes per day in prayer (10+10) is the MINIMUM. Stay on your knees so the bullets keep flying over your head. Stephen Covey calls this “sharpening the saw.” Paul calls it “keeping in step with the Spirit.” Whatever you call it – a devotional life, quiet time, spiritual disciplines, etc. - don’t try to do ministry without it. Spiritual ends require spiritual means.

3. Remain sensitive to the “tragedy of the commons.”

As organizations grow, stresses come first to “common areas” – areas that are common to everyone. For instance, a receptionist takes calls for everyone. As there are more “everyones” there are more calls and more pressure. (At a certain point, with enough call volume, there may be a need for a second receptionist, or an automated phone system to keep things manageable.) The pastor himself is often a victim of this “tragedy of the commons.” For instance, the pastor is “the counselor” to everyone. At a certain point, the pastor needs to be referring people to other counselors (I think after a max of six counseling hours per week), or hiring an associate pastor. Common areas need to be monitored and reorganized for scalability, in order to protect from burnout.

4. Account for “project weight.”

The feeling of responsibility for a project can be called “project weight.” People feel more weight at certain times than others (e.g. a teaching pastor on Saturday night typically “feels the weight”). When you are in the process of reorganizing a ministry, starting another service, or launching another site, there is additional weight on your shoulders. Others should be more sensitive when a person is shouldering project weight. The weight needs to be redistributed when it gets too heavy, or when you feel like you’ve had to shoulder it for too long.

5. Pay back borrowed strength.

You can only borrow from tomorrow’s strength for so long, before you have to pay it back. If you have had a particularly stressful stretch of ministry (lots of crisis, meetings, spiritual warfare), you will need to compensate by taking an appropriate break, or by “coasting” for awhile. There is a divine rhythm with which God expects his children to be in sync. There is a sleep rhythm (16 hours awake, 8 hours asleep). There is the sabbath rhythm (six parts work, one part rest). There is the seasonal rhythm (fall, winter, spring, summer). Make sure that there is a downbeat in your life. And if you have borrowed from tomorrow’s strength by curtailing sleep, day’s off or vacations, catch up before the debt grows.

6. Change gears.

Instead of working the engine harder, get into a higher gear. With a higher gear ratio there is more speed, with greater efficiency. If we stay in too low of a gear too long we burn up the engine (and sadly, don’t get very far in the process). Change gears by delegating and redistributing the work load, sharing project weight with others, and maintaining a manageable span of care (5-7 direct reports). Use Sunday night or Monday to review your personal life plan, and prioritize.

7. Reach out.

I have probably not communicated this clearly enough, or often enough, but please know that I am on your side, and that you can call on me for support. If you need encouragement or counsel, or just a shoulder to cry on, I would count it a privilege to support you in what God has called you to do. If you are facing pressure or temptation, please don’t isolate, or become a victim. Do the extremely courageous thing, that many are too proud to do: reach out. At a time in my ministry when I was feeling overwhelmed, I did not reach out, and became a casualty. I would not want this for my enemies, much less my friends. By virtue of the fact that you are receiving this dMail, I take it that you are in ministry, and have an important role in the lives of others. Please don’t allow self-pity or impression management to get in the way of your health. Go the distance.

Effectiveness

When I was Christmas shopping I ran into some folks I had known from the past at CTK. I'll call them Bill and Mary. They left the church a couple years ago. They did not move out of the community. They left to attend another church. They left in a good way. They called me up and told me that they were leaving. They told me why. They blessed me as they were leaving, but they left just the same. I had not seen them in a while, but I had thought about them. So here we are in a major department store, standing face to face. These can be awkward moments for an ex-pastor, but we had a pleasant conversation. Once again, they were very encouraging to me. And something they said was instructive. They said, "We always really enjoyed your teaching." It echoed what they had told me when they left, "We are going to miss your teaching, but....."

Now think about that for a second. They enjoyed my teaching. But they left. How does that work? Let this be a lesson to us all: meaningful teaching can help to attract people to your ministry, but it is not enough to keep people in your ministry. What keeps people is: meaningful relationships and meaningful responsibilities. Bill and Mary did not find what they need, so they moved on. It was that simple. The teaching was not enough to keep them there. It seldom is.

I don't want to diminish the value of strong teaching. I don't think that you can grow a strong, healthy, replicating ministry without it. But it is not enough, in and of itself. If pastoral effectiveness consisted of good teaching, most of the pastors in America would be pastoring growing churches. But, in fact, some of the best teachers in the country you've never heard because they are pastoring small, stagnant churches.

True pastoral effectiveness is found in leadership - leading people toward meaningful relationships and meaningful responsibilities. I evidently didn't show good enough leadership for Bill and Mary. And my teaching, no matter how good, could not make up for it.

Here's the tell-tale: When Bill and Mary left, not many people missed them. Why? Because they were not "plugged in." They were not a part of a small group. They did not have meaningful relationships. When they left, they did not leave "a hole." Why? Because they were not part of a ministry team. They weren't contributing to the mission in a way that was meaningful.

Had I spent a little less time preparing my weekly message, and a little more time making phone calls and getting groups and ministry teams organized, I could have been farther ahead, at least with Bill and Mary. There is an immediate feedback loop with teaching that can delude us from the hard work of social architecture. We can retreat into our study and dream up clever phrases and analogies, meanwhile, what people really need from us is not being delivered. They need our help to develop their relationship with God and other brothers and sisters in Christ. They need our help to find their purpose, and be equipped to do the work of the ministry.

We are living in a different time. It is the information age. There was a time when a pastor was valued simply for the insights that he could bring. Those days are gone. If someone is truly looking for excellent Biblical teaching they can hear the best possible on Christian radio each and every day. They can buy books, CDs and DVDs. They can download audio files. They can do a Google search and obtain research on any and every topic in which they might have interest. Really, you, as a pastor, can't beat that.

But what you can provide for people, that the Christian book store and the internet cannot, is meaningful relationships, and meaningful responsibilities. When was the last time you "hooked someone up"?

War

Between earth and heaven there is a war going on. The conflict is taking place in a realm that John Wimber referred to as “the excluded middle.” It was Wimber’s contention that evangelicals largely exclude from their thinking the realities going on in the spirit realm, preferring to focus instead on either the tangible world around us, or else the celestial world awaiting us above - heaven. But the scripture is clear that we must engage with forces in the middle we cannot see, but that are nevertheless real.

Every now and then I am reminded of just how spiritually charged our world’s atmosphere is. One reminder came at the end of a book I just finished called Presence, by Senge, Scharmer, Jaworski, and Flowers. This is not a Christian book (a couple of the authors are Buddhist), but they cite some phenomena that is interesting:

A recent study has shown that random number generators (RNGs) around the world behaved in highly nonrandom ways on September 11, 2001. RNGs are computer programs that generate numbers that meet statistical conditions for randomness, required for various research applications. They are shielded from electromagnetics, telecommunications, and all other known forces that could cause systematic biases. In other words, these are computer programs that are supposed to be insulated from all external influences and are tested regularly to assure that this is so. An ongoing monitoring study of thirty-seven RNGs around the world showed the extent of the anomalous behavior on September 11. A recent report in the Foundations of Physics Letters documents an abnormally high average variance, autocorrelation (correlation among successive numbers generated by each program), and “internode” correlation (correlation among the different programs) across this global network – on average, the probability of what was observed was less than one in a thousand. Moreover, the minute-by-minute behavior of these statistics across the global network matches the chronology of the terrorist attacks, with the non-random behavior starting about 5:00 AM and peaking around 11:00 AM, Eastern (U.S.) daylight time, staying extremely deviant into the evening. In the words of the authors, the “substantial deviations from chance expectation” on September 11 have potentially “profound theoretical and practical implications.” They conclude that “it is unlikely that [known] environmental factors could cause the correlations we observe” and that, barring demonstration to the contrary, “we are obliged to confront the possibility that the measured correlations may be directly associated with some (as yet poorly understood) aspect of consciousness attendant to global events.”

In other words, if I can summarize, “some weird stuff is going on, and we don’t know what to make of it, but it seems organized, and spiritual.” I’m not quite sure what to make of this, either. But the possibility exists that during the hours surrounding the terrorist attacks of the World Trade Center there was heightened demonic activity that might account for some of the phenomena. We know that it was a dark day for humanity. We know that there is a “dark side” out there (principalities, powers, rulers of darkness) in Satan and his demons. With a biblical worldview we may be able to connect the dots on this one.


Paul gave us some instruction on how to get along in a world with spiritual conflict: “For though we live in the world, we do not wage war as the world does. The weapons we fight with are not the weapons of the world. On the contrary, they have divine power to demolish strongholds” (2 Corinthians 10:3,4). Worldly weapons in this context might include ingenuity, rhetoric, showmanship, splashiness, forwardness, charm, and charisma. Paul doesn’t use these. Instead he uses weapons that can demolish strongholds. A stronghold was a massively fortified tower that only required a few men to guard it. What does this mean in non-metaphorical language? Paul unpacks his metaphor in verse 5: “We demolish arguments and every pretension that sets itself up against the knowledge of God, and we take captive every thought to make it obedient to Christ.”

A spiritual warrior is trying to “take captive every thought.” The strongholds are between people’s ears. The picture is of a military expedition into enemy territory, an expedition so effective that every plan of the enemy is thwarted, every scheme foiled, every counter-offensive beaten. The designs and schemes of sinful men are captured by Christ and brought under a new authority. The weapons in the warrior’s hands destroy the way people think and demolish the mental structures by which they live their lives in rebellion against God. In his own words, Paul’s weapons tear down “every pretension that sets itself up against the knowledge of God.” This means that many who dismiss the crucified Christ with scorn come in time to embrace his lordship, cherish the cross, abandon self-promotion, and exchange it for self-denial and obedience.

That’s what the weapons do. But what are the weapons? As the conflict is essentially spiritual, so are the weapons (Ephesians 6:13-18):

-the truth of the gospel

-righteousness

-boldness borne of a deep grasp of the gospel

-faith

-salvation itself

-the Word of God

-vigilant prayer

Those are Paul’s powerful weapons. Spiritual ends require spiritual means.

Argue a skeptic into a corner, and you will not take his mind captive for Christ; but pray for him, proclaim the gospel to him, live out the gospel of peace before him, walk righteously by faith until he senses your ultimate allegiance and citizenship are vastly different from his own, and you may discover that the power of truth, the convicting and regenerating work of the HS, and the glories of Christ Jesus shatter his reasons and demolish his arguments until you take captive his mind and heart to make them obedient to Christ.

Fight the good fight!

Excitement

John Rosemond is a family psychologist who has written about the epidemic of boredom among today’s affluent American kids. When he travels overseas, he asks parents “Do your kids complain about boredom?” The answer is invariably, “No.” When he surveys the previous generation in America and asks, “When you were raising your kids, did they complain about boredom?” They tell him, “Rarely.” But when he asks parents in America today whether their children complain of boredom, they say, “All the time.”

When he asks overseas about the number of toys the kids have, parents usually respond, “Toys?” When he asks older adults in this country how many toys their kids had growing up, the answer ranges from 1-10, and often they’ll say, “we mainly used a cardboard box for fun.” In contrast his research indicates that the average 5 year old in America today has 260 toys.

More significant than the number of toys is the fact that today’s toys “make the noise for you.” In previous generations and in different parts of the world the noise of a fire truck, or the shooting sound of a toy soldier would have to be supplied by the child. But the experience is more entertaining, because there are an infinite number of ways to make a siren noise. For the previous generation the toy soldier was in one position, and did not talk. So you had to supply so much more imagination to the experience. But that was the fun of it. Playing now is very controlled, and it’s b-o-r-i-n-g. It’s passive, instead of active.

I think John Rosemead has put his finger on one of the reasons the average church experience has become so blasé. Someone’s doing it all for us. The paid staff do the ministry. They make all the noise. We just sit back passively and enjoy the show. The irony is that a passive approach to church ends up being less stimulating in the long run.

When you help people become engaged in either a small group or ministry team, you do more than increase the size of your ministry. You raise the quality of it as well. The most exciting experience for a Christian is to be hands-on and engaged; active in ministry instead of passive. When Christians find a place where they can make some noise, their faith takes on new meaning.

When you are personally involved, Christianity becomes a real, lively experience between you and God. You’re almost never bored.


One of the better quotes I’ve come across lately: “Church has become so complicated that you have to be a professional to do it.”

Presence

Aaron Brooks is the quarterback of the New Orleans Saints, and he's mad. It’s been a rough year to be a football player in New Orleans, Louisiana. It's been rough on the field, and off. Nearly the entire city was wiped out by Hurricane Katrina. The storm continues for the players. Some of their friends and family were killed. Many of them have lost homes. And then the team has been bounced around to temporary training facilities and practice fields. It's not a recipe for success in a league as competitive as the NFL. They have a losing record. Morale is way down.

It's not surprising that Aaron Brooks would be mad. It might surprise you to hear who he is mad at: NFL Commissioner Paul Tagliabue. It's not like the NFL Commissioner could have stopped the hurricane. What could commissioner Tagliabue have done? Aaron Brooks says, “Maybe he couldn’t have said anything, or done anything, but he could have been here. He could have shown up.” Evidently, following Katrina, Commissioner Tagliabue never made a trip to New Orleans to meet with the players. He met with government and business leaders. But he did not meet with the players. When they felt like they needed him, he wasn't there. There is a resentment over his absence that is still smoldering.

Someone has said that 80% of success is "just showing up." That is certainly true when folks are in crisis. As a pastor you may not be in a position to change things. You may not even know what to say. But just being there can be a tremendous comfort to folks in the midst of disaster. Don't underestimate the impact of “showing up” in the waiting room, or the hospital room, or the court room. There are many times where I've told a family, "I don't really know what to say" and I been told, "That's ok, pastor. We're just glad that you're here." I can tell by the look in their eyes that they are sincerely appreciative.

In my experience, saying the right words at the right time is overrated. Being in the right place at the right time is underrated. As a pastor, your presence is powerful. Maybe more powerful than anything you could ever say.


You make huge deposits in the emotional bank account by “showing up.” Those deposits may prove invaluable at other times, when the account is drawn down for some reason. I heard a story of a huge wedding that had some unfortunate pastor-related complications. Unfortunately, the pastor who was to perform the wedding went out of town that day. He forgot completely about the wedding. As the time of the wedding came, the couple tried to reach the pastor, but could not. There was no one in attendance to perform the wedding, and the couple had to inform the crowd that the wedding would have to be rescheduled. This was a prominent family in the church, but this pastor survived the ordeal ok. How? By being this family’s pastor for more than 30 years. He had “been there” for them many, many times. He had made so many deposits over the years that there was enough in the account to cover even a massive withdrawal, which the mishap certainly was.

Acceptance

God calls his children to live by a different code of conduct: To a life of love, acceptance and forgiveness. James wrote, "If you really keep the royal law found in Scripture, 'Love your neighbor as yourself,' you are doing right. But if you show favoritism, you sin and are convicted by the law as lawbreakers." To James, The Golden Rule is the Royal Law. Love your neighbor as yourself. Do unto others as you would have them do unto you. It’s the idea of asking the question: What is in this person's best interests? And when we can’t come up with the answer we “put ourselves in their shoes” and treat them accordingly.

James calls it a law because it's more than a good idea. When good ideas are good for everyone all the time they become laws. The Golden Rule for a follower of Christ is a law. James calls it a royal law because it's not just a good idea, it's God's idea. It reflects God's vision for this world, for his kingdom. It comes from the vantage point of his throne. It is the straight and narrow way that Jesus spoke of in Matthew 7:12-14: “So in everything, do to others what you would have them do to you, for this sums up the Law and the Prophets. Enter through the narrow gate. For wide is the gate and broad is the road that leads to destruction, and many enter through it. But small is the gate and narrow the road that leads to life, and only a few find it.” God's vision for this world is harmony: People putting others first, every person being loved.

The Golden Rule not only reflects God’s vision, but God’s values. To God no one is less valuable than another. When we read that “God so loved the world,” we understand that each person matters to God. And if people are good enough for God, they should be good enough for us. And everyone is good enough for God.

The church in the AD 30s (not 1930s) understood this: With great power the apostles continued to testify to the resurrection of the Lord Jesus, and much grace was upon them all. There were no needy persons among them. For from time to time those who owned lands or houses sold them, brought the money from the sales and put it at the apostles' feet, and it was distributed to anyone as he had need (Acts 4:33-35).

By the time the AD 50s rolled around, James is dealing with a sad scenario: “Suppose a man comes into your meeting wearing a gold ring and fine clothes, and a poor man in shabby clothes also comes in. If you show special attention to the man wearing fine clothes and say, ‘Here's a good seat for you,’ but say to the poor man, ‘You stand there’ or ‘Sit on the floor by my feet,’ have you not discriminated among yourselves and become judges with evil thoughts?”

Want to know an unsavory little secret about everybody? Almost all of us walk around with an unpublished list in our minds of certain kinds of people we tend to like and certain kinds of people we could do without. We have a list of desirables and a list of undesirables. Of course, we don't talk about this kind of stuff. How could you as a Christian, much less a pastor? Most of us have a hard time admitting to ourselves that we have favorites or show partiality to people we interact with. But it's true nonetheless. Some among us, if the truth were known, would admit to having the same kind of problem that James is addressing. We prefer to be around rich people instead of poor. In fact, some of us are annoyed by the poor, and we feel a little superior to them. We try to insulate ourselves from them as much as possible. Others of us, if the truth were known, prefer to be with educated people. We look down our noses at those who haven't gotten as far as we have. Some would rather be with people of the same collar as themselves. If white collar, then white. If blue collar, then blue.

Some like to be around thin people and would rather not associate much with those who weight a little more. Of course, many people come right out and say they would rather be around heterosexual people than homosexual people. A lot of people don't even try to hide their disdain for homosexuals. Today there are still large segments of society that discount and diminish the value of women. Many churches go out of their way to make sure that women know it - and it's really not about a biblical standard. It's about chauvinism. Then we get into skin color. Some of us have feelings that we wouldn't want to be made public about where our preferences lie in skin color. Some of us tell jokes at the expense of certain ethnic groups. We say it’s a joke, but there's a reason why we're laughing.

James says, Don't kid yourself about this. This stuff must be exposed. This has to be repented of. This has to be transformed from the inside by the love of God. This is very close to the heart of God. It's right at the heart of what God stands for. In Romans 2:11 we read “With God there is no partiality of any kind.” This is serious business. Every, single person matters to God. They should matter to us.

If God could speak to me today on this matter, I know what he'd say, "Dave, you have never looked in the eyes of someone who does not matter to me. Every time you make eye contact with a waiter, a waitress, an attorney, a teenager, a salesman, a grandparent in a rest home, a minority person, a gay or lesbian, an illegal immigrant, every politician who votes the opposite way you vote - every single person matters to me. Forget the categories. Don't look at their riches, rank, religion, or race. They are one prayer away from receiving my son Jesus Christ, and receiving salvation as you have. They are people for whom my son died. They deserve your respect. They deserve your honor. They deserve your love."

Someone has said, prejudice is being down on what we're not up on. We've got to look at others the way God does….through the cross. We are all on level ground at the foot of the cross.

Numerical

Bob Jones, founder of the conservative university that bears his name, once said, "Jesus promised that 'where two or three are gathered, there am I in the midst of them' but that doesn't mean that He doesn't like a bigger crowd." (supply rim shot here)

I happen to agree with Jones on this point. All things being equal, God desires for His church to grow numerically as well as spiritually. What indicators do we have that Jesus would "like a bigger crowd"?

1. God doesn’t want anyone to perish

• "The Lord is patient, not wanting anyone to perish, but wants everyone to come to repentance." 2 Peter 3:9

2. God wants his house to be full

• "Go out into the country...and urge anyone you find to come in, so that my house will be full." Luke 14:23

3. God’s body is alive and growing

• "Under Christ's control, the whole body is nourished...and grows as God wants it to grow." Colossians 2:19

4. God is building His church

• Jesus said, "I will build my church." Matthew 16:18

Some may look at CTK and see that it is “small pieces loosely joined” and come to the conclusion that we prefer small over big. We don’t actually prefer small over big. We prefer more, over bigger. That is, we want to reach an unlimited number of people (more people than you could ever put it any one facility), but we feel that the best way to do that is to be in an unlimited number of places. We don’t feel that our calling is to build a church, but to reach a community. And we feel that trying to reach large numbers of people in one place is a very limited idea. So at CTK we feel we need to grow larger and smaller at the same time! We need to keep “breaking it down” so that we can always make good on our pledge: “Always A Place For You.”

When I was a kid, I remember when a new fast food restaurant came to my home town of Anchorage, Alaska. There were big yellow arches out front. They had a clown named Ronald. But what I remember most was the sign. Right from the start they had a sign up that read “40 million served.” I remember thinking, “Wow, how did they do that?” My parents filled me in: “Son, they are a chain, which means that they have restaurants in lots of different places. That’s how they did that.” Evidently McDonald’s was faced with a choice. Build a bigger restaurant to serve more people, or build more restaurants to serve more people. They went the “more” route. The rest, as they say, is history. They quit putting those signs up after they got into the billions.

Early in CTK’s story, we were faced with a choice. Either reach more people by being “bigger,” or reach more people by being “more.” We decided that instead of trying to reach “thousands by hundreds,” we would try to reach “tens of thousands by tens.” We dreamed, “Instead of trying to create a ministry, what if we could inspire a movement?” The conventional church growth theory is “Bigger is better.” If we had chosen to go that route, there would no doubt be a church in Mount Vernon now of well over 1000 people. But by believing that “more is better than bigger” we have become a church of thousands that now is free to become a church of tens of thousands or hundreds of thousands.

How big God’s church gets is His business. We just know that we want to reach out to an unlimited number of people, or as many as we possibly can. The best way we know to do that is to be in as many places as possible.

Recruiting

It is everyone's job at CTK to deploy leaders. We are not in the church planting business. We are not in the church growth business. We are not in the multi-site business. We are in the leader deployment business. We identify, deploy, train and support leaders. How do we do this? The following except from The Leadership Engine gives us some tips:

[Service Master has a four-step methodology for teaching: (1) Prepare the learner. (2) Show the learner. (3) Have the learner show you. (4) Coach. It applies to values as well as skills. The leaders who thoroughly understand and believe in the values not only tell them to newcomers, but demonstrate them and quickly put the learners in real-life situations where they need to apply them. Then the teachers help the learners improve their performance. It’s a powerful teaching tool that helps assure that the values permeate the organization from top to bottom.

Phil Myers was working nights as a janitor in an operating room in Indianapolis when his meticulous work attracted the attention of his supervisor, Chris Kinman. Kinman, who worked for Service Master, although Myers did not, began to give Myers more responsibility. Then one night he gave Myers the Service Master manager’s manual and asked him to read it. Myers, who still seems hyperactive after twenty-one years at Service Master, wasn’t much of a reader, so he just skimmed it. Because he worked the night shift from 10:00 PM until 6:00 AM, Myers only saw Kinman and the other Service Master managers for one hour each day, before they went home at 11:00 PM, but Kinman sought him out and made the most of the limited time. “Chris and I got to know each other,” said Myers. He would ask things like, ‘What do you want to be when you grow up?’ Six or seven months after that, I had the opportunity to become an evening supervisor for him.” The opportunity frightened Myers because “I was a twenty-one-year-old kid about to step into a role of people who were old enough to be my parents if not my grandparents. I had no formal education. I had taken some classes and was going to college, but had no degree….I was scared to death. I had led some people my own age in the Air Force, but now I was going to lead twenty people.” But Kinman encouraged him. “I can remember that feeling [of fear]. But Chris put confidence in me. ‘You tell me that you want to succeed, I’ll see to it that you do not fail. Just keep trying, and you will not fail,’” Kinman told Myers.]


From the article above, what are the three most significant phrases that need to be underlined?

What are the takeaways for you from this story?


At CTK our leadership development process is Identify, Deploy, Train and Support (IDTS). This is a different sequence than what is found in many churches (ITDS) where individuals are not deployed until they have received extensive training. Similar to Service Master, we deploy first, then train. Not only are we able to rapidly put leaders in the battle this way, but we find that the learner is more “teachable” when they are actually putting their knowledge to use in real time. Obviously there is a minimal amount of assessment and orientation that precedes deployment. But we certainly don’t think a leader needs to know all the answers before they get in the game. We just want them to be relationally connected to fellow-learners and mentors.

Journey

“There was a man of the Pharisees named Nicodemus, a member of the Jewish ruling council. He came to Jesus at night….”

In John 3 Nicodemus was going through a process. He had questions. He needed answers. He was preparing himself for a major life change. He was getting ready give up his former beliefs - some of which were firmly held (he was a Pharisee). The process was emotional. His decision was going to have repercussions. This is why he came at night. It’s not easy, after climbing the ladder, to come to the realization that it is leaned against the wrong wall. Jesus respected the difficult process that Nicodemus was going through. He used the word picture of birth to describe the change. He used the word picture of the wind to describe the Holy Spirit. He didn’t talk at him, He talked with him. He treated Nicodemus with respect.

It is absolutely critical that we remain sensitive to the spiritual journey people are on. After a funeral service I officiated a man came up to me to say thanks. He told me he had been to a funeral service previously where spiritual sensitivity had not been present. I think he used the words “hell, fire and brimstone” to describe the tone of that service. With tears in his eyes he remembered, “It was really hurtful.” To my knowledge this man was not a believer. But what he was telling me was that one experience had pushed him away from God, the other had nudged him a little closer.

At CTK we not only want to respect the spiritual journey, we want to facilitate it.. There are three types of facilitation that are needed:

1) Physical Facilitation....Can people find you when they need you?

By subscribing to “multility” we are creating multiple places for people to find us. By organizing by small groups, with multiple services and sites, we are giving people hundreds of opportunities to get their questions answered. Most churches have one entry point. The Sunday morning service. We want to have an unlimited number of contact points. If you are a pastor wanting to facilitate the spiritual journey for people ask yourself, “Do people know where to find you? Are there options?”

2) Emotional Facilitation....Can people feel safe with you?

In some churches people are expected to believe before they can belong. At CTK “belonging” precedes “believing.” We want to give people a place to belong, so that they’ll come to believe. “Safe” is an important word for us, and the people we are trying to reach. We say we want to be “a safe place to hear a dangerous message.” Evidently, Nicodemus felt safe bringing his questions to Jesus. If you are a pastor wanting to facilitate the spiritual journey for people ask yourself, “Is it safe for wayfarers to be with you, and not be 100% committed yet?”

3) Spiritual Facilitation....Can people get the deeper answers from you?

Felt-need ministry has become the rage in the past couple decades. But there are deeper spiritual issues than how to discipline your children, or how to get ahead at work. There is a spiritual battle going on for the souls of men. It would have been tragic if Jesus had said to Nicodemus, “Let me share with you 10 steps to becoming a better Pharisee.” If you are a pastor wanting to facilitate the spiritual journey for people ask, “Are we addressing the divide between light and darkness? Are we praying for spiritual transformation?”

Only the Spirit of God can change a heart. Our job is just to put the cookies on the lowest shelf. We can build the bridge. God is the one who has to draw them across. We just try to clear the path to the cross, and keep light on the path for the person who is on a journey to God.

Unchurched

As a leader, one of the questions you have to answer is “Who are we trying to reach?” You can't be all things to all people.

If you plot on an X/Y graph the following extremes: saved/unsaved, and churched/unchurched, you end up with four possible quadrants that you can try to reach:

1. The saved/churched
2. The unsaved/churched
3. The saved/unchurched
4. The unsaved/unchurched

At CTK, we have eliminated quadrants 1. and 2. from consideration by saying that we want to "create an authentic Christian community that effectively reaches out to unchurched people love with acceptance and forgiveness so that they may experience the joy of salvation and a purposeful life of discipleship." Our mission is not to draw people from other churches. Our mission is to reach out to unchurched people, particularly those who are unsaved.

When you decide who you are going to reach, you automatically choose who you are going to be hostile to - the quadrant and hemisphere that is opposite your choice. If you reach out to unchurched/unsaved people, you will no doubt produce an environment that is at points antagonistic to those who are saved and churched. I have found that the more that CTK creates an environment that is friendly and welcoming to the unchurched, the less inviting we look to “pre-processed Christians” who are “looking for a new church” (unless, of course, they have the “arrows pointed out”).

Conversely, if our goal were to make CTK extremely comfortable for those who are churched (those who already have their ticket punched), we would unwittingly create an environment that is hostile to the unsaved. In fact, this is what has already happened to the majority of 400,000 churches across the country.

Jesus also made choices. He came to reach out to the lost. Consequently, he was not favored by the establishment. The religious leaders (roughly analogous to the saved/churched of our day) took a dim view of his concerns for pagans, sinners and the lost. Even Jesus could not simultaneously meet the needs of the lost, and the establishment. In the process of reaching out the one, he “ticked off” the other.

The establishment still takes a dim view of pastors and churches who befriend pagans, sinners, and lost people. Establishment Christians want their pastors to care for and fraternize with “church people.” They want a chaplain, not a captain. Sadly, they are not asking what they can do for Christ’s church, they are asking what Christ’s church can do for them. I have found it is difficult to placate the establishment while at the same time aggressively reaching out to unchurched people in love, acceptance and forgiveness. My advice to you: “Don’t burn up too much energy trying to please both worlds.” Keep the arrows pointed out and ask others to join you in reaching out to unchurched people.

Passion

Churches typically engage in very similar activities. What differentiates churches from each other are their values: both the content of those values and the strength of conviction with which they are held. CTK is a special church in both respects. We have clear ideas. We also have clear feelings about those ideas. We know what we’re about, and we feel strongly about it.

When Cortez landed in Mexico he set fire to the ships that brought him there. It was either conquer or be conquered. There was no turning back. His heart was completely in it. His fervor reflected his faith, his passion corresponded with profession.

The dictionary defines passion as: “Intense emotion compelling action. A strong devotion to some object, activity or concept.” It is a fire in the belly. If you only had one biblical word to define passion it would be “heart.”

Therefore we do not lose heart. Though outwardly we are wasting away, yet inwardly we are being renewed day by day.
2 Corinthians 4:16

Whatever you do, work at it with all your heart, as working for the Lord, not for men.
Colossians 3:23

You can go a long way with the right heart. The Pike’s Place Fish Market in Seattle has become the most well-known fish market in the world by bringing a contagious enthusiasm and energy to their work. Their workers dance, sing, toss fish, and otherwise carry on. They are thoroughly immersed in their work. They have proven that it’s not just what you do, it’s how you do it.

In Zen and The Art of Motorcycle Maintenance Robert Pirsig refers to this vigor as “gumption.”

If you’re going to repair a motorcycle, an adequate supply of gumption is the first and more important tool. If you haven’t got that you might as well gather up all the other tools and put them away, because they won’t do you any good. Gumption is the psychic gasoline that keeps the whole thing going. If you haven’t got it, there’s no way the motorcycle can possibly be fixed. But if you have got it and know how to keep it, there’s absolutely no way in the whole world that motorcycle can keep from getting fixed. It’s bound to happen. Therefore the thing that must be monitored at all times and preserved before anything else is gumption.

At a writer’s workshop the moderator asked a panel of well-known authors this question: “What does it take to write a best seller?” After a little discussion, their consensus was that writers must be “in a fury.” If you write with passion, your words are intensified. Your message has force. Your readers can better sense your spirit and sincerity. They went on to suggest that if you cannot write with passion, perhaps you have selected the wrong subject.

Followers of Jesus Christ have certainly selected “the right subject.” And if passion, gumption, or fury (or whatever you want to call it) is important to selling fish, maintaining motorcycles, or writing novels, it certainly is appropriate for something as important as God’s work.

Passion is not optional for a Deliberately Simple church. Enthusiasm for what we’re doing is nearly as critical as what we’re doing. Soren Kierkegaard warned of the danger of the church losing its passion for the gospel and treating it like “just another piece of information.” The result could be compared with reading a cookbook to a person who is hungry.

When an unchurched person comes to church, one of their leading questions is, “Do they really believe this stuff?” Visitors are looking to see whether we are lip-synching, or if it’s coming from the heart. Unfortunately, many unbelievers have concluded that Christians are going through the motions.

Several years ago, at Christmas, my wife Kristyn and I flew to my home state of Alaska - and we got out of there just in time. There was a volcano that erupted south of Anchorage and threatened to disrupt air travel. As it turned out, we were fortunate to make our flight back to Seattle, but those scheduled to fly the next couple of days were grounded by the fallout. In the aftermath my parents mailed me a clipping from a newspaper in Anchorage. A photographer had gone into the air terminal and taken a picture of one of the monitors that displays the airline departure times. The picture had no caption. It spoke for itself, because the monitor read:

Flight Status
1727 Cancelled
362 Cancelled
1742 Cancelled
584 Cancelled
1720 Cancelled
1557 Cancelled
1714 Cancelled
1717 Cancelled
1724 Cancelled

Delta Airlines, We Love To Fly, and It Shows!

Sometimes there is a difference between what we advertise and what we’re really all about. I remember coming up behind a car on the interstate. On the back of the car was a bumper sticker: “Happiness is being a grandmother.” So with enthusiasm I began to pass, expecting to see the sweetest grandmotherly figure behind the wheel of that car. What I saw instead was an older lady, hunched over the steering wheel with a bull-dog like scowl on her face. I couldn’t tell if it was the grandma or the big, bad wolf in the grandmother’s clothes. And I thought: “That’s false advertising….to say that happiness is being a grandmother, and then to look like that!”

I realize that as Christians we can be guilty of false advertising from time to time. We say, “We love to fly.” But what shows is that we are spiritually grounded. Nothing is taking off. All flights are cancelled. We profess that “happiness is being a Christian,” but most people could never guess that we’re enjoying ourselves. We look more like Eeyore than Tigger. All the slogans and bumper stickers can’t disguise the reality that there is a disconnect between our profession and our passion.

Compared with what we ought to be we are only half awake. Our fires are damped; our drafts are checked.
William James

When we lack passion it is often because we have allowed something precious to become familiar. Max Lucado writes about the day his daughter nearly drowned in a back-yard pool. Lucado says, as he drew his baby girl out of the water, he understood something new about Satan. He realized that Satan is the author of complacency. Lucado reflects on the moment of truth, when he found this out:

It was a divine slap - a gracious knock on the head of severe mercy. Because of it I came face to face with one of Satan’s slyest agents - the agent of familiarity. His commission from the black room is clear, and it’s fatal: “Take nothing from your victim cause him only to take everything for granted.” He had been on my trail for years, and I never knew it. But I know it now. I’ve come to recognize his tactics and detect his presence. And I’m doing my best to keep him out. His aim is deadly. His goal is nothing less than to take what is most precious to us and make it appear as most common. To say that this agent of familiarity breeds contempt is to let him off easy. Contempt is just one of his offspring....He’s an expert in robbing the sparkle and replacing it with the drab. He invented the yawn. He put the hum in “hum-drum”. And his strategy is deceptive. He won’t steal your salvation - he’ll just make you forget what it is like to be lost. You’ll grow accustomed to prayer and thereby not pray. Worship will become commonplace and study will be optional. And with the passing of time he’ll infiltrate your heart with boredom and cover the cross with dust so that you’ll be safely out of reach of change. Nor will he steal your home from you, he’ll do something far worse. He’ll paint it with a coat of drabness. He’ll replace evening gowns with bath-robes. Nights on the town with evenings in the recliner. And romance with routine.

I think Lucado is right. If Satan can desensitize us, he can effectively undermine what God wants to do in our lives. We must keep the fires of passion lit by regularly reminding ourselves what is eternal....what is life-changing....what is life-giving.

Accountability

At CTK we prefer the word "support" to "accountability." But this is not to say that we have no accountability. It’s just that accountability expresses itself differently at CTK:

First, the Holy Spirit is our guide. Jesus heard the same concern I sometimes hear: “How will we know the way?” (only it’s usually “How will they know the way?”). Jesus’ answer was: “I’m going to send you another Counselor who will be with you forever. He will guide you into all the truth.” We are taking Jesus up on His promise to guide us into the truth. I or other pastors cannot personally be at every small group meeting to see that things go a certain way, but the Holy Spirit can. We are dependent on the Spirit to give leadership to God’s people. I sometimes ask people, “Has God ever taught you something?” Invariably the answer is “Yes.” Then I say, “Well, you can count on Him doing the same thing for others.”

Second, our mission statement defines the outcomes that we are looking for, and we are all accountable to its expectations. Our mission is "To create an authentic Christian community that effectively reaches out to unchurched people in love, acceptance and forgiveness so that they may experience the joy of salvation and a purposeful life of discipleship." The mission statement speaks to what we want to be (an authentic Christian community) and what we want to do (effectively reach out to unchurched people). If we cease to be what we’ve set out to be, or do what we’ve set out to do, then our mission statement corrects us.

Third, we have a strong culture, and typical of a strong culture, it defines outcomes and appropriate attendant behavior. A culture is simply how we do what we do. So if someone starts operating in a manner that is contrary to the culture (say, having the arrows pointed in, instead of out) the culture will push back against that. When you have a strong culture, the guidance you are looking for comes from within, instead of through external rules and controls.

Fourth, we take "relational responsibility" for each other. Through the Church Council (which supports the Lead Pastor), the Lead Pastor (who supports the Area Pastors) the Area Pastors (who support the local pastors), the Local Pastors (who support the Directors), Directors (who support the group leaders) and Small Group Leaders (who support the group participants) we have a manageable “span of care” that keeps us in touch with each other, and engaged in each other’s lives. Relational responsibility involves “speaking the truth in love” to each other.

Fifth, we have policies and procedures in place as "rails to run on." But what minimalist structure we have is designed to be liberating. Great organizations free people, instead of restricting them. CTK is an example of that ugly-sounding idea from Tom Peters’ In Search of Excellence – “simultaneous loose-tight controls.” On the one hand we are tight on the things that matter; on the other hand we are loose on everything else. We have freedom, with handrails. The handrails are our "beliefs" and our "brand."

Sixth, we are responsive to issues as they arise, and we anticipate that they will arise. We subscribe to the “2% rule.” The 2% rule says that out of every 100 groups we start, two will go sideways. This is based on our actual experience. Out of the first 100 small groups we started, 2 of them went sideways; one theologically, and one relationally. Knowing the 2% rule, we face choices as a church. Do we a) invest our efforts into trying to prevent the 2% from happening through extensive reporting and meetings (in which the 2% will still happen – we’ve just burned up a lot of energy trying to stop it), or do we b) put our efforts into reaching out, but prepare ourselves mentally and spiritually for dealing swiftly with issues as they arise? At CTK we have chosen b). Instead of organizing to keep the 2% from happening, we have chosen to put our energies into reaching out. As a friend of mine likes to say, “If you use your hands to cover your butt, it doesn’t leave you any hands to do the work.”


Why do we prefer the word “support” to “accountability”? The word accountability implies an imbalance between people - that there are “good” people and “bad” people. The “bad” people need to be “held accountable” (one of the most unhealthy phrases I think I’ve ever heard) by the “good” people. But the goal is obviously to be one of the good people. How? By not appearing bad. What this system rewards is keeping up the appearances that everything is ok, so that you are on the high side of the equation. We like the word “support” better because it implies that we are fellow strugglers (on the same plane), and that there is nothing to be gained by faking each other out. Instead of starting with the premise that we are all ok but need “accountability”, we start with the premise that we are all fellow strugglers, in need of “support” so that we can grow. So we ask, “How can we support each other?” instead of “How can we hold each other accountable?” It ends up in the same intended place, but a lot quicker, because it skips the gymnastics of appearance management.


One of the questions I routinely get is, “With so many small groups and Worship Centers out there, how will you find out if people are teaching false doctrine, or straying morally?” The answer is simple: “People love to tattle.” How did Paul find out about the moral dysfunction at Corinth? It was reported to him. We don’t need to go looking for trouble for it to appear. Years ago, when we had a small group go “sideways” theologically, someone in the group placed a call to me almost immediately and let me know what was being espoused. I was able to deal directly with the error, and “cut out the cancer.”

Interdependence

At CTK we have chosen to be interdependent for the sake of our mission, rather than dependent or independent. Most of us have very little previous experience working interdependently, as part of a network. Our modern culture (churches included) has reinforced the Darwinian belief that the central fact of life is competition, rather than cooperation. Modernity’s motto is “I’ve got mine” instead of “All for one, one for all.”

Christians resist deeper levels of interdependence, not because interdependence isn’t preferable, but because it is more difficult (I have found American Christians to be a lazy breed). Human nature tends to default to “stovepipes” and “silos.” Indeed we are finding that interdependence requires some things that independence does not. In specific it requires higher doses of trust, others-orientation, communication and wide-angle point of view:

Trust

Quote: “The new dependence on productive assets located within someone else’s state represents an unprecedented trust in the integrity and peacefulness of strangers.” (Richard Rosecrance, The Rise of the Virtual State)

Takeaway: You can not be distrusting, or fearful, and function in an interdependent way.

Others-orientation

Quote: “One of the most exciting sports experiences anyone can have is watching a team catch fire. Perhaps as a basketball game begins, the players on one team seem to be operating independently of one another, mechanically going through their routines, in effect competing among themselves. Then they suddenly undergo a transformation. One of them makes an inspired play that leads to a basket: At this instant a bifurcation point becomes amplified. Now the moves the players make seem coupled together, all five team members working like a single organism.” (John Briggs, The Seven Life Lessons of Chaos)

Takeaway: You cannot be self-seeking and function in an interdependent way.

Communication

Quote: “What’s the biggest problem in the world of security today? Simple. The CIA won’t talk to the FBI.…who won’t talk to Customs….who won’t talk to the INS…who won’t talk to the Air Force….who won’t talk to the Army….who won’t talk to the Navy. (And the few who do choose to talk across walls are seen as ‘disloyal’ to, say, ‘200 proud years’ of Army or Navy tradition). And so on. Fighting ‘virtual states’ like Al Qaeda, demands seamless (Big, Big Word) integration of our domestic and international security forces. In fact, integration of the civilized world’s domestic and international security assets.” (Tom Peters, Re-Imagine)

Takeaway: You cannot be isolated and function in an interdependent way.

Wide-angle POV

Quote: “Reactive learning is governed by ‘downloading’ habitual ways of thinking, of continuing to see the world within the familiar categories we’re comfortable with. We discount interpretations and options for action that are different from those we know and trust. We act to defend our interests. In reactive learning, our actions are actually reenacted habits, and we invariably end up reinforcing pre-established mental models. Regardless of the outcome, we end up being ‘right.’ At best, we get better at what we have always done. We remain secure in the cocoon of our own worldview, isolated from a larger world. But different types of learning are possible.” (Peter Senge, Presence)

Takeaway: You cannot be narrow-minded and function in an interdependent way.

Community

The difference between a community and a crowd is connection. If you get a bunch of people in the same room who have no connection to each other, you have a crowd. If you get a bunch of people in the same room, who are connected to each other, you have a community. It is through community that we have our needs met and are able to meet the needs of others. It is through community that the church can be the church.

Building a community that effectively reaches out is a delicate balancing act between familiar and new relationships . There are chasms on either side of a narrow path. On one side, there is the danger of becoming a club; on the other the danger of becoming a crowd.

Danger: Club. Ministries that do not engage in making more disciples of Jesus Christ can become inward focused, resembling a club more than a church. If a church is not intentional about reaching out, a Christian community can easily become an end in itself, instead of a means to an end.

Danger: Crowd. When a ministry reaches out to lost people, but does not maintain an authentic Christian core, it can become a crowd instead of a church. It’s possible to be effective in reaching out to large numbers of unchurched people, but without a sufficient Christian community to assimilate them into, in effect, you’ve just gathered together a greater concentration of darkness, instead of drawing people out of darkness and into the light.

At CTK our mission is to create an authentic Christian community that effectively reaches out. This involves maintaining a healthy balance between “community” and “reaches.” An “authentic Christian community” is what we want to be. “Effectively reaching out” is what we want to do.


A young adult group at one of our Worship Centers had a campout recently that didn’t turn out as planned. As we would hope, these CTKers wanted to make this campout an outreach opportunity (an event with “that”), so they invited unsaved, unchurched friends to join them. One night, several of the invited guests on the trip began drinking alcohol that they had brought with them. Much to the consternation of the retreat organizers, shortly thereafter the tone of the event shifted away from the spiritual conversations that they had planned. The leaders came back very disappointed, but I believe that they learned a couple valuable lessons about outreach events:

• The need for overwhelming force. This is extremely politically incorrect to say, but effectively reaching out requires that there be more cowboys than Indians. The goal is to get “them” on “our” turf, not the other way around. As an example, it may be wiser for a youth group of 5 kids, to try to reach out to a couple unchurched kids, instead of ten. If the group of 5 becomes 15, and now two-thirds of the group are unbelievers, you run the risk of no longer being an authentic Christian community, but instead becoming an unchristian crowd. The time to reach out to ten kids at a time is when you have twenty kids already on board. I personally like at least a 2:1 ratio. Unfortunately for the young adults on this camping trip, they had more like a 1:1 ratio, and things tipped backwards on them. The greater the concentration of darkness, the brighter the light needs to be to dispell it.

• The need for clear boundaries. Effectively reaching out to lost people requires anticipating challenges that can arise “lostness.” Lost people swear, drink, smoke, sleep around, etc. Lost people cannot be expected to behave in a Christian manner. Good leadership anticipates these possibilities and their potential adverse impact on the Christian community. Clear boundaries and expectations for the event (not for their lives necessarily) is one way in which we can continue to maintain an authentic Christian community while reaching out. We don’t keep from reaching out, but we reach out in a “boundaried” way. For instance, when I did youth work in the inner city, we had some very cool events for teenagers to attend (some drew as many at 500 kids at a time). But because of the gang lives that many of them knew we had very clear rules regarding language, dress, weapons, drugs, alcohol and physical contact. While they were on our “turf” they were expected to behave in a way that would not be detrimental to what we were trying to accomplish.

Intimacy

Intimacy was what we were made for. What air is to the body, to feel understood is to the heart. Dante defined Hell as “proximity without intimacy.” Dean Ornish reports that solitary people are three to five times likelier to die earlier than people with ties to a loving group of family or friends. Based on the research, a doctor would be just as wise to proscribe relationships as drugs or operations. We do proscribe relationships at CTK. We ask every person at CTK to participate in a weekly small group, because we see the following benefits:

1. Friendship. Sydney Smith put it so well when he said, “Life is to be fortified by many friendships. To love and be loved is the greatest happiness of existence.” The Apostle Paul’s approach to ministry was intensely personal. The last chapter of Romans reflects this.

Greet Priscilla and Aquila, my fellow workers in Christ Jesus. They risked their lives for me….Greet my dear friend Epenetus, who was the first convert to Christ in the province of Asia. Greet Mary, who worked very hard for you. Greet Andronicus and Junias, my relatives who have been in prison with me. They are outstanding among the apostles, and they were in Christ before I was. Greet Ampliatus, whom I love in the Lord. Greet Urbanus, our fellow worker in Christ, and my dear friend Stachys. Greet Apelles, tested and approved in Christ. Greet those who belong to the household of Aristobulus. Greet Herodion, my relative. Greet those in the household of Narcissus who are in the Lord. Greet Tryphena and Tryphosa, those women who work hard in the Lord. Greet my dear friend Persis, another woman who has worked very hard in the Lord. Greet Rufus, chosen in the Lord, and his mother, who has been a mother to me, too. Greet Asyncritus, Phlegon, Hermes, Patrobas, Hermas and the brothers with them. Greet Philologus, Julia, Nereus and his sister, and Olympas and all the saints with them.
- Romans 16:3-16

This is a list of twenty-seven friends that he had established in Rome. There were a lot more Christians than that in Rome. But while you can be friendly with an unlimited of people, you can be friends with a limited number of people. While many churches work at being friendly, at CTK we want people to find friends to share the journey. There is a difference between experiencing friendliness and having friends.

Research suggests we have limited capacity for friendship. A test was done where people were shown flash cards with a certain number of dots on them. In a limited amount of time the subjects of the trial were to identify the number of dots on the page. The subjects would get the number right up to about seven dots. Beyond that number, people started to guess. There seems to be a built-in intellectual capacity for seven. This is the reason that telephone numbers have seven digits. Alexander Graham Bell wanted to have the longest sequence possible so that there would be more possibilities, but wanted a number small enough to be memorable, to avoid wrong numbers. What the research suggests is there is an intellectual boundary that calls for a small group.

People have a channel capacity for relationships. If you have more than a certain number of emotional channels opened up, you become overwhelmed. When people are asked to list the names of the people who, if they died, would leave them truly devastated, chances are you will not respond with over twelve names. One of the reasons why we are committed to small groups of 3-10 people is that it seems to be the optimum size for friendships.

2. Growth. A key to spiritual growth is to be in community with others who can spur you on toward it.

And let us consider how we may spur one another on toward love and good deeds. Let us not give up meeting together.
- Hebrews 10:24,25

In a small group you will experience spiritual growth. A weekly meeting with other people who are growing in their faith helps to keep you on track in your own spiritual journey. It keeps the things that are truly important on the front burner. Without that meeting, we can find ourselves easily distracted by the tyranny of the urgent.

In the 1780s during a 5 year period the number of people meeting in small groups under John Wesley went from 20,000 to 90,000. John Wesley was not a charismatic preacher. His genius was organizational.

Wesley realized that if you wanted to bring about a fundamental change in people’s belief and behavior, a change that would persist and serve as an example to others, you needed to create a community around them, where those new beliefs could be practiced and expressed and nurtured….It’s easier to remember and appreciate something, after all, if you discuss it for two hours with your best friends. It becomes a social experience, and object of conversation.
- Malcolm Gladwell, The Tipping Point

It is through community that truth is built into our lives. That we grow.

3. Encouragement. The number one thing that gets delivered in a small group is encouragement. When people walk away from a group meeting feeling encouraged, they are walking away from a good group meeting. The challenge for most people is not the gap between what they know and what they don’t know. It is the gap between what they know and what they are living. Most people are trafficking in unlived truth. They know more than they are putting into practice.

Therefore encourage one another and build each other up, just as in fact you are doing.
- 1 Thessalonians 5:11

Let us not give up meeting together, as some are in the habit of doing, but let us encourage one another — and all the more as you see the Day approaching.
- Hebrews 10:25

Sometimes the encouragement you receive in a small group is overt, sometimes more covert. When you are around people who are taking steps, you’re inclined to take some yourself. Have you ever been on a street corner with a group of people, waiting to cross a street, with no traffic coming in either direction? Even though the signal has not changed to “walk” there are probably several people in the group who are secretly wanting to walk across. Then someone decides to go. And almost unconsciously the group follows. Being in a group can carry you in a direction you might not have the courage to go on your own. When you get around people who are taking steps of faith, it becomes contagious, and before you even realize what is happening, you are taking steps too.

I think people crave to have a family; you aspire to have one, you create one in any way you can.
- Jennifer Elise Cox, The Brady Bunch

Christ died in part to create a new opportunity for you to be born again into a new family, the family of God. This was Jesus’ invitation to us at the last supper, the eve of his crucifixion.

It was just before the Passover Feast. Jesus knew that the time had come for him to leave this world and go to the Father. Having loved his own who were in the world, he now showed them the full extent of his love.
- John 13:1

Jesus did not have this final meal in order to model a religious ceremony. He did this to show his disciples how much He loved them. He showed it in washing their feet. In what he shared with them. In giving them the bread and the cup. We refer to this event in two ways: as the Lord’s Supper (which speaks to the vertical aspect of it) and as Communion (which speaks to the horizontal aspect of it). Jesus said keep doing this, even after I’m gone. Jesus was saying: This type of community you have experienced with me, continue to celebrate it in the future.

James Patterson wrote Suzanne’s Diary for Nicholas about a mother who keeps a diary for her baby about to be born. Her words of advice are instructive for us.

Imagine life is a game in which you are juggling five balls. The balls are called work, family, health, friends, and integrity. And you’re keeping them all in the air. But one day you finally come to understand that work is a rubber ball. If you drop it, it will bounce back. The other four balls are made of glass. If you drop one of these , it will be irrevocably scuffed, nicked, perhaps even shattered. And once you truly understand the lesson of the five balls, you will have the beginnings of balance in your life.

I like that analogy. And I guess I would say, when it comes to finding intimacy with others, don’t drop the ball.


Kriss Leadbetter (who with her husband Dean are praying and working towards establishing CTK in Allyn, WA) made a presentation at CTK in Oak Harbor called “Practical Ways to Fulfill the Mission of CTK in Regards to Small Groups.” I thought it was an excellent piece of work. Here were her points.....

Pray for the empty chair.
Seek out people attending CTK (regular and new) – ask if they are in a small group and if not….
Give them a list of the groups, times and places, etc.
Make note of their names and pray for them to get connected.
Don’t assume that workers or long time attendees are connected with a group.
Be open to leading and multiplying as the Lord leads.*
Pray for all the small groups.

1 Peter 4:8 – Above all keep fervent in your love for one another, because love covers a multitude of sins.

Colossians 1:1-12

Hebrews 10:23-25

*Remember there are many others out there that would like to experience the warmth and love you have in your group. That’s why we need to multiply. We don’t lose those that we already know and love but we gain more. Love will increase as we give it away.

Legalism

CTK is a "grace-based" organization. Interestingly, many of the pastors and key leaders have had previous experience in legalistic church groups. I grew up in a very legalistic group (I was a “pharisee of the pharisees”), but now that I am “free” I could never go back. I know all too well the problems with legalism, and there are at least five....

1. The “whose church is this?” problem....by establishing our own rules and regulations for the church and the people in it, we run the risk of forgetting that this is God’s church, not ours.

2. The “big sin, little sin” problem....by picking out some sins and saying nothing about others, we send a message that there are big sins we can't tolerate; others are the “little sins” that we can live with.

3. The “enforcement” problem....by having a standard that is not strictly Biblical we place ourselves in the predicament of having to enforce something without scriptural authority.

4. The “hypocrisy” problem....since there is usually spotty enforcement we set up an environment of hypocrisy, where we imagine that we have a church full of “saints" when, in fact, we know deep down that we do not.

5. The "growing list" problem....when you begin to make lists of sins, you head down a path of ever increasing list-making, and standard keeping, because there is always one more sin out there that needs to be addressed. In the end, however, spirituality is not attained through the keeping of lists, but by a heart that seeks after God.

Legalists believe that we achieve a standing with God by what we do, or don’t do. It is a great day when you come to realize that our standing with God is not based on what we have done for Him, but based on what He has done for us. God loves us in spite of who we are and what we’ve done, not because of who we are and what we’ve done. There is nothing that we can do that will make God love us more, and there is nothing that we can do that will make God love us less. They don’t call it “amazing grace” for nothing!

Organization

A cell-based ministry like CTK is leader and labor-intensive. If we wanted to do it easier, we would organize ourselves in groups of hundreds, instead of tens. But we have chosen the effectiveness of community over the efficiency of crowds. This requires a follow-up commitment to organization. Small group ministry requires continual organizational development so that there is reasonable span-of-care, even with growing numbers of small group leaders. If it has been awhile since you are re-organized for growth, you might consider giving fresh leadership to each of the elements that comprise effective organization: people and procedures.

People

People with leadership and administrative talent must be identified, recruited, deployed, trained and supported to see that the right things are happening in your ministry. As a pastor you should have at least five Directors that you are developing:

Director of Worship
Director of Small Groups
Director of Childrens Ministries
Director of Youth Ministries
Director of Operations.

If any of these positions are unfilled, start by “getting the right people on the bus.” Begin now to pray that the Lord will send forth laborers into the harvest, make a list of prospects that may be God’s answer to that prayer, and take action to begin identifying, deploying, training and support new leaders in your ministry. Remember, as a pastor your job is not to do the ministry, but to see that the ministry gets done. Through much of my ministry I set aside one evening per week (when people would be home to talk) to work the phones and recruit new ministry directors and small group leaders.

Procedures

It is a leader’s job to not only “get the right people on the bus” but to provide a context in which these people can be successful. We say that every leader’s job at CTK is to “create and sustain an environment whereby the people of CTK can execute their ministries with maximum fulfillment and minimum obstacles.” This usually involves providing some basic structure:

Job descriptions. What am I supposed to do?

Schedules. When am I supposed to be here?

Team rosters. Who else is on the team with me? What are their phone numbers? Is there any room for others to join us?

Organizational charts. How are we organized? Where am I at on the map? Who do I report to if I have a problem?

Procedures. How do we do things around here?

Meetings or contact points. When do we regularly touch base to share and care for each other?

Information loops. How do we keep everyone informed and in the know?

Many pastors prefer to work “in” the ministry, instead of “on” the ministry. Yet, if someone is not working “on” the ministry, over time things disintegrate to such a level that people can no longer express and enjoy their ministries. If it has been awhile since you tended to the organization, be sure to make this a priority soon. Every soldier has a right to competent command.


Every job has meaning when you connect it to the bigger picture. Dish washing can seem like a menial task until you remember how much it matters to the next person who will eat off that plate. Window washing is really about providing clear vision for people to see the world.

A critical role for a leader at CTK is to let people know how their contribution matters. Someone handing out programs is not just passing paper around, they are welcoming people to a new life. A children’s worker is not “taking care of kids” as much as they are facilitating an age-appropriate encounter with God.

When late night talk show host David Letterman returned after quintuple bypass surgery he brought the medical staff from the hospital onto the show. Lined across the stage were anesthesiologists, surgeons, and nurses. Letterman said, “These are the people who saved my life.” With that statement he brought into clear view that it’s not about reading gauges, making incisions, or emptying bed pans. It’s about people. And as long as we remember that, even the smallest task has meaning.


People need to find two things to have a meaningful experience at CTK:

Meaningful relationships

Meaningful responsibilities

Empowerment

There are four words with which every pastor in the CTK network needs to become fluent. These four words are "Yes, Sure, You Bet." “Yes,” “Sure,” and “You Bet” need to be spoken frequently to make certain that we are open to God's plans, and not just our own - to guarantee that we are empowering people, instead of controlling them.

When was the last time that you told someone in your ministry “Yes, Sure, You Bet”? Over the years, I have been amazed at how powerful those words have been to the hearer. Evidently, these words are rarely spoken (or heard) in the traditional church anymore. Many church leaders can say “no” but few have the power to say “yes.” Personally, I view this to be a tell-tale sign of bureaucracy. At CTK we value empowerment. That means saying yes to what God wants to do in a person’s life.

Here are some of the people that we love to say “yes” to at CTK.

1. People who have a heart for ministry. While at CTK we have a limited number of programs that we start, there are an unlimited number of ministries that our people may start. There are a number of people in ministry at CTK who have told me, “I couldn’t do this at my previous church. There was too much red tape.”
2. People who are less than the best. In modern church circles the key word is “excellence.” What this means to many people is “those who are average need not apply.” At CTK we emphasize “good enough” instead of “perfection.” This opens the door to many people who previously would not have been considered gifted enough to minister.
3. Pastors who have failed or fallen. We believe that “hope for the future, forgiveness for the past” applies to everyone, even leaders. A church leader from another denomination told me recently that the difference between their group and CTK was that we “actually give a person a second chance.” His denomination talked the language of recovery, but fell short on actually taking a risk.

Faith is belief times action. At CTK we not only want to have faith in God, but in people.


Donnie Deutch (marketing guru) was interviewing Bernard Kerick (former NYC Police Commissioner) about the United States' "war on terror." He said, "If you had 200 billion dollars to spend on terrorist prevention, would you go to war in Iraq, or is there a better way to spend 200 billion dollars?" It was a "highest and best use" question. Both of them had to agree that the war in Iraq has done some good (notably, removing Saddam Hussein from power). But neither of them felt comfortable saying that it was the best use of 200 billion dollars imaginable.

There is a church with which I am familiar that recently went through an 80 million dollar building program. The church now has an auditorium that seats 7,000. So let me rephrase Deutch's question, "If you had 80 million dollars to spend on reaching lost people, would you spend it on a building, or is there a better way to spend 80 million dollars?"